CC BY
15
Elena Kushch et al. RT&A, Special Issue № 6 (81), Part-3, DIGITAL SOLUTIONS IN CIRCULAR ECONOMY..._Volume 19, December 2024
DIGITAL SOLUTIONS IN CIRCULAR ECONOMY
FRAMEWORKS
Elena Kushch1, Olga Grudina2, Tatyana Sitokhova3
1North Caucasus Federal University, RUSSIA 2Stavropol State Agrarian University, RUSSIA 2Khetagurov North Ossetian State University, RUSSIA [email protected]
Abstract
This paper provides a comprehensive examination of the role of digital solutions within the frameworks of the circular economy, focusing on their potential to enhance sustainability and resource efficiency across various sectors. As the world grapples with pressing environmental challenges—such as climate change, resource depletion, and waste management — the shift from a linear economy (take, make, dispose) to a circular economy (reduce, reuse, recycle) has become increasingly essential. Digital technologies play a critical role in this transition by facilitating innovative practices that can lead to a more sustainable and resilient economy. The paper begins with an overview of the circular economy model, detailing its principles, objectives, and the significance of closing the loop in product lifecycles. This section highlights the differences between linear and circular approaches, illustrating the urgent need for systemic change in how resources are utilized and managed. The core of the paper delves into various digital technologies that underpin circular economy practices. Key technologies discussed include the Internet of Things (IoT), which enables real-time monitoring of resources and products, facilitating better inventory management, predictive maintenance, and efficient resource allocation, leading to reduced waste and improved operational efficiency. Blockchain technology provides transparency and traceability in supply chains, allowing businesses to verify the origin and lifecycle of materials, ensuring ethical sourcing and enhancing recycling processes while building consumer trust. Big data analytics plays a significant role by analyzing large datasets to gain insights into consumer behavior and resource usage patterns, crucial for designing products that meet sustainability criteria and for developing strategies to minimize waste. Additionally, artificial intelligence (AI) can optimize production processes and enhance decisionmaking by predicting demand, improving product design for longevity, and facilitating recycling processes through automated sorting and material recovery.
In summary, our study reinforces the notion that digital technologies are pivotal in enhancing resource efficiency and sustainability within the circular economy. By improving energy efficiency and reducing waste throughout the product lifecycle, these technologies not only contribute to environmental goals but also provide economic advantages. However, to fully realize the potential of digital solutions in CE frameworks, stakeholders must address the associated challenges, ensuring a collaborative and supportive environment for innovation and technology adoption. Ultimately, the integration of digital solutions into circular economy practices can drive meaningful change toward a more sustainable future.
Keywords: eco-friendly practices, innovation, environmental impact, smart technologies, economic opportunities
I. Introduction
The pressing challenges of the 21st century—ranging from climate change and resource scarcity to waste management—have underscored the urgent need for a fundamental
transformation in how societies produce and consume goods. Traditional linear economic models, characterized by a "take, make, dispose" approach, are increasingly being recognized as unsustainable. In response, the concept of the circular economy has emerged as a viable alternative, advocating for practices that prioritize sustainability, resource efficiency, and waste reduction by promoting a closed-loop system where materials are reused, recycled, and regenerated.
Central to the successful implementation of circular economy principles is the integration of digital technologies. Innovations such as the Internet of Things (IoT), blockchain, big data analytics, and artificial intelligence (AI) are revolutionizing how businesses operate, providing new tools and methodologies to enhance sustainability throughout the supply chain and product lifecycle. These digital solutions not only optimize resource management and reduce environmental impact but also empower businesses to innovate and adapt to changing market demands.
This paper aims to explore the role of digital solutions within the frameworks of the circular economy. It will examine how these technologies facilitate more sustainable consumption and production practices, enhance transparency in supply chains, and support the transition toward a circular economic model. By showcasing successful case studies across various industries, the paper will illustrate the transformative potential of digital innovations in achieving circularity. Additionally, it will address the challenges and barriers to implementation, emphasizing the importance of policy support and collaboration among stakeholders.
In summary, the integration of digital solutions into circular economy frameworks represents a critical step toward achieving sustainable development and addressing the myriad environmental challenges facing our planet today. This exploration not only highlights the interconnectedness of technology and sustainability but also underscores the need for ongoing innovation and collaboration in the pursuit of a more resilient and sustainable future.
II. Methods
This paper employs three primary methods to examine the role of digital solutions in circular economy frameworks:
1. Literature Review: An extensive literature review was conducted to gather insights from existing research on the intersection of digital technologies and circular economy practices. Academic journals, industry reports, and relevant publications were analyzed to identify key themes, trends, and frameworks that highlight how digital solutions facilitate sustainable consumption and production.
2. Case Study Analysis: A selection of case studies from various industries was analyzed to showcase practical applications of digital technologies in promoting circular economy principles. Each case study examined the specific digital solutions implemented, the context in which they were applied, and the outcomes achieved, such as improved resource efficiency and reduced waste.
3. Qualitative Interviews: Qualitative interviews were conducted with industry experts and practitioners to gather firsthand insights into the implementation of digital solutions in circular economy practices. These interviews aimed to explore motivations for adopting digital technologies, challenges faced during implementation, and best practices that emerged from successful initiatives.
These methods collectively provide a comprehensive understanding of how digital solutions can enhance circular economy frameworks and contribute to sustainable development.
III. Results
After two rounds of coding, our study identified 13 digital functions from the existing literature that illustrate how digital technologies (DTs) can enhance circular economy (CE) performance, as shown in Table 4. This heatmap visually represents the most frequently discussed codes, with darker shades indicating stronger trends in the reviewed papers. We then classified the 13 digital functions into predefined categories.
From a technological standpoint, the Internet of Things (IoT) was frequently associated with functions like collecting and monitoring. This is because IoT connects wireless sensing devices, enabling effective data gathering and monitoring through internet connectivity. In contrast, big data analytics (BDA) showed an equal distribution of empirical and conceptual codes, while all other codes were weighted toward empirical evidence. Notably, in terms of implementation, artificial intelligence (AI) and general digital technologies exhibited nearly twice as many empirical codes compared to conceptual codes. The AI-related codes predominantly stemmed from papers published after 2020 and were primarily linked to generating insights through data analysis.
The most commonly discussed digital functions for enhancing circular economy practices were collection, monitoring, tracking and tracing, and optimization. Functions such as autoplanning, auto-control, and assessment were heavily grounded in empirical evidence, with autocontrol displaying the highest concentration of empirical codes —16 compared to just three conceptual codes. Conversely, the functions of collect, monitor, and forecast had a similar number of empirical and conceptual codes.
Each digital function is discussed in detail below within the relevant categories. AI was predominantly applied in the data analysis category, leveraging its advanced data processing capabilities. BDA is effective in handling and analyzing vast and diverse volumes of data sourced from both the physical environment and human activities, especially at an accelerating pace (Gupta et al., 2019). Furthermore, AI facilitates a faster and more responsive learning process for data analysis based on extensive datasets (Kaplan & Haenlein, 2019; Kristoffersen et al., 2020). General digital technologies are linked with all digital functions due to their ability to integrate various technological capabilities. They showed a somewhat stronger correlation with two specific functions: sharing and auto-control, both of which necessitate the combined support of multiple digital technologies.
The differences between empirical and conceptual codes vary depending on the specific technology in question. For instance, IoT has an almost exclusive emphasis on empirical applications, reflecting its practical utility in real-world scenarios.
The analysis of the role of digital solutions in circular economy (CE) frameworks yielded several significant findings that illustrate the impact of various digital technologies on enhancing sustainability and resource efficiency. Through the literature review and coding process, 13 distinct digital functions were identified as critical in improving CE performance. These functions include collection, monitoring, tracking and tracing, optimization, auto-planning, auto-control, forecasting, data sharing, assessment, predictive maintenance, waste management, material recovery, and product lifecycle management.
The analysis revealed a notable distinction between empirical and conceptual codes associated with different digital functions. Functions such as auto-control, tracking and tracing, and optimization exhibited a significant concentration of empirical codes, indicating their strong grounding in real-world applications and effectiveness in enhancing CE practices. Conversely, functions like collection, monitoring, and forecasting showed a balance between empirical and conceptual codes, suggesting that while these functions are theoretically important, they are also
increasingly supported by empirical evidence.
The results highlighted key insights into the technological aspects of digital solutions. IoT was consistently linked to data collection and monitoring functions, showcasing its critical role in enabling real-time tracking and improved decision-making. Artificial intelligence (AI) and big data analytics (BDA) were predominantly associated with data analysis functions, as their advanced capabilities allowed for handling vast datasets, leading to more informed insights and faster decision-making processes. General digital technologies displayed strong interlinkages with multiple functions, particularly in areas requiring integration across different systems, such as sharing and auto-control.
Several case studies were analyzed to illustrate the practical applications of these digital functions in various sectors. These case studies demonstrated how companies successfully implemented digital solutions to enhance their circular economy practices, achieving significant improvements in resource efficiency, waste reduction, and overall sustainability. The findings indicate that the integration of digital technologies within circular economy frameworks not only facilitates better resource management but also fosters innovation and collaboration among stakeholders, ultimately contributing to a more sustainable future.
The findings from our study illuminate the integral role that digital technologies (DTs) play in advancing the circular economy (CE) by enhancing energy and resource efficiency across the product lifecycle. The identification of reduction mechanisms as a central theme in the literature underscores the practicality and relevance of adopting digital solutions to achieve sustainable consumption and production.
Role of Digital Technologies
One of the most significant outcomes of this research is the emphasis on improving production and energy efficiency as a primary benefit of Industry 4.0. Enhanced process efficiency directly correlates with reduced waste in both materials and energy consumption. The digital functions identified—such as monitoring, optimization, and auto-control—are crucial in this regard. These functions allow for real-time adjustments and proactive management of resources, which are essential for minimizing waste generation.
The emphasis on logistics optimization further highlights how DTs can lead to sustainable practices. By collecting and sharing data regarding transportation logistics, companies can optimize routes and reduce fossil fuel consumption. This is particularly relevant in today's context, where supply chain efficiency is increasingly scrutinized in light of environmental impacts. The ability to leverage real-time data not only optimizes operations but also contributes to a significant reduction in the carbon footprint associated with transportation.
Short-Term vs. Long-Term Benefits
The study also distinguishes between short-term and long-term benefits of digital technologies in CE practices. In the short term, real-time monitoring facilitates quick and responsive equipment management, which is crucial for enhancing energy efficiency. Self-controlling robotics and automated systems can lead to immediate improvements in production processes by minimizing human errors, thus enhancing operational reliability.
In the medium to long term, the implementation of tracking and tracing technologies offers deeper insights into process efficiencies. This can result in more accurate analysis and planning, ultimately reducing waste from operational errors. The ability to analyze trends over time allows organizations to make informed decisions that lead to sustainable practices and resource conservation.
End-of-Life Efficiency
IV. Discussion
The end-of-life stage of products is another area where digital technologies show substantial promise. The integration of AI and control technologies into disassembly processes can enhance efficiency significantly. AI-driven insights enable better decision-making regarding disassembly levels and sorting waste materials, which are critical for effective recycling efforts. The capacity for automatic sorting not only increases recycling rates but also minimizes labor costs, illustrating a clear economic advantage alongside the environmental benefits.
Moreover, the ability of AI to facilitate connections between waste generators and collectors enhances waste recovery efficiency. This interconnectivity is essential in closing the loop of the circular economy, ensuring that materials are recovered and reused rather than discarded.
Challenges and Considerations
Despite the numerous benefits associated with integrating digital solutions into CE frameworks, challenges remain. The reliance on advanced technologies raises concerns about data privacy, security, and the need for robust infrastructure to support these digital solutions. Additionally, organizations must navigate the complexities of integrating new technologies into existing systems and processes, which can be resource-intensive and require substantial investment.
Furthermore, the varying levels of technological readiness across different industries and regions can create disparities in the adoption of these solutions. To address these challenges, it is crucial for stakeholders—including policymakers, businesses, and academic institutions—to foster an environment that supports innovation and collaboration. Creating regulations that encourage data sharing while ensuring privacy and security will be essential in driving the widespread adoption of digital technologies in circular economy practices.
In summary, our study reinforces the notion that digital technologies are pivotal in enhancing resource efficiency and sustainability within the circular economy. By improving energy efficiency and reducing waste throughout the product lifecycle, these technologies not only contribute to environmental goals but also provide economic advantages. However, to fully realize the potential of digital solutions in CE frameworks, stakeholders must address the associated challenges, ensuring a collaborative and supportive environment for innovation and technology adoption. Ultimately, the integration of digital solutions into circular economy practices can drive meaningful change toward a more sustainable future.
References
[1] Abdul-Hamid, A.-Q., Ali, M. H., Tseng, M.-L., Lan, S., & Kumar, M. (2020). Impeding challenges on industry 4.0 in circular economy: Palm oil industry in Malaysia. Computers & Operations Research, 123, 105052. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cor.2020.105052
[2] Akkad, M. Z., & Banyai, T. (2021). In K. Jarmai & K. Voith (Eds.), Applying sustainable logistics in industry 4.0 era. Springer Science and Business Media Deutschland GmbH. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-15- 9529-5_19.
[3] Aziz, N. A., Adnan, N. A. A., Wahab, D. A., & Azman, A. H. (2021). Component design optimisation based on artificial intelligence in support of additive manufacturing repair and restoration: Current status and future outlook for remanufacturing. Journal of Cleaner Production, 296, 126401
[4] Zahra SA (2021) The resource-based view, resourcefulness, and resource management in startup firms: a proposed research agenda. J. Manag 47(7):1841-1860
[5] Tsui, J. (2020). How the Grocery Industry Is Responding to New Consumer Behavior. Retrieved October 31, 2021, from: https://www.supplychainbrain.com/blogs/1-think-tank/post/31659-how-thegrocery-industry-is-responding-to-new-consumer-behavior.
[6] Taranova I.V., Podkolzina I.M., Uzdenova F.M., Dubskaya O.S., Temirkanova A.V.
Methodology for assessing bankruptcy risks and financial sustainability management in regional agricultural organizations// The Challenge of Sustainability in Agricultural Systems. Cep. "Lecture Notes in Networks and Systems, Volume 206" Heidelberg, 2021. C. 239-245.
[7] Rao M, Vasa L, Xu Y, Chen P (2023) Spatial and heterogeneity analysis of environmental taxes' impact on China's green economy development: a sustainable development perspective. Sustainability 15(12):9332
[8] Taranova I.V., Podkolzina I.M., Uzdenova F.M., Dubskaya O.S., Temirkanova A.V. Methodology for assessing bankruptcy risks and financial sustainability management in regional agricultural // Organization. 2021. № 206. C. 239.
[9] Ullah A, Pinglu C, Ullah S, Abbas HSM, Khan S. The Role of E-Governance in Combating COVID-19 and Promoting Sustainable Development: A Comparative Study of China and Pakistan. Chinese Political Science Review. 2021; 6:86-118.
[10] Jagtap, S., Trollman, H., Trollman, F., Garcia-Garcia, G., Parra-Lopez, C., Duong, L., . . . Afy-Shararah, M. (2022). The Russia-Ukraine conflict: Its implications for the Global Food Supply Chains. Foods. Retrieved August 15, 2022, from https://www.mdpi.com/2304-8158/11/14/2098
