CC BY
8Journal of Siberian Federal University. Engineering & Technologies, 2018, 11(4), 401-408
y^K 669.714.7
Further Developments
and Advantages Utilizing Slotted Anodes
Giovanni Campice*
T.T. Tomorrow Technology 18 Via Dell'artigianato, Due Carrare (PD), 35020, Italy
Received 25.01.2018, received in revised form 29.04.2018, accepted 19.05.2018
Slotted anodes have been used by smelters that require large size anodes. Being inter-anode separations, slots can be considered acting as expansion gaps to safely absorb the heat-induced expansions. The slots are helping to reduce the thermal stresses in the anodes and thus reducing the risk of cracking.
Approach to slots cut in the bottom surface of the anodes has nowadays changed and become extremely important, since they represent effective ways to escape gas continuously formed during Aluminium reduction process, thus reducing the accumulation of gas bubbles underneath the anodes. For this reason the use of slots in the anodes allows to reduce electrical cell resistance as well as to improve cell stability. Slots in the anodes therefore result in reduced electrical power consumption for the Aluminium production.
The depth of the slots is important to ensure that these benefits last throughout the entire life of the anodes ("full-life slots"), while slot shape, which determines the gas escape direction and related areas of influence, is also important to achieve further benefits in pot management. Cutting slots with reduced width reduces the amount of carbon removed from anodes when slots are cut. Narrow slots are improving specific Aluminum production per anode as well as prolonging anodes cycle time.
Keywords: slots, anode, aluminium reduction, slotting machine.
Citation: Campice G. Further developments and advantages utilizing slotted anodes, J. Sib. Fed. Univ. Eng. technol., 2018, 11(4), 401-408. DOI: 10.17516/1999-494X-0062.
© Siberian Federal University. All rights reserved
Corresponding author E-mail address: [email protected]
Разработка и преимущества использования анодов с пазами
Джованни Кампич
T.T. Tomorrow Technology Италия, 35020, Due Carrare (PD), Via Dell'artigianato, 18
Аноды с пазами используются на алюминиевых заводах, где требуются аноды большого размера. Можно считать, что пазы, являясь внутри анодными разделителями, действуют как тепловые зазоры, чтобы безопасно сглаживать расширения, вызванные изменением температуры. Пазы помогают уменьшить термические напряжения в анодах, тем самым снизив риск образования трещин.
Отношение к процедуре прорезки пазов в нижней части анодов сейчас изменилось и становится очень важным, т.к. пазы представляют эффективный способ, чтобы избежать непрерывное газообразование при электролизе алюминия, тем самым снижая накопление газовых пузырей на подошве анодов. По этой причине использование пазов в анодах позволяет снизить электросопротивление электролизера, а также повысить его стабильность. Таким образом, пазы в анодах приводят к снижению потребления электроэнергии при производстве алюминия. Глубина пазов важна, чтобы обеспечить все эти преимущества на протяжении всего срока службы анодов («пазы с полным сроком службы»), в то время как форма пазов, которая определяет направление отвода газа и связанные области влияния, также является важным параметром, чтобы достичь дополнительных преимуществ при управлении электролизером. При прорезке в анодах пазов с уменьшенной шириной снижается количество выбрасываемого углерода. Узкие пазы повышают удельное производство алюминия в расчете на один анод, а также продлевают срок службы анодов.
Ключевые слова: пазы, электролиз алюминия, машина для прорезки пазов.
Advantages from slots cut in baked anodes
T.T. Tomorrow Technology - the Engineering and manufacturing Company based in Italy - has achieved particular knowledge in anodes cutting/slotting technology. Internal R&D coupled with a long experience in designing and manufacturing dedicated equipment for anodes cutting, slotting and handling, were the basis to develop the last generation of Automatic Anodes Slots Cutting Machines.
Data collected by Tomorrow Technology from customers using slotted anodes give reference and values of the major operational benefits coming from the use of slotted anodes in Aluminium reduction process. The main advantages obtained by the implementation of slotted anodes are:
• reduced ACD distance (lower voltage drop of 50-100 mV);
• increased pot stability;
• better alumina dissolution;
• Improved current efficiency.
The related major benefits achieved by the use of slotted anodes with direct impact on the Aluminium smelter economics are:
• energy saving (ranging from 0.11 to 0.17 kWh/kg of produced Al);
• increased production (which may be computed as 1,3-1,7 % extra Al production, by increasing line current, since the saved energy is used to raise the line current to produce extra Aluminum).
In a different approach the alternatives to use gained voltage drop can be:
• reduced energy costs;
• increase of current so that the original energy input is maintained (again with extra Aluminum production).
More operation, safety and environmental benefits also follow after introducing the slotting technology.
In this scenario the depth of slot is important to ensure the benefits can last for the entire anode life (full life slots). Slot shapes are important to achieve further benefits in the pots management thanks to the control of the gas exit direction and related area of influence. The last generation of Anodes Slotting Machinescancut slots up to 450 mm depth.
Opportunity to reduce the slot width Uas also impertant conseqacnces on economics and managsmene oa potooo ms. The last generation of A nodes eietting Machines operate to cut slots with blades thicknest ef r2mm, in ism and 8 mm. Slnca tge weight of cerbon Cssl whe n anodes are slotted depends on blade thickness, the impact on cells performance and management is considerably in favour of stots (tur wit. thmnee Madoa which reduce tho canboo lart while slotting the anodes.
Narrow slots oUsw In rnacie Wgher rpecifin Aluminium proOuctlen os r anode as nell as tc prolong anodes cycle time. Fig. 1 shows actual slots geometrical parameters in baked anodes as last generation of Anodes Slotting Mnohines acliiovee.
SOot profited are very imjeortant Oo achieve benefits .en .ol management Tho Two Axis Dy namic SlotCstring (TADnC)-pntentedbh T.T. Tomorrow eouhnolohУ- appOied So the Antomhtic Slots Cutting MochmeaUows cutting 3 families of slot profiles, whose main characteristics are illustrated in Ffg. 2.
In r0e sltnation at Oig 2e tWo ^^c^ji^ ut nos neleeted by enndes is almosl ancontrolled.
The teaonal eonfiguratien oa sioSe ^111ii. .is. tiartsfrom a ]yre -rsieeSt-ble riot nedth,ondste o smaüer one with a ownsíant inclínatlon. This shape ef sloit allowt io near h preferential dieection of oeo e. The interrapted rli)ls profi.e (Fó0. f iO ckariy ^ovonlr gae from eating from one spee-fio sMo oso anodes.
Fig. 1. Narrow and deep slots are cut in baked anodes with last generation of Slotting Machine
ililiillilil
" N?
Fig. 2. Profiles of slots cut in baked anodes: a - straight slots (passing through the anode at the same depth); b -inclined slots; c - interrupted slot (when the slot is not cut through both anode ends)
Fig. 3. Anodes with interrupted slots in electrolysis pot with gas excaping towards the center
Patticiüae conciderations applyto conditions of interrupted slots in the pot with gas exit direction toward Zho cvntee of the pet (Fig. d).
As it is wvil knowe, aiumina is fed inho the bath during cell nporation and tl is important to have good alumrna digioiutiae. The anode gas aeteaand duozng ekcSnoZycis canbnuszd tp creatp ahurtrnlence in the aiuminv feedteg zone Zzt dts dissplotiop aid to roduoi oHumina aggtomeration.
^teri^ue^itad minis wti. ¡proper orientation are impothanh ta otvale ta goop tuibolptce ass anodes gas to the exient ntpourahle tn ínoreooa aZumino dip eoiution.
IntornzptgV slols are a meons lo f^c^^t^i^^te gishubMet nc^a^^^r^^t^^^j^oi^^ly tothi cintrolipv of the reduction cellto tipediti trisitolution of alumina. At the same time, the slots allow to operate the pots
at a lower pot noise and reduced pot voltage and therefore lower power consumption and higher current efficiency.
For the above reasons the interrupted slots are cut in the anodes in such a manner as to direct flow gas to the centreline of the reduction cell to expedite the dissolution of alumina. Facilitating the gas flow toward the center of the reduction cell gives operation advantages while increasing efficiencies.
Conveying gas in the centre of the pots results furthermore in less erosion to the reduction cell sidewalls, thus increasing cell life. In a pot with anodes without slots gas flow is from the anode, through the low resistant liquid bath almost in an uncontrolled way. Typically, this may lead to dangerous conditions at side walls of the pot, modifying thermal balance and disturbing the side ledge. Again implementation of interrupted slots in anodes to convoy gas toward the centreline of the pots results beneficial for the pot operations and cells life.
In addition to the economic benefits of the increased Aluminium production - directly resulting from the reduced ACD distance-, Smelters using Anodes Slots Cutting Machines are confirming that the slots give also the following operation improvements:
• increased pot stability;
• Improved current efficiency;
• better alumina dissolution;
• reduced (almost eliminated) number of anode effects (thus limination of harsh environment and risk operations);
• reduction of greenhouse gases and CO2 emissions.
Economic returns from slots in the anodes
Implementation of Anodes Slotting projects represents investments with short paybacks. Reduced supply lead-time from the contract award to the commencement of the production at client sites makes faster the commencement of the economic advantages. It is easy to simulate the economic results coming from the use of slotted anodes.
Typical payback calculations for the implementation of a new Anodes Slotting Line even in smelters with production capacity in the range of 250.000 - 300,000 tons per year of Aluminium show pay back between 7 and 12 months.
Since short pay backs (as we may consider if less than one year) are usually more difficult to happen at "small" production capacities, above mentioned results represent indeed a considerably profitable investment starting also from smelters whose production capacity is not so big. Smelters with bigger production capacities are enjoying further positive scale factors.
In this scenario the slot height has a direct impact on specific benefits, since their final amount depends directly on the slot height. The pay back time of the investment is shortened by the higher slots height.
This is the leading point for smelters when moving from the (short and wide) slots formed in the green anodes to the higher and narrower slots cut after anodes are baked.
Recognised benchmark is now to have slots whose height allows to prolong their positive effects during the entire anodes life. Slots width (often said "thickness") is, as a matter of facts, a measure of the carbon "lost" (i.e. not going to the pots). Reduction of slot width (or thickness), therefore, leads
to maximize productivity of the cells, while prolonging anodes cycle time. With last generation of Anodes Slotting Machines it is now possible to cut slots in baked anodes up to 450 mm depth with 8 mm width only. Fig. 4 shows one of the last generation Anodes Slotting Machine while cutting slots 450 mm heiggn and 8 mm width.
The opportunity to cut baked anodon wilh dnepee end neenower slota (450 mm depfh and 8 mm width, at a4ste mentionedt aw s matton of facte ai oprnmg new steneeios snd pee.ents new opjcortunities for investmenissnstifiedbnhiyhepgnomtcreiurns.
Several catculotsons of She Return ofOnveoiment of ehe p4 >s IscS ^nrin>g of new investment for new Asodes lll<s>tri:il^ Machinei t:o teptase former slotilngequinmenr (ovsn ie itUl wn working conditions) glee evidence of the high gaofiiobiiity eg tPest choiceo. TSis prioe merearing isend of Aluminium ae LME (os ofDecnmber 201d) .s aoegnifymg tot economic reton from abovo mnntioned invest menti.
Fig. 5 slrowe ae^o^^^ etotted. witit new^ ang nartow sMs byfors and gftoo being in tlse jeot.
Fig. 4. Last generation ofAutomutic Anodes Slotting Machine in operation
Fig. 5. Slottedanodes atend of life and beforebeingputin operation
Alternatives analysis (formed slots vs. cut slots)
Traditionally there are two methods of introducing slots into anodes:
• forming the slots in the green anodes by means of special moulds in the anodes vibro compactor;
• cutting slots in the anodes after the baking process.
The first method - while only apparently cheaper - results in increased waste of anodes for unsatisfactory quality before they they may reach the cells properly and suffers of intrinsic limits in dimensions (short and wide slots reduce current density and limit slot life in the cells) and anodes characteristics (lower and non-homogeneous physical parameters).
The second method (i.e. cutting slots in the anodes after the baking process) allows overpassing the limits and the cons of the slots formed in the green anodes.
Often Anodes Slotting Machines have been installed where previously slots were formed in the green anodes; comparing with slots cut in baked anodes, the following key points may be summarized in the Table below.
It is easy to calculate how the weight of carbon lost with slots formed in green anodes is much higher than carbon lost when anodes are slotted after baking. If we compare the same slots height, the carbon lost when slots are formed at the green phase may be up to 3 times the amount which is lost cutting slots in baked anodes; the impact on cell performance and management is therefore considerably in favour of slots cut in baked anodes, which furthermore are not suffering any density issue. Slots cut in baked anodes are helping to reduce carbon consumption if compared with anodes slotted while green, since typical disadvantages of slotted green anodes are avoided; particularly CO and CO2 attack in slotted green anodes is higher due to reduced apparent density and increased air permeability.
Conclusions
Short pay back quickly starts after short delivery time and smooth implementation where the last generation of Automatic Anodes Slotting Machines manufactured by T.T. Tomorrow Technology are in operation.
Slots are successfully cut in baked anodes up to 450 mm depth and 12, 10 or 8 mm width.
In addition to the very high economic benefits of increased Aluminium production, smelters using Anodes Slots Cutting Machines are gaining further operational advantages.
Table. Comparison of slots formed in green anodes vs. slots cut in baked anodes
Slots formed in green anodes (typical) Slots cut in baked anodes
Orientation Tied to anodes exit direction from the mold No limitation
Slot width 25-40 mm (at base) to 10-20 mm (at top) 12-10-8 mm (constant)
Slot height 150-300 mm Up to 450 mm
Anode density Not homogeneous (affected by plates to form slots), lower Higher, homogeneous (not affected by slots)
We can conclude that the implementation of anode slotting technology allows paybacks ranging within short periods, even for smelters with smaller production capacity. It results in increased production capacity and minimizes production costs; while paying importance to safeguarding energy energy resources, it leads to reducing environmental impact.
The opportunity to cut slots with interrupted profile (as to forward released gas toward the centre of the pots), to increase slot depth and reduce the width is justifying new investments to replace old slotting equipment already in operation; appraisals of that are considering the benefits of deeper and narrower slots give evidence of high profitability even in case of replacement of existing equipment in operation at lower performances level.
The article is based on the paper presented at the IX International Congress "Non-ferrous metals and minerals-2017".
