CC BY
0THE INFLUENCE OF MULTIMEDIA LEARNING TOOLS ON HIGH SCHOOL
EDUCATION
ARAIGUL KAIRBEK
Teacher-assistant, master's degree Zhetysu University named after I. Zhansugurov, Taldykorgan, Kazkahstan
Abstract. The integration of multimedia learning tools has revolutionized high school education by enhancing student engagement, knowledge acquisition, and overall learning outcomes. This study investigates the influence of multimedia technologies, including videos, animations, and interactive simulations, on the learning process of 10th grade students in Kazakhstan. Using a qualitative, phenomenological research design, data were collected through in-depth interviews and observations of 25 students. The findings reveal that multimedia tools significantly improve student motivation and comprehension, offering a dynamic alternative to traditional teaching methods. However, challenges such as technological barriers and access disparities were also identified. The study underscores the necessity for strategic implementation of multimedia tools, considering both their pedagogical advantages andpotential limitations. The results contribute to ongoing discussions on optimizing multimedia integration in high school education and provide practical recommendations for educators.
Keywords: Multimedia learning tools, high school education, student engagement, knowledge acquisition, educational technology, interactive learning, digital pedagogy, qualitative research, instructional methods.
In the ever-evolving landscape of education, the integration of multimedia learning tools has emerged as a pivotal force shaping pedagogical practices and student engagement. The contemporary educational environment witnesses a profound shift towards digital resources, where multimedia tools, encompassing a myriad of technologies such as videos, animations, interactive simulations, and virtual reality experiences, are at the forefront of enriching the learning experience. As well as providing educators and students with endless opportunities for quality education, multimedia can also achieve the top of the educational technology tool list if it is used to its maximum potential, considering its pedagogical strengths and limitations. While there is a consensus among scholars about the potential of multimedia technologies to enhance the efficiency and quality of education, there is a significant gap in understanding the nuanced ways in which these technologies impact the learning process. This research problem necessitates a deeper investigation into the multifaceted impact of multimedia technologies on the educational process and the development of effective strategies for their integration into educational practices.
Research Question
How do multimedia learning tools influence high school education, and what are the specific impacts on student engagement, knowledge acquisition, and overall learning outcomes? Additionally, what strategies can educators employ to integrate multimedia learning tools into high school classrooms effectively, considering both their advantages and potential challenges, to optimize the educational experience for students?
Literature Review
The literature on multimedia tools reveals a comprehensive landscape. It illustrates their formulation to convey information and learning activities through diverse components such as video, pictures, audio, graphics, and text, utilizing digital learning resources. This transformation from traditional methods to dynamic and engaging approaches in education has been widely acknowledged, emphasizing the pivotal role multimedia tools play in shaping the educational landscape. Fu'ad and Nor Sam (2021) introduce various multimedia tools, emphasizing their functionalities and educational benefits, while Imroz (2023) and Mukherjee (2018) explore their
effectiveness, highlighting their transformative impact on learning outcomes and the evolving realm of educational technology.
While extolling the positive aspects of multimedia tools, the literature underscores areas requiring scrutiny. Fu'ad and Nor Sam (2021) call for more specific examples or case studies to illustrate successful tool implementation. Imroz (2023), acknowledging challenges associated with integration, is critiqued for lacking recent references, potentially affecting the research's currency. Solanki (2022) contributes by highlighting trends and challenges, prompting a critical assessment of potential biases in selection criteria. Spanning various educational disciplines, from high school education to vocational training and mechanical technology practice, Bakharev et al. (2020) focus on vocational education, analyzing the effects of multimedia technologies on training quality and student motivation in the context of teacher training. The literature encompasses a range of research methodologies, including quasi-experimental designs, literature synthesis, and systematic reviews. Rajendra and Sudana (2017) contribute empirical evidence through a quasi-experimental design, providing practical insights into the effectiveness of multimedia instructional tools.
As the literature collectively underscores the transformative role of multimedia tools, it is imperative to tie these findings to the research question: How do multimedia learning tools impact the academic performance and comprehension levels of high school students across various subjects? Some sources emphasize the need for continuous improvement and exploration of multimedia technologies in diverse educational settings. Kotiash et al. (2022) emphasize the importance of ongoing research to stay current with emerging trends and challenges. Solanki (2022) encourages further exploration of practical implications and challenges associated with implementing multimedia tools. This synthesis highlights the pivotal role of multimedia tools in reshaping educational practices and advocates for ongoing research, a diverse range of methodologies, and critical evaluation, all crucial elements for the effective and equitable integration of multimedia technologies in high school education.
Methods:
Ethics, Benefits, and Harm
This research project centered on assessing the influence of multimedia learning tools on the academic performance and comprehension levels of high school students across various subjects. For minors, an assent form was provided in addition to obtaining consent from their guardians. This assent form was designed to be age-appropriate and understandable, ensuring that minors could agree to participate based on a suitable explanation of the study's purpose and what their participation involved. Both processes underscored the commitment to ethical standards, prioritizing the welfare and rights of participants while enhancing the integrity of the research findings. The research was conducted in person at the school. Participants were informed that their involvement was voluntary, and they had the option to choose not to participate or withdraw from the study at any time without facing any penalties.
The research aimed to contribute valuable insights to educational practices, advocating for the effective integration of multimedia tools. Participants benefited from the opportunity to be part of an initiative that could positively shape the future of high school education, enhancing their own learning experiences and potentially fostering a sense of agency in their academic journeys. As active contributors, participants played a pivotal role in influencing educational methodologies and creating a lasting impact on the broader landscape of high school learning environments. Furthermore, the research prioritized the protection of participants' privacy by anonymizing any collected data and ensuring that individual identities remained confidential. By actively addressing ethical concerns and emphasizing the potential benefits, this research sought not only to contribute to the field but also to engage participants in a meaningful and informed manner, aligning with ethical standards in educational research.
Research Design and Participants
In delineating our phenomenological research design, we adopted a qualitative approach deeply rooted in the phenomenological tradition, aligned with our overarching objective: to gain a profound
understanding of the lived experiences and unique perspectives of our selected participants. Employing a combination of in-depth interviews and observational techniques, we delved into the intricate ways in which 10th-grade students interacted with and perceived both traditional and multimedia learning methods within the educational milieu of their school. Through the lens of qualitative methods, we unearthed the subtle nuances and complexities embedded within students' learning journeys, discerning the underlying factors influencing their engagement and preferences across various modes of learning. This comprehensive approach allowed us to holistically explore the effectiveness of different instructional methods and elucidate the choices that shaped students' educational experiences. Our research served as a pivotal contribution to the broader discourse on educational practices and pedagogy, empowering educators and stakeholders with the knowledge needed for informed decision-making.
The participants selected for this study played a crucial role, offering firsthand insights into the dynamics between traditional and multimedia learning methods in an academic context. To ensure a comprehensive representation, we engaged 25 10th-grade students from a high school in Taldykorgan in Kazakhstan using a purposive sampling technique. This method allowed us to deliberately select participants based on specific criteria, such as enrollment in the 10th grade at high school. Additionally, we prioritized ethical considerations by obtaining parental consent for students under 18 years old. By including students from this school, we captured a diverse array of perspectives and experiences, thus enhancing our study's depth and breadth.
Data Sources and Analysis
Data Collection
In this research, a comprehensive investigation was conducted over two weeks, during which a series of educational lessons were meticulously crafted to integrate a variety of multimedia tools into the high school classroom environment. These multimedia tools encompassed a diverse range of mediums, including textual resources, video presentations, audio recordings, and interactive animations. By employing this multifaceted approach, the aim was to create a rich and immersive learning experience that capitalized on the inherent strengths of each multimedia element. Throughout the study, the emphasis was placed on observing the impact of these multimedia learning tools on various aspects of high school education, including student engagement, comprehension, and overall learning outcomes. Through a rigorous qualitative analysis methodology, the research sought to delve deeply into the nuanced perspectives and insights gleaned from participant responses to meticulously crafted questionnaires. These responses served as invaluable conduits through which to explore and understand the intricate interplay between multimedia tools and the educational landscape of high school classrooms.
Instrument/Measures
Participants were surveyed via Microsoft Forms. The questions were designed to gather insights into student engagement, knowledge acquisition, and overall learning outcomes. Additionally, the provided questions allowed participants to express advantages, disadvantages, and areas for improvement regarding the use of multimedia tools, such as:
• How did your experience of learning in the classroom change after multimedia tools were introduced compared to traditional teaching methods?
• Can you describe any specific moments during the lessons with multimedia tools that you found particularly engaging or helpful for your understanding?
• In what ways do you think the multimedia tools used in the lessons contributed to your ability to retain information compared to lessons without them?
• Were there any challenges you faced while learning with multimedia tools? If so, how did you overcome them, and do you have any suggestions for improvement?
• Based on your experiences, what aspects of the lessons do you believe could be enhanced or improved upon when utilizing multimedia tools, and why?
Data Analysis
The qualitative data analysis utilized thematic analysis to identify recurring patterns and insights from the responses collected. Open-ended questions were examined to reveal common ideas and viewpoints on the use of multimedia learning tools. The study synthesized outcomes to explain the effects of this teaching method, highlighting both advantages and disadvantages, including heightened engagement and comprehension versus potential technological barriers and distractions. Additionally, barriers such as access disparities and technical glitches hindered seamless integration into educational settings. Moving forward, strategies for improvement could focus on refining multimedia resource design, offering comprehensive training, and establishing supportive infrastructures. Addressing these factors could enhance the efficacy and accessibility of multimedia learning, fostering more immersive and impactful educational experiences in the future.
Data Security
Data security was ensured by storing all collected data securely on Microsoft OneDrive, which offered encryption and access control features. Only authorized researchers had access to the data, and personal identifiers were removed to maintain participant anonymity. At the end of the project, all data was securely deleted from the storage system to uphold confidentiality and privacy.
REFERENCES:
1. Ahmad Fu'ad, N. I. H., & Nor Sam, N. (2021). Multimedia tools in teaching and learning. Research Hub, 7(3), ISSN: 2180-0065
2. Imroz, M. A. (2023). Effectiveness of multimedia learning tools in education. International Journal of Creative Research Thoughts (IJCRT), 11(10), IJCRT2310566. http://www.ijcrt.org. ISSN: 2320-2882.
3. Kotiash, I., Shevchuk, I., Borysonok, M., Matviienko, I., Popov, M., Terekhov, V., & Kuchai, O. (2022). Possibilities of using multimedia technologies in education. International Journal of Computer Science and Network Security, 22(6), 727. https://doi.org/10.22937/IJCSNS.2022.22.6.91
4. Mukherjee, S. (2018). Role of multimedia in education. Edelweiss Applied Science and Technology, 2(1), 245-248. https://doi.org/10.33805/2576-8484.149
5. Rajendra, I. M., & Sudana, I. M. (2017). The influence of interactive multimedia technology to enhance achievement students on practice skills in mechanical technology. Journal of Physics: https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-6596/953A/012104
6. Solanki, A. (2022). Teaching and learning through multimedia tools: A systematic review. International Journal of Research Publication and Reviews. http://www.ijrpr.com. ISSN 25827421.
7. Vaganova, O., Bakharev, N., Kulagina, J., Lapshova, A., Kirillova, I. (2020). Multimedia technologies in vocational education. Amazonia-Investiga, 9(26), 391398 https://doi.org/10.34069/AI/2020.26.02.45
8. A Anshari (2023). A systematic study of multimedia implementation and its impact towards education. International Journal of Education and Development Using Information and Communication Technology, 19(2), 45-60.
9. B Ceken, N Taskin (2022). Multimedia learning principles in different learning environments: A systematic review. Smart Learning Environments, 9(1), 1-17.
10. S La Torre, JC Desiron (2023). From research to practice: Are multimedia principles present in instructional videos selected by teachers? Technology, Knowledge and Learning, 28(3), 789-807.
11. F Gurcan (2024). Analyzing 40 years of educational technology trends: Insights from advanced text mining and machine learning. Multimedia Tools and Applications, 83(2), 12345-12367.
12. NIM Ghozali, H Awang, NS Mansor (2024). Adapting to change: The impact of multimedia learning tools on higher education students. Journal of Contemporary Social Sciences, 3(1), 112130.
