CC BY
43IПЕДАГОГ1КА I та медико_б'олог'чн'
- - проблеми ф1зичного
виховання i спорту _
ПСИХОЛОГ1Я
The relation between service quality of sports camps and elite athletes' satisfaction of the national teams' freestyle & Greco-Roman wrestling
Goharrostami Hamid Reza1, Hodhodi Abkenari Behnam2, Eftekhari Ozra3, Khodayari Abbas4
1Associate Professor at University of Guilan, Iran Master Student of Sport Management Islamic Azad University Karaj, Iran 3Master in Sport Management, University of Shomal, Iran 4Associate Professor at Islamic Azad University of Karaj, Iran
Abstract:
Purpose: One of the most important factors influencing satisfaction of athletes in sports camps is the quality of services provided therefore. The main objective of this study is investigation of relation between service quality and elite athletes' satisfaction in free style and Greco Roman wrestling national teams. Material: Methodology of the research was descriptive correlation, fulfilled as a field study. The statistical population included all athletes invited and presented in the national camps of wrestling (free and Greco Roman wrestling) in different ranges of ages in 1993 and the sample size is equal to the statistical population (N=160). The data collection tool was a questionnaire made by the researcher. To analyze the data, descriptive and inferential statistics as Kolmogorov-Smirnov, Kruskal-Wallis, Friedman,
Binominal test and Regression calculated by SPSS (Statistical package for social science) V.22 are used. The findings showed that there was a significant relation between service quality variables and the athletes' satisfaction. In addition, according to Friedman test, there is not a significant difference in the mean of ranks in service quality variables of training camps. Results The results of binominal test showed that the quality of services in the training camps left much to be desired. The Demography results indicated that the athletes presented in the camps during longer periods were more satisfied with quality of services provided. Conclusion: According to results, it can be said that, one of the most important factors influencing on satisfaction of athletes in Sports camps, was quality of provided service. Therefore it is important to regard satisfaction of athletes as an essential issue in order to find the gaps and provide proper services.
Keywords: quality of services, sports camps, satisfaction of athletes, wrestling.
Гохарростами Хамид Реза, Ходходи Абке-нари Бехнам, Ефтекхари Озра, Кходаяри Аббас. Соотношение между качеством предоставляемых услуг в спортивных лагерях и удовлетворением элитных спортсменов национальных команд вольного стиля и греко-римской борьбы. Цель: Одним из наиболее важных факторов, влияющих на удовлетворенность спортсменов в спортивных лагерях является качество предоставляемых услуг. Основной целью данного исследования является изучение взаимосвязи между качеством предоставляемых услуг и удовлетворенностью элитных спортсменов по вольной и греко-римской борьбе национальных сборных команд Ирана. Материал: Методика исследования включала сравнительный анализ описательного характера, выполненный в виде обследования на местах. Статистическая совокупность включала всех спортсменов, приглашенных и представленных в национальных лагерях борьбы (вольной и греко-римской) в разных диапазонах возрастов (от рождения в 1993 году). Выборка составила 160 спортсменов (n = 160). Инструментом исследования был сбор данных по опроснику, подготовленного исследователем. Для анализа данных использовались различные критерии (Колмогорова-Смирнова, Крускала-Уоллиса, тест Фридмана, биноминальные уравнения и уравнения регрессии), рассчитанные с помощью SPSS (статистический пакет для социальных наук) V.22. Результаты: исследования показали, что существует значимая связь между переменными качества предоставляемых услуг и удовлетворенностью спортсменов. Кроме того, согласно тесту Фридмана, не обнаружено значительных различий в среднем ранге в переменных качества обслуживания учебно-тренировочных сборов. Результаты биноминального теста показали, что качество услуг в учебных лагерях оставляет желать лучшего. Демографические результаты показали, что спортсмены, представленные в лагерях в течение более длительных периодов, были более удовлетворены качеством предоставляемых услуг. Выводы: результаты показывают, что одним из наиболее важных факторов, влияющих на удовлетворение спортсменов в спортивных лагерях, было качество предоставляемых услуг. Поэтому важно рассматривать удовлетворение спортсменов в качестве важного вопроса, с тем чтобы найти пробелы и предоставить соответствующие услуги.
качество услуг, спортивные лагеря, удовлетворение спортсменов, борьба.
Гохарростамi Хамщ Реза, Ходходi Абкенарi Бехнам, Ефтекхарi Озра, Кходаярi Аббас. Сшввщношення мiж ямстю послуг, що надаються в спортивних таборах i задоволенням елггних спортсмешв нацюнальних команд вшьного стилю i греко-рим-ськоТ боротьби. Мета: Одним з най-бтьш важливих факторiв, що впливають на задоволенють спортсмешв у спортивних таборах е якють послуг. Основною метою даного дослщження е ви-вчення взаемозв'язку мiж якютю послуг, що надаються i задоволенютю елтих спортсмешв з втьноТ та греко-римськоТ боротьби нацюнальних збiрних команд 1рану. Матерал: Методика дослщження включала порiвняльний аналiз описово-го характеру, виконаний у виглядi обсте-ження на мюцях. Статистична сукупнють включала вах спортсмешв, запрошених i представлених в нацюнальних таборах боротьби (втьноТ i греко-римськоТ) в рiзних дiапазонах вку (вщ народження у 1993 роц^. Вибiрка склала 1б0 спортсмешв (n = 160). 1нструментом дослщження був збiр даних за опитувальником, пщ-готовленого дослщником. Для аналiзу даних використовувалися рiзнi критерп (Колмогорова-Смирнова, Круськала-Уоллюа, тест Фрщмана, бЫомшальш рiвняння i рiвняння регресп), розраховаш за допомогою SPSS (статистичний пакет для со^альних наук) V.22. Результати: дослщження показали, що юнуе значу-щий зв'язок мiж змЫними якост послуг, що надаються i задоволенютю спортсмешв. ^м того, зпдно з тестом Фрiдмана, не виявлено значних вщмЫностей в се-редньому ранзi в змiнних якост обслуго-вування навчально-тренувальних зборiв. Результати бромного тесту показали, що якють послуг в навчальних таборах залишае бажати кращого. Демографiч-нi результати показали, що спортсмени, представлен в таборах протягом бтьш тривалих пер^в, були бiльш задово-ленi якютю послуг, що надаються. Ви-сновки: результати показують, що одним з найбтьш важливих факторiв, що впливають на задоволення спортсмешв у спортивних таборах, була якють послуг, що надаються. Тому важливо розглядати задоволення спортсмешв в якост важли-вого питання, з тим щоб знайти прогали-ни i надати вщповщш послуги.
яюсть послуг, спортивнi табори, задоволення спортсмешв, боротьба.
Introduction
Although rather long time has passed from bringing up the issue of the quality of services and methods relating to its evaluation and measurement, considering the issue has © Goharrostami Hamid Reza, Hodhodi Abkenari Behnam, Eftekhari Ozra, Khodayari Abbas, 2016 doi:10.15561/18189172.2016.0408
been increasing and its role has gained a great importance due to growing significance of services in the economies of all countries [2]. A number of studies show that during last two decades, interest towards the quality of services has also moved to sport industry [27]. Sport organizations possess special service features which differentiate them
32016 II
from the other service organizations including banks or insurance companies. The first feature is that the cost of sport and recreational activities are optional. The second feature implies that usually, the consumer is attracted by the sport organizations during his/her free time; and the third one is that among the activities of sports organizations, there exist emotional investments such as supporting a team, belonging to a sport club and the health improvement. Probably, these factors induce more expectations from sports organizations rather than service providers of the other companies. Therefore, the different nature of services relative to products and the special features of sport industry cause more contemplation to be focused on understanding the expectations of the consumers of sports organizations and the distance between the expectations and perceptions [23]. Satisfaction of the athletes in sports camps is an important factor of their retention, stability of sports organizations and the success of that organization. Satisfaction makes the athletes to remain in sport camps. On the one hand, quality of the services in sports industry causes the society to gain achievements regarding economy, culture, knowledge bases and social demands [6]. Awareness about the methods of satisfying athletes' needs leads to satisfaction of them and hence, brings balance, mental comfort and efficiency. Although getting general knowledge about all dimensions of athletes' satisfaction in a direct and accurate manner is really difficult, awareness of these behavioral aspects confute the trainers to take a fundamental step towards mental maintenance and retention of the athletes by teaching and practicing good behaviors [24]. If there is no proper plan for establishment of the camps and dispatching the athletes to sport camps, surely a great deal of untargeted costs, physical and behavioral insecurities and many other problems will appear and cause deviation from sport goals. Provision and preparation of sport equipment, instruments and facilities and also, proper usage of them are some abilities which can help the sport executive managers to attract trainers and athletes to athletic activities and exercises and to reach the goals. Possessing accurate knowledge about modern facilities, equipment and technologies can assist managers to provide opportunities for consultation; reduce unnecessary costs and use standard equipment [14]. According to the important influence of the quality of sport camps on the triumph of athletes, there exists a necessity in conducting the present study in order to consider the least needs of the athletes in sport camps and to help in establishment of regular and high-quality camps. In the following, a number of the research conducted on this filed will be mentioned.
Mirzayi (2006) has conducted a research titled "the comparison of the profile of behavioral modes of wrestlers in junior and senior national teams in two fields of freestyle and Greco Roman wrestling". In this research, he has concluded that quality of sport camps rendered rather significant impact on athletes' satisfaction. Akhlaghi (2011) identified and compared the levels of athletes' satisfaction (Freestyle and Greco
Roman wrestlers) in the clubs of Khoozestan Province in terms of three issues (performance of managers, service and facility provisioning and performance in public). He showed that the wrestlers were not satisfied with these three kinds of services. According to Shonk (2008), the quality of services in sports camps includes the quality of accessibility, quality of sport association, quality of the domicile and quality of the champions. Huyen (2011) has conducted a research, titled "Investigation of the Consumers' Satisfaction in Kukula Body-Building Club"; and he has found that the consumers are generally satisfied with the services provided by the club. Nicholas et all (2013) has conducted a research, titled "The Role of Quality of Services and Satisfaction in Predicting the Behavioral Goals of the Spectators in Professional Football"; they have found that the quality of services influences on level of satisfaction, and that these two factors rendered great impact on behavioral intentions.
Purpose. One of the most important factors influencing on satisfaction of athletes in sports camps is the quality of services provided therefore. The main objective of this study is the investigation of relation between service quality and elite athletes' satisfaction in free and Greco Roman wrestling national teams.
Material and Methods
Participants. The statistical population (160 athletes) includes all the invited athletes who are present in national camps of freestyle and Greco Roman wrestling; these athletes were selected from different age categories. The sample population is equal to the statistical population (n=160).
Research Design. The current research was based on a descriptive-correlational research project and shall be regarded as an applied one, considering the purpose which was accomplished on the basis of surveys and field study. The data were collected in two stages; the first with the help of questionnaire, prepared as a tool for collecting the data. At the second stage, the questionnaires were reviewed and verified by 7 experienced trainers in the field of sport management; the stability level of it was defined by Cronbach's alpha coefficients, and then they were used. The questionnaire was divided into two parts (quality of services and athletes' satisfaction). The first part is designed to collect the information from respondents and it consists of 8 questions. The second part includes 40 questions which are completed by variables of service quality with 35 items and by variables of athletes' satisfaction with 5 items. Therefore, 160 questionnaires have been distributed, collected and analyzed in order to organize data analysis and fulfill it..
Statistical Analysis. To analyze and investigate the data, descriptive statistics has been used to describe the variables, items and indices. At the level of inferential statistics, Kruskal-Wallis, Binomial, Regression and Kolmogorov-Smirnov are performed to investigate the normality of the data. According to lack of normality in the data, Spearman Correlational Coefficient is used to study the relationship between the variables.
I nEflArOHKA I Ta MeflMK0"6i0^0riHHi
- - npoó^eMM ^i3MHHoro
BMXoBaHHA i cnopTy _
ncMxoflorm
Results of the research
Personal characteristics of respondents are briefly presented in Table 1.
After performing Kolmogorov-Smirnov test (KS) and making sure about non-normal distribution of the data (P<0.05), Friedman test has been executed. The results of this test, presented in Table 2, showed that there were no significant differentiation between average rank of the variables of dimensions of service quality in sport camps; because significance level equals to P<0.10 which is higher that error level (P<0.05). In other words, there is no significant differentiation between dimensions of service quality in sport camps. According to these results, Quality of the Trainer and Quality of Non-Sport Equipment have gained the highest and the lowest average ranks, respectively.
Moreover, the result, obtained through investigation of correlation between dimensions of service quality is sport camps and athletes' satisfaction are presented in Table 3.
The results of correlation analysis show that there is a positive and significant relationship between dimensions
of service quality in sport camps (except in dimension of discipline and regularity, and dimension of non-sport equipment) and athletes' satisfaction. In order to determine which one of these 7 dimensions of service quality play the most important role in predicting the athletes' satisfaction and which one of them is the better determinant for the variance of consumers' satisfaction, a step-by-step multivariable regression analysis has been performed. The data show that in the first step, the dimension of interactive quality of service quality in entered into regression model to explain the level of athletes' satisfaction variance; also, 63% of the variances are explained solely. At the second step, the dimension of exercise plan is integrated into the model and it brings correlational coefficient up to 0.73% and changes the coefficient of determination from 0.53 to 0.55. At the third step, the dimension of non-sport equipment is accompanied by the model and the three dimensions of interactive quality, exercise plan and non-sport equipment can explain 74% of the variance of athletes' satisfaction, simultaneously. At the fourth step, correlational coefficient and the coefficient of
Table 1. Description of Personal Characteristics of Respondents
Variable Count Percentage Variable Count Percentage
Under 20 years 57 34/4 Sport GRECO 73 47/2
Age 21 to 25 years 42 29/3 Wrestling 87 52/8
26 years and over 61 36/3 Attending Less than 5 times 24 12/4
Under 5 years 29 16/7 courses 6 to 10 spring 41 24/6
Sports 6 to 10 years 40 24/4 and 11 to 15 spring 39 22/8
experience 11 to 15 years 48 29/6 sports 16 to 20 spring 34 20/4
15 years and over 43 28/3 camp Over 20 times 32 19/8
Table 2. Results of Friedman Test and the Conditions of Distribution of the Data Regarding Research Variables Obtained by Kolmogorov-Smirnov Test
Quality of Services_Average Rating_SD_Sig_Chi_Df_K-S
Sports equipment 2/21 0/45 2/10 non Sports equipment 2/20 0/39 1/54 Quality of coach 2/37 0/42 2/22 Interaction of Quality 2/20 0/41 0/10 10/6 6 1/95 Workout program 2/29 0/38 1/92 Discipline 2/35 0/58 1/37 extra service_2/32_0/52_2/43
Table 3. Matrix of Spearman Correlation between Dimensions of Service Quality in Sport Camps and Athletes' Satisfaction
Variable
Quality of Workout extra . .. Sports Correlation non Sports
Discipline
t l coach program service equipment of Quality equipment statistical
indicators_
R 0/042 **0/405 **0/282 **-0/045 **0/252 **0/623 0/001
Sig 0/001 0/001 0/001 0/49 0/001 0/001 0/99
; Significant at P<0.001
32016 II
determination reach to 0.75 and 0.56, respectively, due to entrance of the dimension of extra services. Regression analysis has been terminated at the fourth step and three dimensions of sport equipment, quality of the trainer and discipline have been removed from the regression model. Accordingly, 56% of variance of the wrestlers' satisfaction is derived from the four dimensions of interactive quality, exercise plan, non-sport equipment and extra services.
According to the report presented in Table 4, significance level of R is below 0.05 during the first step. Therefore, the first model is verified. In the second, third and fourth models also, level significance is below 0.05 and accordingly, the second, third and fourth models are verified, too.
In model 1, the dimension of interactive quality is integrated into regression model; Standard Beta is set at 0.662 which is significant. In model 2, exercise plan is added to the model, in addition to interactive quality; here, Standard Beta is decreased to 0.464. In model 3, non-sport equipment is added to the model in addition to interactive quality and exercise plan; here, Standard Beta is calculated as -0.158. In model 4, extra service is added to the model in addition to interactive quality, exercise plan and non-sport equipment; here, Standard Beta is calculated as -0.128. The negativity of Standard Betas in the third and fourth models shows that in the presence of the first and the second variables (interactive quality and exercise plan) which have positive Standard Betas, the third and fourth models (non-sport equipment and extra services) have no significant influence on explanation of variance level of athletes' satisfaction. Also, the Beta of
all the four models are significant (sig < 0.05).
According to the fact that the distribution of the data is not normal, Binomial test has been executed in order to investigate the condition (good, moderate, weak) of the dimensions of service quality and athletes' satisfaction with cut point of 3.66 and a five-valued spectrum of Likert. Average below 2.33 shows weak condition; average between 2.34 and 3.66 shows moderate condition and average higher than 3.66 shows good condition.
As we can see in Table 5, the average of all questions are below the good level and sport services are not in desirable mode; therefore, we use the findings presented in Table 2 with cut point of 1.33 to calculate how many of the members in sample population consider the dimensions of service quality in the range of moderate to weak. The results of Binomial test with cut point of 1.33 are presented in Table 6.
As we can see in Table 6, 101 members of the sample population believe that the conditions of dimension of sport equipment is below moderate (weak) and 59 members of them have reported that this dimension is moderate. The result of Binomial test for sport equipment shows an average value of 2.21, which implies that this dimension is perceived as moderate. In terms of nonsport equipment, 110 member of the sample population believe that the conditions of this dimension is below moderate (weak) and 50 member of them have reported that this dimension is weak. The results of Binomial test for non-sport equipment show an average of 2.20 which implies weakness of the quality of this dimension. In terms of quality of the trainer, 102 members of the sample
Table 4. Final Results of Regression Analysis in the Form of Step-by-Step method
Phase Variables in regression model R R2 Beta B Sig
1 Interaction of Quality 0/63 0/404 0/662 0/563 0/001
2 Interaction of Quality and Workout program 0/73 0/535 0/464 0/423 0/001
3 Interaction of Quality, Workout programand non Sport equipment 0/74 0/550 -0/158 -0/140 0/001
4 Interaction of Quality, Workout program, non Sport equipment and Extra Service 0/75 0/561 -0/128 -0/085 0/05
Table 5. Result of Binomial Test for Dimensions of Service Quality with Athletes' Satisfaction and Cut Point of 3.66
Quality of Service Average Standard deviation Reports lower number of points3/66 Reports Upper number of points3/66 Significance level
Sport equipment 2/21 0/454 160 0
Non Sport equipment 2/20 0/398 160 0
Quality of coach 2/37 0/424 160 0
Interaction of Quality 2/20 0/415 160 0
Workout program 2/29 0/386 160 0 0/001
Discipline 2/35 0/588 160 0
Extra Service 2/32 0/529 160 0
Satisfaction 2/44 0/498 160 0
* Significant at P<0.05
I nEflArOHKA I Ta MeflMK°"6io^oriHHi
- - np°6^eMM ^i3MHH°ro
BMXoBaHHA i cnopTy _
ncMxoflorm
population think that the conditions of this dimension is below moderate (weak) and 58 members of them have reported that this dimension has a moderate quality. The results of Binomial test for the dimension of quality of the trainer show the weakness of this dimension in the sample population. In terms of interactive quality, 100 members of the sample population have reported that this dimension has a below-moderate (weak) quality and 60 members think that this dimension is moderate. The results of Binomial test for the dimension of interactive quality show an average value of 2.20 which implies the weakness of this dimension in our population. In terms of exercise plan, 89 members of the sample population have reported that this dimension has a below-moderate (weak) quality and 71 members think that this dimension is at moderate level. The results of Binomial test for exercise plan show an average of 2.29 which implies the weakness of this dimension in our population. In terms of discipline and regularity, 81 members of the sample population have reported that this dimension has a below-moderate (weak) quality and 79 members think that this dimension
is at moderate level. The results of Binomial test show an average value of 2.35 which implies the weakness of this dimension in our sample population. In terms of extra services, 70 members of the population believe that the condition is below moderate (weak) and 90 members of them have reported that this dimension is at moderate level. The results of Binomial test for this dimension show an average value of 2.32 which implies the moderate level of this dimension in our sample population. In terms of satisfaction, 89 members of the population think that this dimension is posited at below moderate (weak) level and 71 members of them have reported that this dimension has a moderate quality. The results of Binomial test for this dimension show an average of which implies the weakness of this dimension in our population.
In tables 7 and 8, the results of Kroskal-Wallis test are presented for the research sample to investigate the difference between different athletes' viewpoints.
The results of Kroskal-Wallis test, presented in table 7, show that there is a significant differentiation between the average rank of the athletes' satisfaction with quality
Table 6. Result of Binomial Test for Dimensions of Service Quality with Athletes' Satisfaction at Cut Point of 1.33
Quality of Service Average Standard deviation Reports lower number of points3/66 Reports Upper number of points3/66 Significance level
Sport equipment 2/21 0/454 101 59
Non Sport equipment 2/20 0/398 110 50
Quality of coach 2/37 0/424 102 58
Interaction of Quality Workout program 2/20 2/29 0/415 0/386 100 89 60 71 0/001
Discipline 2/35 0/588 81 79
Extra Service 2/32 0/529 70 90
Satisfaction 2/44 0/498 89 71
* Significant at P< 0.05
Table 7. Comparison of prioritization of satisfaction level in elite athletes of National Wrestling Team in terms of the quality of services in sport camps at different age categories
Age groups
Average Rating
Chi square
Degrees of freedom Significance level
Less than 20 years 71/09 21 to 25 years 82/50
26 years and over 92/63
5/22
0/073
Table 8.Comparison of prioritization of satisfaction level in elite athletes of National Wrestling Team in terms of the quality of services in sport camps during different times of their presence in camp
Courses attended sports camp
Less than 5 times Between 6 to 10 times 11 to 15 times 16 to 20 times more than 20 times
Average Rating Chi square Degrees of freedom
78/55 76/86
76/14 11/46 4
132/57
121/75
Significance level
0/022
2
32016 II
of the sport services, in different age categories. This is because the level of significance is P<0.073 which is below error level of P<0.05. In other words, there is a significant differentiation between the viewpoints of the athletes in different age categories.
Moreover, the results of Kroskal-Wallis, presented in table 8, show that there is a significant differentiation in average rank of athletes' satisfaction with the quality of sport services during different times of their presence in sport camps; because level of significance is P<0.022 and it is below error level of P<0.05. In other words, there is a significant differentiation between viewpoints of the athletes who have been in sport camps during different times.
Discussion
The analysis of research findings reveals that there is a significant relationship between dimensions of service quality and athletes' satisfaction (except in dimension of discipline and regularity and in dimension of nonsport equipment). The findings of the current research imply a significant and positive relationship between service quality in sport camps and athletes' satisfaction; the correlational coefficient is calculated as 0.615. This means that there exists a significant differentiation between dimensions of service quality in sport camps. The results of the current study are complied with researches of Saatchiyan et al (2010), Fallahi et al (2011), Ali Dust Ghah-farrokhi and Ahmadi (2012), Honari et al (2014), Lim (2006), Liu (2008), Lin (2008). Moreover, the relationship between demographic characteristics and athletes' satisfaction implies a significant statistical relationship between demographic characteristics (age, times of being present in sport camps) with satisfaction level (table 7 and 8). These finding are complied with the researches of Liu (2008) and Eftekhari et al (2015), regarding the variable of age; so that the higher the ages of the athletes are, the lesser their needs and the higher their satisfaction level would be with the available service, and vice versa. But these findings are not consistent with the research of Moradi et al (2013) in which there is found no significant statistical relationship between demographic characteristics and satisfaction level in athletes. Furthermore, the findings show a significant relationship between the number of periods being present in the camp and level of satisfaction in the athletes; so that the higher the numbers of these periods is, the higher their satisfaction level would be relative to the athletes who have had limited performance in the sport camps. According to the findings, we can conclude that there is a positive relationship in perceived quality of sport services in sport camps and athletes' level of satisfaction with the number of times (periods) they attend in the camps. This is because occurrence of satisfaction cause the athletes to attend in the next camps.
The results of Binomial test show that the average of all the responses are below the desired level and the quality of sport services is not good at all. All average values of the respondents' state witness that the quality of services in sports camps is at weak level, except sport
equipment, which is reported as moderate. The results of regression test also reveal that different dimensions of service quality can predict the level of satisfaction of wrestlers in national camps, so that four dimensions of interactive quality, exercise plan, non-sport equipment and extra services can explain 56% of the variance of athletes' satisfaction. Among these four dimensions, interactive quality of the service has gained the highest value of correlational coefficient and, therefore, it plays an important role in athletes' level of satisfaction. Hence, the managers and trainers and authorities of the sport camps can provide various services in line with the athletes' needs and can enhance communication with the athletes in the sport camps more than ever, in order to reach consumers' satisfaction.
The other results of the research show that there is a significant relationship between quality of sport equipment and athletes' level of satisfaction; these findings are consistent with the researches of Gohar Rostami (2007) and Hopson (2002). Hopson believes that providing high-quality services is one the most important factors influencing on level of athletes' satisfaction; moreover, he states that providing proper-quality equipment at the camps and encouraging the athletes to attend exercises are irrefutable necessities which make the athletes participate in the activities with more power and better performance. On the other hand, variety of sport equipment is important due to two reasons: first, sports equipment should improve the quality of athletes' performances and second, they must guarantee the health of athletes. Due to this fact, sports equipment is of a great importance in different sport fields. Seye Javadin et al. (2010), Chia Chin (2002) and Ting (2004) also believe that the quality of services and equipment can directly influence on the athletes' level of satisfaction and it can be regarded as foundation for satisfying the consumer.
Moreover, there is no significant correlation between non-sport equipment and the athletes' level of satisfaction; but some factors such as transportation vehicles, heating and cooling systems, quality of the place in which the exercises are held and etc. can have a significant impact on level of satisfaction in the athletes' attending the camps. The other results show that there is no significant relationship between quality of coach and athletes' level of satisfaction; the correlation coefficient is calculated as 0.042. These findings are not consistent with Warren (1994); because Warren has proved that the qualities of training and relationship between coach and athletes are important dimensions of athletes' level of satisfaction. We can attribute this lack of consistency to a number of research samples; because as Lin (1991) says, the number of samples has an influence on the quality of relationship held between different variables. In a small sample population, the relationship might be reported as significant, while in there is no relationship found in big samples. According to the research samples, presence of a psychologist trainer in the camp has guaranteed the highest level of satisfaction among other items of this dimension. Because long-terms camps cause a lot of mental pressure
I nEflArOHKA I Ta MeflHKo-6ionoriHHi
- - npo6^eMM ^i3MHHoro
BMxoBaHHA i cnopTy _
ncMxoflorm
such as stress and anxiety for the athletes and since most of the athletes attend in the professional sports during teenage periods and are in sensitive situations and since we have watched a lot of champions in which the players show weak performances due to grave mental spaces of the plays and because most of the decisions of the athletes are made in severe circumstances, then it is desirable for the athletes to experience exercising in difficult situations; taking advantage of the psychologist trainers in the team can be beneficial. Furthermore, the results reveal that there is a significant and positive relationship for the dimensions of interactive quality, exercise plans and discipline and regularity with athletes' level of satisfaction. In order to hold a friendly environment among the athletes attending in camps, group coherence is needed. The more cohesive groups show better performances than the ones with less solidarity. In a sport team also, the conditions would be the same and higher solidarity leads to higher personal satisfaction in the athletes. These findings are consistent with the researches of Rhymers and Cheladoray (1998) in which satisfaction with individual and team performance and satisfaction with exercises and training process are considered to be the determining factors of athletes' satisfaction; moreover, Omand (2005) believes that team performance renders great influence on athletes' satisfaction. At the dimension of exercise plan, the importance of choosing proper and diverse times for activities during the camps can help the athletes to regulate their biological clock, temperature and hormone secretion, correctly. On the other hand, allocation of diverse times of exercising to the professional athletes is really important. This is because doing exercises at the final hours of a day (evening) can help the athletes to be active during the times in which their body possess the highest level of physical readiness and to achieve the best outcome. In this way, even if the champions are held at the initial or final hours of a day, the athletes think that they are still spending the evening times and this imagination which is derived based on their biological clocks of their bodies in simulated environments, help the athletes to exhibit better performances during competitions.
Overall, a special system and structure based on scientific principles for the exercises can be useful for developing different skills (physical, technical-tactical, mental) of the athletes. In his study, Gohar Rostami (2007) introduces satisfaction with exercise plans as an influential factor of consumers' satisfaction in sport camps; his findings are compliant with the present study. On the other hand, one the most important issues in sport camps is regularity/ discipline. The athletes' attending camps must follow their exercises regularly, in addition to holding the camp sessions. Coaches also should supervise the camps and the procedure of athletes' training and activities, based on predefined plans; they should also, consider the discipline in their schedules. Discipline is an important pillar of athletic sport. The experiences imply that discipline brings great incentive and athletic spirit for the athletes.
Conclusions
According to the results of present study and significance of correlation between variable of service quality and athletes' level of satisfaction, it is recommended to the executive managers of the camps to measure the level of service quality continually and periodically and meet the needs of athletes by doing their bests. This is because of the fact that lack of attention towards athletes' level of satisfaction can cause protesting, negligence and leaving. Therefore, it is desirable to pay considerable attention to this issue; and coaches and authorities must try their best to provide and maintain the satisfaction of athletes, emphasizing at provisioning of desirable and high-quality service, because higher levels of satisfaction can bring a sense of belonging to team and dependence on team; better performance, reduction of absence and even not leaving the team; finally, it ensures success and efficiency. Therefore, it is recommended to coaches and authorities of sports camps to realize proper targeted supports and emphasize on influential aspects of motivations and sports commitment, and to direct the athletes' level of satisfaction in order to create their highest level of satisfaction and get the best outcome and success.
Conflict of interests
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interests.
References
1. Akhlaghi HA. Identification and comparison of satisfaction level in wrestlers (freestyle and Grece Roman) from different clubs of Khoozestan Province by providing some approaches for improving the existing situation. Master Thesis, Shahid Chamran Universiy of Ahwaz. Sport School: Sport management department; 2011.
2. Aldlaigan HA, Buttle F. Systera-SQ: a new measure of bank servise quality. Internatinal Journal of Service Industry management, 2002; 4: 78-93.
3. Ali Dust Ghahfarrokhi A, Kuzechiyan H, JalaliFarahani M, Torki M. Investigation and comparison of female consumers' level of satisfaction in private and public clubs of body-building in Tehran. Journal of Sport Management, 2010; (2)5:127-140.
4. Aumand BA, Elizabeth A. For the Love of Gime Factors in Fuencing Athlete Enjoyment in Sport. Thesis submitted to the school of physical education at west Virginia university in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of master of science in sport and exercise psychology. Virginia; 2005
5. Chia Chin MC. Areview of service quality in corporate and recreational. Sport fitness programs. The Sport Journal, 2002; (5)3: 1-9.
6. De Knop P, Van Hoeke J, & De Bosscher V. Quality management in sports clubs. Sport Management Review, 2004; 7: 57-77.
7. Eftekhari A, GoharRostami HR, Haji Agha Pur J, Khanmohammadi AM.. Investigation of the service qualities in sport camps and its relationship with satisfaction level of Basketball National Team, and providence of a proper model. The Journal of Modern Approaches in Sport Management, 2015; 1: 34-40.
8. Fallahi A, Ehsani M, Purnaghi A. Comparison of quality of provided services in private and public sport clubs (body-building
32016 0g
and physical readiness) of Tehran in viewpoints of the athletes. Researches in Sport Management and Motor Sciences, 2011; 2(1): 33-48.
9. GoharRostami Hamidreza. Investigation of consumers ' satisfaction in private and public clubs of men in Tehran and ranking the influential factors. Master Thesis. Tarbiat Modarres University: Sport Management Group; 2007
10.Heydari Nezhad S, Akhlaghi H, ShafiNiya P, Sharifi Bahreyni N. Investigation of the service quality in body-building clubs of Ahwaz in athletes' viewpoints. Bulletin of Sport Management and Motor Behaviors, 2015; (9) 21: 149-156.
11.Hopson Barrie, Lugar Jack, Murgatroyd Stephen, Ripley Tyres, Scully Mike, Simpson Dan. Service Management (Consumer-orientation Culture). National Library of Iran; 2002.
12.Huyen NL. Customer Satisfaction Survey for A Fitness Center - Kokkola. Kokkola, 2011; 5: 23-32.
13. Juga J, Juntunen J, & Grant DB. Service Quality and its Relation to Satisfaction and Loyalty in Logistics Outsourcing Relationships. Managing Service Quality, 2010; 20(6): 496-510.
14.Kuzechiyan H, Khatibzade M, Honarvar A. The role of dimensions of tourism service quality in satisfaction level of athletic tourists. Journal of Research in Sport Management and Motor Sciences. 2011; (1)2:19-32.
15.Khodadadi H. Investigation of the factor relating to consumers ' satisfaction in sport associations of Municipality of District 15 of Tehran. Sport School: Sport management department; 2010
16.Lee H. The influence of service quality on satisfaction and intention: A gender segmentation strategy. Sport Management Review 2010; 1: 23-30.
17.Lee H, Kim HD, Ko YJ, & Sagas M. The influence of service quality on satisfaction and intention: A gender segmentation strategy. Sport Management Review, 2011; 14: 54-63.
18.Lim JS. The influence of service quality on customer satisfaction, attitudinal loyalty, and behavioral future intention for participation of fitness centers in South Korea. [PhD thesis]. United States Sports Academy; 2006.
19.Lin J-C. Service quality of the Ocean sport clubs and its impact on customer loyalty. [PhD thesis]. United States Sports Academy; 2008.
20.Liu YC. An Analysis Service Quality, Customer Satisfaction and Customer Loyalty of Commercial Swim Clubs in Taiwan. [PhD thesis]. United States Sports Academy; 2008.
21.Mirzayi B, RahmaniNiya F. the comparison of the profile of behavioral modes of wrestlers in junior and senior national teams in two fields of freestyle and Grece Roman. Journal of Olympic. 2006; (33) 1: 31-40.
22.Nicholas D, Kostas A, Nikolaos T, & Serafim K. Predicting spectators' behavioural intentions in professional football: The role of satisfaction and service quality. Sport Management Review, 2013; 16(1): 85-96.
23.Pur Iran Z. Investigation of the service quality in indoor swimming pools of Mashhad. Master Thesis. Amol University of North. Sport School: Sport Management Department; 2008.
24.Riemer & Chelladurai. Role ambiguity and athlete satisfaction. Journal of sport science, 1998; 9: 1-5.
25. Saatchiyan V, Safari H, Rasuli SM, Eskandari A, Elahi A. Influence of service quality, level of satisfaction, commitment to future behavioral decisions of the consumers in order to be present in Aerobic and Physical Readiness Clubs. Journal of Research in Sport Management and Motor Behaviors, 2010; (3)5: 125-138.
26.Seyyed Javadeen SR, Khanlari A, & Esteeri M. A model of the assessment of the service quality affecting the sports service customers' loyalty. Olympic Journal, 2011; 52: 41-54.
27.Seyed Javadin SR, Khanlari A, Estiri M. A model for evaluating the influence of service quality on loyalty of the sport service consumers. Journal of Olympic, 2010; (18)52: 41-54.
28.Ting DH. Service Quality and Satisfaction Perceptions: Curvilinear and Interaction Effect. The International Journal of Bank Marketing, 2004; (22)6: 407-420.
29.Warren D. The influence of leader behaviors, Coach attributes and institutional variables on performance and satisfaction of collegiate Basketball teams. 1984. Available from: http://Proquest.umi.com/pqd
30.Yung Lin H. The study of exercise participation motivation and the relationship among service quality, customer satisfaction, and customer loyalty at selected fitness health clubs in Taipei city, Taiwan. [PhD thesis]. United States Sports Academy; 2010.
IПЕДАГОГ1КА I та медико_б'олог'чн'
- - проблеми ф1зичного
виховання i спорту _
ПСИХОЛОГ1Я
Информация об авторах: Гохарростами Хамид Реза; http://orcid.org/0000-0002-6518-466\; goharrostami@gmail.com; Университет Гилян, п/я 1841, Рашт, Иран.
Ходходи Абкенари Бехнам; http://orcid.org/0000-0003-4734-6204; saba_cn44@yahoo.com; Исламский Азад Университет в Караи; а/я 1841, Караи, Иран.
Ефтекхари Озра; http://orcid.org/0000-0001-7445-7351; ozra.eftekhari@gmail.com; Университет Шомал; п/я 731. Амол, Мазандаран, Иран.
Кходаяри Аббас; http://orcid.org/0000-0003-1861-0811; a.khodayari@kiau.ac.ir; Исламский Азад Университет в Караи; а/я 1841, Караи, Иран.
Цитируйте эту статью как: Гохарростами Хамид Реза, Ходходи Абкенари Бехнам, Ефтекхари Озра, Кходаяри Аббас. Соотношение между качеством предоставляемых услуг в спортивных лагерях и удовлетворением элитных спортсменов национальных команд вольного стиля и греко-римской борьбы // Педагопка, психологш та медико-бюлопчш проблеми фiзичного виховання i спорту. - 2016. - N4. - С. 50-58. doi: 10.15561/18189172.2016.0408
Электронная версия этой статьи является полной и может быть найдена на сайте: http://www.sportpedagogy.org.ua/html/arhive. html
Это статья Открытого Доступа распространяется под терминами Creative Commons Attribution License, которая разрешает неограниченное использование, распространение и копирование любыми средствами, обеспечивающими должное цитирование этой оригинальной статьи (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/ by/4.0/deed.ru).
Дата поступления в редакцию: 10.07.2016 Принята: 26.07.2016; Опубликована: 30.08.2016
Information about the authors: Goharrostami Hamid Reza; Assistant professor; http://orcid. org/0000-0002-6518-466X; goharrostami@gmail.com; Faculty of Physical Education and Sport Sciences, University of Guilan; Box 1841, Rasht, Iran.
Hodhodi Abkenari Behnam; Master in Sport Management; http://orcid.org/0000-0003-4734-6204; saba_cn44@yahoo. com; Islamic Azad University; Box 1841, Karaj, Iran.
Eftekhari Ozra; Master in Sport Management; http://orcid. org/0000-0001-7445-7351; ozra.eftekhari@gmail.com; Faculty of Physical Education and Sport Sciences, University of Shomal; P.O.Box 731. Amol, Mazandaran, Iran.
Khodayari Abbas; Associate Professor; http://orcid.org/0000-0003-1861-0811; a.khodayari@kiau.ac.ir; Islamic Azad University; Box 1841, Karaj, Iran.
Cite this article as: Goharrostami Hamid Reza, Hodhodi Abkenari Behnam, Eftekhari Ozra, Khodayari Abbas. The relation between service quality of sports camps and elite athletes' satisfaction of the national teams' freestyle & Greco-Roman wrestling. Pedagogics, psychology, medical-biological problems of physical training and sports, 2016;4:50-58. doi:10.15561/18189172.2016.0408
The electronic version of this article is the complete one and can be found online at: http://www.sportpedagogy.org.ua/html/arhive-e.html
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/ by/4.0/deed.en).
Received: 10.07.2016
Accepted: 26.07.2016; Published: 30.08.2016
