Testing mechanical structural characteristics of Al2O3 oxide ceramics resistant to sliding friction Текст научной статьи по специальности «Физика»

TESTING MECHANICAL STRUCTURAL CHARACTERISTICS OF Al2O3 OXIDE CERAMICS > RESISTANT TO SLIDING FRICTION

Mihailo R. Mrdak

w Research and Development Center IMTEL Communications a.d.,

ct Belgrade, Republic of Serbia,

O e-mail: [email protected],

^ ORCID iD: http://orcid.org/0000-0003-3983-1605

o http://dx.doi.org/10.5937/vojtehg65-12000

^ FIELD: Chemical Technology

uu ARTICLE TYPE: Original Scientific Paper

£ ARTICLE LANGUAGE: English cc

^ Summary:

Al2O3 is hard oxide ceramics, chemically bioinert and with good sliding properties; it has found wide application in the design of engineering components. The aim of the paper was to apply the APS process with < the change of plasma currents in order to produce Al2O3 layers of such

GL structural and mechanical properties which will find application in the SZ manufacture of biomedical coatings alone or in combination with

^ hydroxyapatite (HA) on the surfaces of alloys used for making implants.

i The coating was deposited with a plasma current of 700, 800 and 900 A.

The mechanical properties of coatings were tested using the Pratt & Whitney standard. The shape of the surface of powder particles and the OJ coating surface were examined by SEM. The metallographic analysis of the inner layers was carried out by light microscopy. The best structural and mechanical properties of the Al2O3 coating deposited with 900A were confirmed by testing the sliding properties of the coating deposited and polished to a mirror on the sealing ring paired with the graphite ring on the water brake.

Keywords: sliding, property, oxides, mechanical properties, deposits, coatings, Al2O3.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT: The author is thankful for the financial support from the Ministry of Education and Science of the Republic of Serbia (national projects OI 174004).

CD CO CD

■4

CM CD !±

T3

(/) <u

Introduction

Ceramic coatings are widely used to improve wear resistance of working surfaces of various mechanisms due to their high strength and structural stability (Toma et al, 2001, pp.149-158). AI2O3 ceramics is applied to many engineering components where good sliding properties and wear resistance to friction are required. Because being bioinert in living tissues, Al2O3 ceramics is applied to the surface modification of biomedical coatings deposited on titanium alloys. Good mechanical characteristics of Al2O3 ceramics allow it - since it is inorganic and bioinert - to be combined in different volume ratios with organic bioactive ceramics hydroxyapatite (HA) in the process of producing biomedical coatings. In this way, coating stiffness is reduced, tensile strength and fatigue resi- mar stance to friction are increased, which extends the life of the coating (Li g et al, 2006, pp.1166-1172), (Liou, 2009). Applying such modified coatings on the surfaces of titanium alloys significantly enhance the biologi- g cal activity of implants and increase the resistance of titanium alloys to $ bio corrosion (Gadow et al, 2010, pp.1157-1164). For the manufacture ^ and modification of biomedical coatings, ceramics of Al2O3 and ZrO2 are most frequently used, alone or in combination, as well as hydroxyapatite (HA) (Hsiung et al, 2012, pp.457-463).

In the plasma spray process, due to high speed of plasma particles and uneven distribution of temperature in plasma, plasma current chan- a ges significantly affect total or partial melting of Al2O3 powder particles, ach which is reflected in the structure and mechanical properties of the coating (Friis et al, 2001, pp.115-127), (Matejicek & Sampath, 2001, pp.1993-1999). Previous studies have shown that the properties of the coating are directly related to the parameters that influence the degree of melting of particles and the mechanism of deformation of molten drops in collision with the substrate (Li & Ohmori, 2002, pp.365-374), (Mrdak, 2016a, pp. 1-25), (Mrdak, 2016b, pp.411-430). The coating quality is primarily defined by its microstructure (type of phases and homogeneity) and its mechanical properties that are critical for reliable behavior of the coating in exploitation (Tucker, 2002, pp.45-53), (Liao et al, 2000, pp.235-242), (Toma et al, 2001, pp.149-158). The share and the phase a-Al2O3/Y-Al2O3 ratio depends on the amount of heat which drops of molten particles carry with them and which is directly dependent on the size ro of melting particles, cooling rate and substrate temperature (Kulkarni et ^ al, 2004, pp.124-137), (Yang et al, 2006, pp. 1649-1653). The y-AI2O3 phase in the coating is desirable for increasing toughness and cohesive coating / adhesion strength. Resistance to sliding contact fatigue of the

■■¡г ф

ю CD

О >

О

см ОС

УУ 0£ ZD О

о <

о

х о ш

н

>-

СС <

(Л <

-J

О ■О

X ш н

о

о >

Al2O3 coating depends on the phase composition, content and pore size, and presence of unmelted particles and cracks.

The paper presents an analysis of the results of tests of the mechanical properties and the microstructure of Al2O3 coatings deposited with 700, 800 and 900A. Because of economic effects, Al2O3 coatings were deposited on steel substrates. The aim was to use plasma in the manufacture of coating layers to be applied for the modification of biomedical coatings and the surface modification of alloys used to produce implants. The coating with the best properties is tested on the sealing ring of the water brake paired with the graphite ring. The investigation confirmed that the Al2O3 coating, polished to a mirror on the sealing ring, substantially improved the efficiency of the sealing and significantly reduced the sealing ring friction abrasion, thus allowing the use of Al2O3 coatings for implant surface modification.

Materials and experimental details

Al2O3 oxide powder used for coating deposition is Metco 105NS produced by the technique of melting / grinding molded blocks to a granulation of 15 - 45 Mm. (Material Product Data Sheet, 2012). Figure 1 (SEM) shows the surface of Al2O3 powder particles used in this work; the particles are of irregular shapes with sharp edges.

Figure 1 - Surface of Л12Оз particles Рис. 1 - Изображение поверхности частиц AI2O3 Слика 1 - Изглед површине AI2O3 честица

To test the mechanical properties and the structure of the layers, the powder is deposited on steel samples (X15Cr13 EN10027), the characteristics and dimensions of which are prescribed by the Pratt & Whitney standard (Pratt & Whitney, 2002). To measure the microhardness and adhesion strength, the Pratt & Whitney standard was used, providing the measurement procedure relating to the number of samples and the number of measuring points (Pratt & Whitney, 2002). The paper presents the

minimum and maximum values of microhardness and average adhesion strength. The metallographic analysis of the coatings and the content of pores in the coatings was performed under a light microscope. The paper presents the average values of a share of pores. The analysis of the surface of the powder particles and the surface of the deposited coating is carried out by the SEM method.

The Al2O3 powder was deposited at atmospheric pressure with a SG-100 plasma gun and a power supply of 40kW. The Al2O3 powder deposition parameters are shown in Table 1. The deposited layers formed a coating thickness from 0.18 to 0.20 mm.

CD CO CD

■4

CM CD !±

О tj

Ъ

Table 1 - Plasma spray parameters Таблица 1 - Параметры плазменного напыления Табела 1 - Плазма cnpej параметри

Deposition parameters Values

Plasma current, I (A) 700 800 900

Plasma Voltage, U (V) 35 37 42

Primary plasma gas flow rate, Ar (l/min) 50 50 50

Secondary plasma gas flow rate, He (l/min) 32 32 32

Carrier gas flow rate, Ar (l/min) 7 7 7

Powder feed rate, (g/min) 40 40 40

Stand-off distance, (mm) 115 115 115

(Л ф

Е 2 ф о ф

"О X о

со

О

Cl <

ч— О (Л

о

<л ф

13 го

го

-С

о "rô

Results and discussion

Figure 2 illustrates the results of the microhardness of Al2O3 coatings deposited with a change in plasma current amperage. The measured values of coating microhardness were directly related to the applied current amperage. The lowest microhardness value of 780 - 1010HV03 belongs to the coating deposited with 700A, and the maximum value of 990 - 1180HV03 characterizes the coating deposited with 900A. Nonuniform and different coating microhardness values are the result of uneven distribution of micro pores, different pore content and pore size in the coating layers. The plasma current amperage significantly influenced the melting of powder particles. Lower current intensity was not enough to melt injected particles throughout the complete cross section, which resulted in the deposited particles having a smaller intercon-

ro о

о ф

E

го тз

■■¡г ф

ю CD

О >

О

см ОС

УУ 0£ ZD О

о <

о

х о ш

н

>-

СС <

(Л <

-J

О ■О

X ш н

о

о >

tact surface and a higher intercontact content of micro pores. Due to poorer melting of particles and a larger share of pores, the coating had a range of microhardness of 230HV03. The coating deposited with 900A had a range of microhardness lower than 190HV03. High amperage affects a greater degree of ionization of the He monoatomic gas, which increases the plasma temperature and heat transfer from plasma to powder particles.

Figure 2 - Results of th e microhardness of AI2O3 coatings Рис. 2 - Результаты микротвердости покрытия AI2O3 Слика 2 - Резултати микротврдоПе превлака AI2O3

Consequently, powder particles melt better and more evenly throughout the cross section. Liquid drops of molten particles are better bonded to one another achieving a greater bonding area and stronger cohesive strength with a smaller proportion of micro pores. Figure 3 shows the results of the adhesion strength of the substrate / Al2O3 coating bond depending on the amperage. The Al2O3 powder deposited with 700A achieved the lowest value of adhesion strength of 38MPa with the substrate. Due to uneven and incompletely melted powder particles in plasma with 700A, particles carry a small amount of heat. Therefore, incompletely melted particles transfer a smaller amount of heat to the substrate, which is why their bond to the substrate is weak.

Figure 3 - Results of the bond strength of AI2O3 coatings Рис. 3 - Результаты твердости связи покрытия AI2O3 Слика 3 - Резултати чврстоПе cnoja превлака AI2O3

Heating the metal substrates from liquid drops of completely melted AI2O3 particles deposited with 900A increases the adhesive bond strength to 47 MPa. At the fracture of the samples, it was established that the fracture mechanism was adhesion at the substrate / Al2O3 coating interface.

Figure 4 illustrates the cross section of the microstructure of the Al2O3 coating deposited with 900A. The substrate / coating bond is very good because contamination from corundum, coarse pores and micro cracks are not visible at the interface. High amperage of plasma current allowed the drops of completely melted particles to overlap completely in collision with the substrate and form thin lamellae and inter lamellar pores of small size and small content in the coating. In the coating, there are micro pores of 5 - 10^m with a mean share of 4.2%. The structure of the coating consists of phases of mixed crystals a-Al2O3 + Y-Al2O3 (Kulkarni et al, 2004, pp. 124-137), (Yang et al, 2006, pp.16491653).

Figures 5 and 6 illustrate the cross sections and the microstructures of the Al2O3 coatings deposited with 800A and 700A.

<u

Ю CD

О >

О CM

a: УУ 0£ ZD О

о <

о z

X

о

Ш

I—

>-

CC <

Figure 4 - Cross section and microstructure of the AI2O3 (900A) coatings Рис. 4 - Поперечное сечение и микроструктура AI2O3 покрытия (900A) Слика 4 - Попречни пресек и микроструктура AI2O3 превлаке (900 A)

Due to low thermal conductivity of the oxide powder, lower plasma current amperage heats and melts powder particles to a lower extent.

(Л <

-J

CD >0

x

Ш I—

О z

—3

О >

Figure 5 - Cross section and microstructure of the AI2O3 (800A) coatings Рис. 5 - Поперечное сечение и микроструктура AI2O3 покрытия (800A) Слика 5 - Попречни пресек и микроструктура AI2O3 превлаке (800 A)

Such semi-melted particles are poorly and improperly deformed in collision with the substrate thus forming pores larger in size and share in the coatings. Coatings with a higher share of pores of irregular shapes and larger pores significantly reduce the cohesive strength of the coating and the coating time and resistance to fatigue friction. Because of their lower density and inhomogeneity, such coatings will wear faster and are unreliable in operation.

Figure 6 - Cross section and microstructure of the AI2O3 (700A) coatings

Рис. 6 - Поперечное сечение и микроструктура AI2O3 покрытия (700A) Слика 6 - Попречни пресек и микроструктура AI2O3 превлаке (700 A)

In the structure of the coating deposited with 800A, there are small and rough micro pores of irregular shape marked with red arrows. Micro pores in the coating had a size of 10 - 20^m with a total content of 6.4%. The microstructure of the worst coatings deposited with 700A is illustrated in Figure 6. The highest content of micro pores of 8.6% and formed coarse pores over 20^m resulted in the coating having the lowest micro-hardness, the highest microhardness range and the lowest adhesion strength.

Figure 7 illustrates the surface morphology of the Al2O3 coating deposited with 900A and analyzed by the SEM method. On the surface of the Al2O3 coating, overlapped particles can be seen, deformed in a characteristic way in collision with the substrate. Drops of molten Al2O3 particles cooled to the substrate temperature and formed a disk-like shape. The morphology of a well-molten particle is marked with a red line in the Figure. Complete overlapping of particles is proof that the Al2O3 particles are completely molten in plasma and as such allow deposition of layers of coating with thin disks - lamellae on whose edges (interfaces) fine micro pores and precipitates are present. Micro pores in the Figure are rounded in

co

CO CD

■4

Ol CD !±

Ъ

(Л

<u

E

<u

О <U "O X о

со

О

Cl <

о .41

<D

13 <0

-C

о "го

го о

о <u Е

го тз

<u

Ю CD

О >

О CM

a: УУ 0£ ZD О

о <

о

X

о

Ш

I—

>-

CC <

(Л <

-J

CD >Q

X Ш I—

О z

—3

О >

yellow, while precipitates are in red and green. Full overlapping of deposited particles, due to a large contact area, indicates a good bond between individual particles in a layer deposited in a single plasma gun shot.

Figure 7 - MorphoIogy surface of the AI2O3 coating in the sprayed state, (900A) Рис. 7 - Морфология поверхности покрытия AI2O3, нанесенного напылением, (900A) Слика 7 - Морфологи]а површине AI2O3 превлаке у напрсканом стаъу (900 A)

It also indicates good bonding between the layers in the coating as well as good adhesion of ceramic particles with the roughened substrate on whose surface liquid Д120з ceramic drops stay during cooling to the substrate temperature. Such deposition of fully molten powder particles enables the production of coatings of good adhesion / cohesion strength and provides the coating with good sliding properties and wear resistance to friction.

Conclusion

On the basis of the results of examining the mechanical, structural and sliding properties of the Al2O3 coatings deposited with 700A, 800A and 900A, it can be concluded:

The results of coatings microhardness were directly related to the applied current amperage. The current of 900A melted injected Al2O3 particles in plasma over the complete cross section, which caused the deposited particles to have a large intercontact surface (good cohesive strength) and maximum microhardness. The transfer of heat from the liquid drops of completely molten Al2O3 particles to the metal substrate enabled that the coating has the highest strength of bond adhesion - 47 MPa.

Plasma current of 900A resulted in Al2O3 powder particles melting 369

CM CD

completely and, in collision with the substrate, they completely overlapped and formed a coating of the best microstructure. In this way, thin lamellae and interlamellar pores of small size with a small share in the coating were formed in the layers. Micro pores had a size of 5 - 10^m with a mean share of 4.2% in the coating. The structure of the coating consisted of the phases of mixed crystals of a-Al2O3 + y-AI2O3.

The coating deposited with 900A was tested on the sealing ring of the water brake paired with its counter pair made of graphite. Testing the sliding properties showed that the Al2O3 coating brushed and polished to a mirror on the sealing ring has good properties of sliding fatigue since the ring sealing efficiency is significantly improved and the ring wear is reduced.

References

T3

E

<D O <1J "O X o

Friis, M., Persson, C. & Wigren, J., 2001. Influence of particle in-flight characteristics on the microstructure of atmospheric plasma sprayed yttria § stabilized ZrO2. Surface and Coatings Technology, 141(2-3), pp.115-127. < Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0257-8972(01)01239-7.

Gadow, R., Killinger, A. & Stiegler, N., 2010. Hydroxyapatite coatings for biomedical applications deposited by different thermal spray techniques. Surface and Coatings Technology, 205(4), pp.1157-1164. Available at: ^ http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.surfcoat.2010.03.059. jl

Hsiung, J.C., Kung, H.K., Chen, H.S. & Chang, K.Y., 2012. Applications of Thermal Spray Coating in Artificial Knee Joints. Life Science Journal, 9(1), pp.457-463. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.7537/marslsj090112.68.

Kulkarni, A., Gutleber, J., Sampath, S., Goland, A., Lindquist, W.B., Herman, H., Allen, A.J. & Dowd, B., 2004. Studies of the microstructure and S properties of dense ceramic coatings produced by high-velocity oxygen-fuel combustion spraying. Materials Science and Engineering, 369(1-2), pp.124- "S 137. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016Zj.msea.2003.10.295. E

Li, C.J. & Ohmori, A., 2002. Relationship between the structure and properties of thermally sprayed coatings. Journal of Thermal Spray Technology, 11(3), pp.365-374. Available at:

http://dx.doi.org/10.1361/105996302770348754.

Li, C.J, Yang, G.J & Ohmori, A., 2006. Relationship between particle erosion and lamellar microstructure for plasma-sprayed alumina coatings. Wear, 260(11-12), pp.1166-1172. Available at:

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.wear.2005.07.006.

Liao, H., Normand, B. & Coddet, C., 2000. Influence of coating microstructure on the abrasive wear resistance of WC/Co cermet coatings.

ф

ю CD

"о >

I*-"

О CM

of ш

а.

Z) О О

_l <

о

X

о ш

н >-

а. <

н

(Л <

CD >о

X ш н о

О

Surface and Coatings Technology, 124(2-3), pp.235-242. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0257-8972(99)00653-2.

Liou, S., 2009. Biomedical Titanium Alloys and Surface Modification, Chemical Industry.

Matejicek, J. & Sampath, S., 2001. Intrinsic residual stresses in single splats produced by thermal spray processes. Acta Materialia, 49(11), pp.19931999. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S1359-6454(01)00099-4.

- Material Product Data Sheet, 2012. Metco 105NS Aluminum Oxide Thermal Spray Powders, DSMTS-0005.1, Sulzer Metco.

Mrdak, IW., 2016a. Study of the application of plasma sprayed coatings on the sections of the Astazou III B turbo - jet engine. Vojnotehnicki glasnik / Military Technical Courier, 64(1), pp.1-25. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.5937/vojtehg64-8933.

Mrdak, M., 2016b. Properties of the ZrO2MgO/MgZrO3NiCr/NiCr triple-layer thermal barrier coating deposited by the atmospheric plasma spray process. Vojnotehnicki glasnik / Military Technical Courier, 64(2), pp.411-430. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.5937/vojtehg64-9612.

- Pratt & Whitney, 2002. Turbojet Engine - Standard Practices Manual (PN 582005), East Hartford, USA, Pratt & Whitney.

Toma, D., Brandl, W., Marginean, G., 2001. Wear and corrosion behaviour of thermally sprayed cermet coatings. Surface and Coatings Technology, 138(2-3), pp.149-158. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0257-8972(00)01141-5.

Tucker, R.C., 2013. ASM hand-book:Thermal spray technology 5A, Materials Park, OH:ASM International.

Yang, H., Luan, W. & Tu, S-T., 2006. Corrosion Behavior and Thermal Conductivity of Plasma Sprayed AlN/Al2O3 Coating. Materials Transactions, 47(7), pp.1649-1653. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.2320/matertrans.47.1649.

ИСПЫТАНИЯ МЕХАНИЧЕСКИХ СТРУКТУРНЫХ ХАРАКТЕРИСТИК ОКСИДНОЙ КЕРАМИКИ А12Оз НА ИЗНОСОСТОЙКОСТЬ ПРИ ТРЕНИИ СКОЛЬЖЕНИЯ

Михаило Р. Мрдак

Центр исследований и развития А.О. «ИМТЕЛ коммуникации», г. Белград, Республика Сербия

ОБЛАСТЬ: химические технологии

ВИД СТАТЬИ: оригинальная научная статья

ЯЗЫК СТАТЬИ: английский

Резюме:

А120з является твердой оксидной керамикой, которая обладает биоинертными свойствами и отличается высокой

стойкостью на скольжение, благодаря чему она широко применяется в проектировании инженерных компонентов. Цель исследования заключалась в приспособлении APS S процесса нанесения плазменного напыления, путем изменения плазменного потока, формирующего слои А!203, обладающие такими структурными и механическими характеристиками, которые могли бы найти применение в производстве биомедицинских покрытий, как в отдельности, так ив ¡? комбинации с гидроксиапатитом, в частности для Л поверхности сплавов, используемых в изготовлении имплантов. Покрытие нанесено плазменной струей 700, 800 и 900А. Механические характерики покрытия испытаны в соответствии со стандартами Pratt & Whitney.

Форма частиц порошка и поверхность покрытия испытаны методом SEM. Металлографический анализ внутренних слоев

проведен с помощью световой микроскопии. |

Лучшие структурные и механические карактеристики Л120з

покрытия выявлены у покрытий, нанесенных при 900А, ^

испытана стойкость на скольжение, путем нанесения на °

уплотнительное кольцо в паре с графитовым кольцом, о

защищающее гидравличиский тормоз и путем шлифования < покрытия до зеркального блеска.

Ключевые слова: скольжение, свойство, оксиды, механические ~ свойства, нанесение, покрытие, А1203.

(Л

о го

ИСПИТИВА^Е МЕХАНИЧКИХ СТРУКТУРНИХ

го .с

КАРАКТЕРИСТИКА ОКСИДНЕ КЕРАМИКЕ AI2O3 |

ОТПОРНЕ НА КЛИЗА^Е ТРЕ^ЕМ

Михаило Р. Мрдак

Истраживачки и разводи центар ИМТЕЛ Комуникаци]е а. д., Београд,

Република Срби]а .9

го

ОБЛАСТ: хеми]ске технологи]е <j

ВРСТА ЧЛАНКА: оригинални научни чланак Е JЕЗИК ЧЛАНКА: енглески

Сажетак:

Л120з je тврда оксидна керамика, xeMujcKu биоинертна са добрим клизним своjствима, ща je нашла широку примену у проjeктовану инженерских компоненти. Цил> рада био je да се APS процесом са променом плазма струje произведу слоjeви Al203 структурних и механичких карактеристика щи Ье наЬи примену за производну биомедицинских превлака засебно или у комбинации са хидроксиапатитом (ХА) на површинама легура ще се користе за израду импланата. Превлака je депонована

ГО тз

щ са плазма cmpyjOM 700, 800 и 900 А. Механичке

карактеристике превлаке испитане су применом стандарда Pratt & Whitney. Облик површине честица праха и површина ё превлаке испитана jе методом SEM. Металографска анализа

5 унутрашъих слоjева испитана jе светлосном микроскопирм.

> Наjбол>е структурне и механичке карактеристике Л120з

превлаке депоноване са 900 А потвр^ене су испитиваъем клизних своjсmава превлаке депоновне и полиране до огледала of на заптивном прстену упареном са графитним прстеном на

воденоj кочници.

о Къучне речи: клизаъе, своjсmво, оксиди, механичка своjсmва,

о депозити, превлаке, Al203.

<

Paper received on / Дата получения работы / Датум приема чланка: 08.10.2016. не Manuscript corrections submitted on / Дата получения исправленной версии работы ^ / Датум достав^а^а исправки рукописа: 16.01.2017.

Paper accepted for publishing on / Дата окончательного согласования работы / Датум коначног прихвата^а чланка за об]ав^ива^е: 18.01.2017.

<

© 2017 The Author. Published by Vojnotehnicki glasnik / Military Technical Courier (www.vtg.mod.gov.rs, втг.мо.упр.срб). This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/rs/).

W

^t © 2017 Автор. Опубликовано в «Военно-технический вестник / Vojnotehnicki glasnik / Military CD Technical Courier» (www.vtg.mod.gov.rs, втг.мо.упр.срб). Данная статья в открытом доступе и

распространяется в соответствии с лицензией «Creative Commons» >0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/rs/).

© 2017 Аутор. Обjавио Воjнотехнички гласник / Vojnotehnicki glasnik / Military Technical . Courier (www.vtg.mod.gov.rs, втг.мо.упр.срб). Ово je чланак отвореног приступа и О дистрибуира се у складу са Creative Commons licencom g (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/rs/).

®