Possibility of Measuring of Erythrocyte Size Distribution Parameters by Laser Diffractometry of a Blood Smear
Sergey Yu. Nikitin, Evgeniy G. Tsybrov*, Maria S. Lebedeva, Andrei E. Lugovtsov, and Alexander V. Priezzhev
M. V. Lomonosov Moscow State University, GSP-1 Leninskie Gory, Moscow 119991, Russian Federation *e-mail: [email protected]
Abstract. We consider the issues of obtaining information about the distribution of red blood cells in size from the scattering pattern of a laser beam on a wet blood smear. Within this article it is assumed to calculate the first three moments of the size distribution. The analytical model of light diffraction by blood smears was developed, as well as numerical experiments for verification suggested approach were carried out. The possibility of calculating average diameter of erythrocyte, width and asymmetry of size distribution by analyzing the angular distribution of light intensity in the diffraction pattern was shown. © 2024 Journal of Biomedical Photonics & Engineering.
Keywords: light scattering; laser diffractometry; data processing algorithms; red blood cells; size distribution; asymmetry.
Paper #9103 received 28 Apr 2024; revised manuscript received 20 May 2024; accepted for publication 20 May 2024; published online 29 Aug 2024. doi: 10.18287/JBPE24.10.040302.
1 Introduction
In the human circulatory system, the microrheological properties of blood play an important role. The main microrheological parameters include the deformability and aggregation ability of erythrocytes [1]. The size distribution of red blood cells also affects the rheology of blood [2]. The importance of this distribution is evidenced, in particular, by the fact that the width of the erythrocyte size distribution is a reliable predictor of mortality in the general population of adults aged 45 years and older [3]. Typically, red blood cell size distribution is measured using a Coulter counter or flow cytometer [4-6]. Other measurement methods are also being developed, such as digital microscopy [7], hyperspectral holography [8], and laser diffractometry [9-14]. The advantage of the laser diffractometry method is that this method allows one to quickly process large ensembles of red blood cells without requiring complex equipment such as microscopes, microchannels, high-speed electronic circuits, etc.
The laser diffractometry method is based on the effect of scattering of a laser beam on a blood smear or a thin layer of red blood cell suspension. With such scattering, a pattern appears that resembles the pattern of light diffraction by a round aperture (the so-called Airy
pattern). The picture has axial symmetry. In its center there is a bright spot, the brightness of which decreases as the scattering angle increases. As a rule, this spot is surrounded by a dark ring, behind which a faint light ring is visible. The task of laser diffractometry is to determine the parameters of an ensemble of red blood cells based on measurements of the characteristics of the diffraction pattern. Note that the quality of the diffraction pattern strongly depends on the method of preparing the blood smear and its quality. For more details on this, see Ref. [15].
Some theoretical aspects of laser diffractometry of erythrocytes were considered in Refs. [16-20]. It is known that the angular size of the first dark ring in the diffraction pattern determines the average size of the red blood cells on the blood smear. The visibility of this ring determines the size distribution width of red blood cells. In this work, we identify the parameters of the diffraction pattern that determine the asymmetry of the size distribution of erythrocytes.
2 Characteristics of the Diffraction Pattern
Fig. 1 shows an example of a diffraction pattern that occurs when a laser beam is scattered on a blood smear, and the angular distribution of light intensity in this pattern I = 1(9). Normalizing this distribution to the
intensity of the central diffraction maximum /(0), we obtain the function
/(e) = Ml
' V J /(0)
Let us consider a fragment of the diffraction pattern lying near the first minimum of light intensity (the first dark ring). In this region, the function J(0) can be approximately represented as
/(0)=/(0o)+f/"(0oM0
0o)2.
(1)
Here e0 is the angular coordinate of the first minimum of light intensity in the diffraction pattern, determined by the condition
m) = 0,
(2)
(a)
(b)
Fig. 1 (a) Diffraction pattern obtained from a wet blood smear and (b) the angular distribution of light intensity in this pattern. Laser wavelength X = 650 nm.
where /''(90) is the second derivative of the function f(0) with respect to the scattering angle, taken at 9 = 90. Let us introduce the dimensionless parameter
/2 = /"(0o) • e0 and denote
m) = /0.
(3)
(4)
The parameters 90 and /0 are shown in the graph of the function /(9) in Fig. 1b. These parameters, as well as the /2 parameter, can be measured in an experiment on scattering of a laser beam on a blood smear.
3 Parameters of the Erythrocyte Ensemble
We will consider the red blood cells on a blood smear to be round discs and characterize them with radii fl. The applicability of this model is justified by the fact that in the region of the diffraction pattern of interest to us, the indicatrix of light scattering by a biconcave disk and a flat disk differ negligibly little from each other [18]. Taking into account the scatter of red blood cells in size, we will consider the radius of the red blood cell to be a random variable and describe it with the following Eq.:
R = flo •(I + £).
(5)
Here R0 is the average radius of red blood cells on a blood smear, e is a random parameter, the average value of which is considered equal to zero
<£> = 0.
(6)
The size distribution of red blood cells will be characterized by the parameters
M = <e2>
and
v = ( e3>.
(7)
(8)
The 0 value characterizes the width, and the v value characterizes the asymmetry of the size distribution of erythrocytes. When calculating diffraction patterns, we will use the approximation of a weakly inhomogeneous ensemble of red blood cells. Mathematically, this approximation is expressed by the Eq.:
|e| « 1. (9)
For convenience, we also introduce the parameters
= (10)
and
/ = Vv.
(11)
Our task is to express the parameters of erythrocytes R0,M, v through the characteristics of the diffraction
pattern 90,f0,f2 and to construct an algorithm for measuring the average radius of an erythrocyte, as well as the width and asymmetry of the size distribution of erythrocytes using laser diffractometry of a blood smear.
4 Diffractometric Equations
Following the works [16, 17], we will model red blood cells as transparent flat disks. The angular distribution of light intensity in the diffraction pattern arising when a laser beam is scattered on a blood smear is approximately described by the following Eq.:
I(e)=1l0Nlal2Q)2{R4G(kRe)). (12)
Here I is the light intensity at a given point of the observation screen, R is the radius of a red blood cell, в is the scattering angle, I0 is the intensity of the incident laser beam, N is the number of red blood cells on the blood smear illuminated by the laser, z is the distance from the blood smear to the observation screen, к = 2n/X is the wave number, X is the light wavelength, the parameter lal2 characterizes the thickness and optical density of the red blood cell, angle brackets indicate averaging over the size of the red blood cells. The function G, called the Airy function, is defined by the Eq.:
G(x) = [^]2
(13)
where A(x) is the first order Bessel function. The Airy function satisfies the condition G(0) = 1. Eq. (12) was obtained in the single scattering approximation and describes the distribution of light intensity in the far diffraction zone in that part of the observation screen where the radiation of the direct laser beam does not impinge. Let us represent the normalized distribution of light intensity in the diffraction pattern f(8) in the form
(p4)f(9) = (р4С(рв)).
Here
p = kR = 2n-
X
(14)
(15)
is red blood cell size parameter.
Let us consider a limited part of the diffraction pattern located near the first minimum of light intensity. Mathematically, this region is determined by the condition p9 « x0, where the value x0 is determined by the equation
h(x0) = 0.
Here
x0 = 3.8318.
Expanding the Bessel function into a Taylor series in the vicinity of the point x0, we obtain
AW = J'i(Xq) • (X - Xo) + 1J'L'(X0) • (x - x0)2 +
+ \K'(x0)<x-xoy.
In the region 0.5 < x/x0 < 1.3 the error of this approximation does not exceed 3%. The derivatives of the Bessel function included in this expression can be calculated using the Eqs. [21]:
/0М = -Ji(x),
/1 (x) =Jo(x)--k(x).
(17)
In this approximation, for the function f(d) we obtain the expression
(p4)f = (p4H(y)), where
рв
У
Xo
(18)
(19)
is the normalized scattering angle. The function H(y) is defined by the following Eq.:
where
V(y) = XaJl(xo) • (y — 1) +\xlK(xo) ■
(y-1)2+±x30J["(x0)^(y-1)3.
Using Eqs. (17), we obtain
H (x) = --Jo(x) + (-1+2)h(x),
Jl"(x) = (-1+3)[jo(x)-lh(x)].
Here J0(x) is the zeroth order Bessel function. In particular, for x = x0
J'i (*o) =Jo(*o),
JÏ (to) = —~Jo(xo),
Xo 1+-
Ji (Хо) = (—1+^]]о(Хо)
(16)
Let us denote
Jo(xo) = —P.
(20)
Here
ß = 0.40276. (21)
Then
;i(*„) = -ß,
Zl'feO^ß,
Xo
;i"(^o) = (l-;3?)ß.
The functions ^(y) and H(y) take the form
^(y) = ay3 — ôy2 + cy — d
and
H(y) = cxy4 — C2y3 + C3y2 — C4y +
+c5—^ + %
5 y y0
(22)
where
a = ^°(x0 — 3), ô=^3(x2 — 4), c=^3(x2 —7), d=-^(x2 — 12)
(23)
and
aô = c,
(2ac + ô2)-^ = c3,
X0
(a d + ôc) —2 = c4,
X0
(c2 + 2ô d)4= C5,
(24)
c d"2 = c6,
Xo
d2 4 = c7.
x0
Thus, the normalized angular distribution of light intensity in the diffraction pattern is represented as a polynomial relative to the normalized scattering angle. This distribution is expressed by Eqs. (18), (19), (22).
Derivatives of the function /(0) /(n)(0)=^/(0)
are expressed by the following Eqs.:
<p4>Xo/(1)(9) = <p5tf(1)(y)>, <p4>x0/(2)(9) = <p6tf(2)(y)>
where
tf(1)(y) = g = 4ciy3 - 3c2y2 + 2c3y - c4+i| -2^3, ^(2)(y) = g = 12ciy2 - 6c2y + 2C3-2 ^ + 6^.
The functions /(n)(9) are also polynomials with respect to the normalized scattering angle.
Let us find the angular coordinate 90 of the minimum light intensity in the diffraction pattern. Assuming
/(1)(9o) = 0
we get the Eq.:
<p5tfM(yo)> = 0,
where
00
yo=P-
Xo
From here
<p5 (4Ciy3 - 3c2yo2 + 2c3yo - c4 + - 2^)> = 0
or
4 cx (p5y0) — 3c2<psy0> + 2c3<p5yo> — C4<ps> +
„5 „5
+C6 &> — 2C7 <^> = 0.
y0
Vo3'
Here
<p5yo> = <p8>,
Aft
<p5yo> = "0 <p7>,
An
<p5yo>="°<p6>,
Xo
52
<^> = "0<p3>, yo "o
5 3
0 = "3<p2>.
yo "o
Now
4 ci~3<p8> — 3c2"|<p7> + 2C3 "°,<p6> — C4<p5>+
Xo
+c6A0 <p3> — 2c7A3<p2> = 0.
Let us consider a weakly inhomogeneous ensemble of erythrocytes. From Eqs. (9) and (15) it follows that
4
2
a -j = ci
X
X
o
o
o
o
P = Po'(1 + where
(P) = Po
is the average size of a red blood cell on a blood smear. Let us enter the parameters
mn = (-Q={(1 + e)n).
Po
Then
(pn) = mnp0 and the equation for the angle 90 takes the form
03 O
4ci:jm8p0 — 3c2-°2m7p70 + 2c3-°m6p0
e20
Xo
Si ^0 3 O ^0 2 r\
c4m5Po + Ce-â^sPê - 2c7i3m2P2 = 0
°0
or
Q3 q2 Q
4ciz3™-8po — 3c2 ~°Lm7Po + 2C3Z°m6Po -
2 3
-C4m5 + c6~202m3 — 2c7 73T5m2 =
aoPo VaPa
Let us denote
. eo „ Z = -p0.
Xo
Then
Ac^qZ3 — 3c2m.7Z2 + 2c3m6z — c4m5 + 1 1
+c6m3-^—2c7m2~3= 0
or
4c1msz6 — 3c2m7z5 + 2c3m6z4 —c4m5z3 + c6m3z — 2c7m2 = 0.
(25)
Proceeding in the same way as when deriving Eq. (25), we obtain two more Eqs.:
m4z2f0 = c1m8z6 — c2m7z5 + c3m6z4 —
14A —^2^7
—c4m?z3 + Cc,mAz2 — c.m^z + c7m-
m4z2f2 = 12c1m8z6 — 6c2m7z5 + +2c3m6z4 — 2c6m3z + 6c7m2.
(26)
Here the parameters f0 and f2 are determined by Eqs. (3), (4). For a weakly inhomogeneous ensemble of erythrocytes, the parameters mn are related to the values of n and v by the relations
m2 = 1 + ß,
(27)
m3 = 1 + 3ß + v, m4 = 1 + 6ß + 4v, m5 = 1 + 10ß + 10v, m6 = 1 + 15ß + 20v, m7 = 1 + 21ß + 35v, m8 = 1 + 28ß + 56v.
From Eqs. (23), (24) it follows that there are certain relationships between the coefficients of Eqs. (25), (26). These relations are expressed by the following Eqs. :
4c1 — 3c2 + 2c3 — c4 + c6 — 2c7 = 0,
Ci — C2 + C3 — C4 + C5 — c6 + C7 = 0, (28)
12c1 — 6c2 + 2c3 — 2c6 + 6c7 = 8ß2.
For a weakly inhomogeneous ensemble of erythrocytes, we will look for a solution to Eqs. (25), (26) in the form
z = 1 + a, (29)
where lal « 1
is a small parameter. Then, in an approximation linear in this parameter
zn = 1 + na.
(30)
Let us introduce the values Mn, defining them by the Eqs.:
mn = 1 + Mn.
From Eq. (27) it follows that
IMJ « 1,
(31)
M2 = ß, M4 = 6ß + 4v,
M3 = 3ß + v, M5 = 10ß + 10v,
(32)
M6 = 15ß + 20v, M7 = 21ß + 35v, M8 = 28ß + 56v.
Substituting Eqs. (30), (31) into Eqs. (25), (26) and taking into account Eqs. (28), (32), we obtain the following Eqs.:
Ciaa + c^p + clvv = 0,
(1 + 6y + 4v + 2a) fo = C2aa + 02^ + ^2Vv, (33) (1 + + 4v + 2a)f2 = 8@2 + c3aa + + c3vv.
Here
3
a = T°po — 1.
Xo
(34)
The numbers x0 and p are defined by Eqs. (16) and (21). The remaining coefficients are determined by the following Eqs.
cla = 24q - 15c2 + 8c3 - 3c4 + c6,
clM = 112q — 63c2 + 30c3 — 10c4 + 3c6 — 2c7, (35)
c1v = 224^ — 105c2 + 40 c3 — 10c4 + c6,
From Eq. (39) it follows that
M I 2 2
a =---+ -x2v.
2 3 o
(42)
Substituting Eq. (42) into Eqs. (40), (41), we obtain ¿[l + 5ß + 4v(l+f)]/)=ß + ^
^[l + 5^ + 4v(l+X°)]/2=
= 1 — (2xo2 — l)ß — (7xo2 — l0)v.
(43)
c2a = — 5c2 + 4c3 — 3c4 + 2c5 — c6,
c2m = 28ci — 21c2 + 15c3 — 10c4 + 6c5 — 3c6 + c7,
(36)
c2v = 56^ — 35c2 + 20c3 — 10c4 + 4c5 — c6,
Eqs. (42) and (43) solve the problem. They relate the characteristics of the diffraction pattern e0, /0, /2 with the parameters of the ensemble of erythrocytes p0, m, v. The solution to these equations taking into account Eqs. (16), (21) has the form
c3a = 72q — 30c2 + 8c3 — 2c6,
c3M = 336C-l — 126c2 + 30c3 — 6c6 + 6c7,
c3v = 672cl — 210c2 + 40c3 — 2c6.
(37)
From Eqs. (23), (24), (35) - (37) it follows that
CiB = 8ß2,
C1v =
= 0,
c im = 4ß2
C2M = 4ß2,
4ß2
(38)
C3« = —40ß2, C3m = —4(4 xo + 3)ß2, c3v = —8(11x2 — 30)ß2.
Substituting Eq. (38) into Eq. (33), we obtain the following Eqs. :
8ß2a + 4ß2ß—^2x2v = 0,
(l + 6ß + 4v + 2a)/o = 4ß2ß + 4ß2v, (l + 6ß + 4v + 2a)/2 =
= 8ß2 — 40ß2a — 4(4xo + 3)ß2ß — 8 (11x2 — 30)ß2v
or
2a + ß — 4xov = 0,
^(l + 6ß + 4v + 2a)/ = ß + v,
-^(l + 6ß + 4v + 2a)/2 =
= l —5a-
(2xo2+3)ß — 1(llxo2 — 30)v
(39)
(40)
(41)
ß
-1.2977+233/d+/0 83.7+4io/o + 18.6/2 '
v = 12977-667/o-/o (44) 83.7+4io/o+18.6/2' V 7
5 Measurement Algorithm
The algorithm for measuring parameters ju\v',p0 is expressed by the Eqs.:
ß =
v =
-1.2977+233/d+/0 83.7+410/0 + 18.6/0,
3 ( 1.2977-66.7/o-/0 83.7+410/0 + 18.6/0,
po = (l
0.5ß + 9.79v)383.
"o
(45)
(46)
(47)
The average diameter of a red blood cell on a blood smear can be found using the following Eq.:
D = l.22 • (l
"o
0.5ß + 9.79v ).
(48)
In these Eqs., p0,0', v' are the parameters of the size distribution of red blood cells, 90,/0,/2 are the characteristics of the diffraction pattern that occurs when the laser beam is scattered on a blood smear, X is the laser wavelength. Namely, p0 is the average size parameter of the erythrocyte, is the relative width of the distribution of erythrocytes along the radii, v' is the asymmetry coefficient of the distribution of erythrocytes along the radii, 90 is the scattering angle at which the first minimum light intensity in the diffraction pattern is achieved, /0 - relative light intensity in the first minimum, /2 - relative curvature of the angular distribution of light intensity at the first minimum intensity. The parameters X, 90,/0,/2 can be measured in an experiment by scattering a laser beam on a blood smear. The indicated values are mathematically determined by Eqs. (1) - (11).
On the stability of the algorithm. Estimates show that for the conditions of interest to us, the denominators of
Eqs. (44) weakly depend on the parameters /0 and /2, which are the input data for the algorithm. If we neglect this dependence, then the parameters 0 and v become linear functions of the parameters /0 and /2. This means that the relative error in measuring the parameters 0 and v is the same as the relative error in measuring the diffraction pattern parameters /0 and /2. Further, by virtue of Eqs. (44) - (46), the relative error in measuring the parameter 0' is two times, and the parameter v' is three times less than the relative error in measuring the parameters 0 and v. On this basis, we conclude that the measurement algorithm expressed by Eqs. (45), (46) is stable.
6 Verification of the Algorithm in a Numerical Experiment
Let us evaluate the accuracy of the algorithm using a model of a bimodal ensemble of red blood cells. This ensemble contains red blood cells of only two sizes. Let p1 be the size parameter of the first component of the ensemble, p2 be the size parameter of the second component of the ensemble, p be the fraction of particles of the first type. The parameters of the bimodal ensemble are found using the following Eqs.:
Po = <P> = P1P1 + P2P2,
Pi = Po(1 + £1), P2=Po(1 + ^2),
¿1=^—1,
1 Po
2 Po
(49)
M = (e2> = Pi£i2 + P2£22, v = ( e3> = pig3 + P2 £2.
The angular distribution of light intensity in the diffraction pattern arising when a laser beam is scattered on a bimodal ensemble of erythrocytes is described by the Eq. :
/(e)
_ PiP4G(p1e)+p2P4G(P2e) P1PÎ+P2P2
characteristics of bimodal ensembles (BME) and the results of calculations of the parameters of diffraction patterns are presented in Table 1. The numerical values of the erythrocyte size parameters are selected for the laser radiation wavelength X = 0.63 ^m.
We use the found values of the parameters 9o, /o and /2 as input data for the algorithm expressed by Eqs. (45) - (47). Using Eqs. (45) - (47), we calculate the parameters of the ensemble of erythrocytes P0,0', v' and compare the obtained values with the exact values of the parameters found using Eqs. (10), (11), (49). The calculation results are presented in Table 2. In this table, P0c, 0c, vC are the exact values of the parameters of bimodal ensembles of erythrocytes, found using Eqs. (10), (11), (49). Approximate values of these parameters, found using algorithm (45) - (47), are designated P0,^',v' . The errors in determining the parameters of an ensemble of erythrocytes using algorithm (45) - (47) are designated 5p0, 5v'. These errors are expressed as percentages.
Let us consider, as an example, the problem of reconstructing the parameters of a bimodal ensemble of erythrocytes from laser diffractometry data of a blood smear. The task is to determine the parameters of the bimodal ensemble p,p1,p2 from the measured parameters of the diffraction pattern 90,/0,/2. Using the following Eqs.:
P£1 + (1 — P)^2 = 0 M = P^ + (1 — P)^ v = pe3 + (1 — p)e|
we find [22]
p=i(l+T=2U=)
F 2 V VV2+4M3/
=
2M ,
where p1 = p, p2 = 1 - p, and the function G(x) is determined by Eq. (13). Setting the parameters of the bimodal ensemble p1, p2 and p, through numerical calculations we find the parameters of the diffraction pattern 90, /0 and /2, determined by Eqs. (2) - (4). The
Table 1 Parameters of diffraction patterns found by numerical experiment.
v+VV2+4U3 £2 = —- ,
2 2M Pi = Po • (l + £i), P2 = Po • (l + £2).
(50)
BME 1 BME 2 BME 3 BME 4 BME 5
Pi 35 33 32 31 30
P2 40 42 43 44 45
p 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4
0o,rad 0.1005 0.0984 0.0968 0.0948 0.0923
/0 0.002501 0.006984 0.009471 0.01181 0.01377
/2 1.141 0.887 0.7777 0.7011 0.680
Table 2 Results on the evaluation of parameters of RBC size distribution, obtained in the numerical experiment.
BME 1 BME 2 BME 3 BME 4 BME 5
Poc 38 38.4
Po 38 38.5
Sp0,% 0 0.3
6.45 11.5
tf, % 6.34 10.9
Sp',% 1.7 5.2
K -0.0478 -0.085
v' -0.0458 -0.081
Sv', % 4.2 4.7
Pc 0.4 0.4
p 0.41 0.40
Sp, % 2.5 0
Pic 35 33
Pi 35.1 34.1
Spi,% 0.3 3.3
Pic 40 42
P2 40 42.6
Sp2,% 0 1.4
The calculation results are presented in the same Table 2. In this table, Pc,Pic,P2c are the exact values of the parameters of bimodal ensembles of erythrocytes. Approximate values of these parameters, found using Eqs. (45) - (47), (50) based on the analysis of diffraction patterns, are designated p,p1,p2 . The errors in determining parameters using algorithm (45) - (47), (50) are designated Sp,Sp1,Sp2. These errors are expressed as percentages. Note that it is advisable to test the proposed algorithm on more complex models of red blood cell ensembles.
7 Discussion
In this paper we presented an algorithm to measure parameters of the size distribution of red blood cells on a blood smear. The algorithm is designed to measure the average size, as well as the width and asymmetry of the red blood cell size distribution. In the case of a bimodal ensemble of erythrocytes, these data make it possible to determine the individual size of the ensemble components under consideration, as well as the percentage ratio between them. The solution to the inverse scattering problem is presented in the form of explicit analytical expressions suitable for weakly homogeneous ensembles of erythrocytes. From a mathematical point of view, the possibility of analytically solving the inverse problem of scattering a laser beam on an inhomogeneous ensemble of red blood cells is associated with the use of two approximations. First, this
38.6 38.8 39
38.8 39.2 39.8
0.5 1 2
14.0 16.4 18.8
12.9 14.6 15.9
7.9 11 15
0.104 -0.122 -0.140
0.103 -0.124 -0.144
1.0 1.6 2.9
0.4 0.4 0.4
0.37 0.35 0.33
7.5 12.5 17.5
32 31 30
33.6 33.2 33.0
5.0 7.1 10
43 44 45
43.9 45.1 46.5
2.1 2.5 3.3
is a polynomial representation of the Bessel function and the Airy function, applicable to a limited part of the diffraction pattern that occurs when a laser beam is scattered on a blood smear. Second, the approximation of a weakly heterogeneous (in size) ensemble of erythrocytes. The first of these approximations makes it possible to write diffractometric equations in terms of elementary functions, the second makes it possible to linearize these equations with respect to small parameters and obtain their analytical solution. Both approximations introduce measurement errors, which we estimated using a numerical experiment. The results show that the error of the algorithm increases with increasing heterogeneity of the ensemble. The corresponding data are shown in Table 2. Thus, with an expansion of the size distribution of erythrocytes n' = 14%, the measurement error of the ensemble parameters is not more than 8%, and with
= 18.8% the measurement error reaches 17.5%. The results obtained can be used to create laser diffractometers of erythrocytes with expanded functionality.
For the practical implementation of the proposed measurement algorithm, several conditions must be met. Red blood cells on a blood smear should have their natural shapes, and their concentration should not be too high so that the condition of single light scattering is met. The laser beam must be sufficiently coherent. The width of the laser spectrum must be much less than its carrier frequency, and the coherence radius must significantly exceed the size of the red blood cell. Finally, the system
for recording diffraction patterns must have a sufficiently high resolution and a sufficiently wide dynamic range for measuring light intensity.
Let us also note the following circumstance. Eq. (48) shows that to accurately determine the average diameter of erythrocytes using laser diffractometry, it is necessary to know the width of the erythrocyte size distribution. This is due to the fact that the contribution of the red blood cell to the light intensity in the diffraction pattern is proportional to the fourth power of the radius of the red blood cell. In other words, the contribution of large erythrocytes dominates over the contribution of small erythrocytes. At a constant average radius of the erythrocyte, this leads to the fact that the scattering of erythrocytes in size shifts the minimum light intensity in the diffraction pattern to the region of small scattering angles. Therefore, the average size of a red blood cell on a blood smear depends not only on the angle 90, but also on the width of the red blood cell size distribution.
Our theoretical model is based on the assumption of weak heterogeneity of the erythrocyte ensemble. We call an ensemble weakly heterogeneous for which the scatter of erythrocyte sizes is small compared to the average size of an erythrocyte. For blood samples close to normal, this condition is well met. Mathematically, the condition is expressed by the formula ^«1. In the numerical experiment we use a model of a bimodal ensemble of red
blood cells. This model is convenient because it is characterized by a minimum number of parameters. In the case of pathological blood samples (for example, with sickle cell anemia), the visibility of the dark ring in the diffraction pattern can be significantly reduced, which will be interpreted by our algorithm as an abnormally large dispersion of red blood cells in size.
Our algorithm is based on processing the diffraction pattern in the region of the first dark ring. As a rule, there is such a ring. But if it is not there, then this may indicate the presence of a large number of irregularly shaped cells, for example, echinocytes, in the blood sample.
Acknowledgements
The theoretical part, development of theoretical experiment methodology, data analysis were supported by the Russian Science Foundation grant (No. 22-15-00120). Computer simulation of diffraction patterns was supported by the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation as part of the program of the Moscow Center for Fundamental and Applied Mathematics under the agreement No. 075-15-2022-284.
Disclosures
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
References
1. A. V. Muravyov, P. V. Mikhailov, and I. A. Tikhomirova, "Microcirculation and Hemorheology: points of interaction," Regional blood circulation and microcirculation 16(2), 90-100 (2017). [in Russian]
2. F. I. Ataullakhanov, D. V. Borsakova, E. S. Protasov, E. I. Sinauridze, and A. M. Zeynalov, "Erythrocyte: a bag with hemoglobin, or a living active cell?," Pediatric Hematology/Oncology and Immunopathology 17(1), 108-116 (2018). [in Russian]
3. K. V. Patel, L. Ferrucci, W. B. Ershler, D. L. Longo, and J. M. Guralnik, "Red Blood Cell Distribution Width and the Risk of Death in Middle-aged and Older Adults," Archives of Internal Medicine 169(5), 515 (2009).
4. A. Bogdanova, L. Kaestner, G. Simionato, A. Wickrema, and A. Makhro, "Heterogeneity of Red Blood Cells: Causes and Consequences," Frontiers in Physiology 11, 392 (2020).
5. J. Picot, C. L. Guerin, C. Le Van Kim, and C. M. Boulanger, "Flow cytometry: retrospective, fundamentals and recent instrumentation," Cytotechnology 64(2), 109-130 (2012).
6. R. Green, S. Wachsmann-Hogiu, "Development, History, and Future of Automated Cell Counters," Clinics in Laboratory Medicine 35(1), 1-10 (2015).
7. V. A. Dubrovskii, I. V. Zabenkov, E. P. Karpocheva, and S. O. Torbin, "Identification and Counting of Erythrocytes of Native Human Donor Blood by Digital Optical Microscopy Using Spectral Filtered Illumination," Optics and Spectroscopy 129(3), 315-328 (2021).
8. A. E. Lugovtsov, V. D. Ustinov, G. S. Kalenkov, S. G. Kalenkov, and A. V. Priezzhev, "Hyperspectral Holography and Laser Diffractometry of Erythrocytes," Journal of Biomedical Photonics & Engineering 6(2), 020306 (2020).
9. M. Bessis, "A diffractometric method for the measurement of cellular deformability," Blood Cells 1, 307-313 (1975).
10. Y. Yang, Z. Zhang, X. Yang, J. H. Yeo, L. Jiang, and D. Jiang, "Blood cell counting and classification by nonflowing laser light scattering method," Journal of Biomedical Optics 9(5), 995-1001 (2004).
11. Y. S. Yurchuk, V. D. Ustinov, S. Y. Nikitin, and A. V. Priezzhev, " Scattering of a laser beam on a wet blood smear and measurement of red cell size distribution," Quantum Electronics 46(6), 515-520 (2016).
12. P. S. Vinnikov, V. D. Ustinov, A. E. Shtanko, A. E. Lugovtsov, G. S. Kalenkov, and M. A. Karpilova, "A Mobile Device for Measuring the Size Distribution of Red Blood Cells," Biomedical Engineering 54(1), 6-8 (2020).
13. M. A. Casas-Ramos, G. E. Sandoval-Romero, "Yeast cells characterization through near-forward light scattering," Optical and Quantum Electronics 52(3), 159 (2020).
14. M. J. Berg, S. C. Hill, G. Videen, and K. P. Gurton, "Spatial filtering technique to image and measure two-dimensional near-forward scattering from single particles," Optics Express 18(9), 9486-9495 (2010).
15. M. S. Lebedeva, E. G. Tsybrov, and A. E. Nikandrova, "Experiments on laser diffractometry of blood smears," Proceedings of the XVI International Scientific and Technical Conference "Optical Methods of Flow Investigation", Moscow, 175-182 (2021).
16. S. Y. Nikitin, A. E. Lugovtsov, and A. V. Priezzhev, "On the problem of visibility of the diffraction pattern in laser diffractometry of red blood cells," Quantum Electronics 40(12), 1074-1076 (2010).
17. S. Y. Nikitin, A. E. Lugovtsov, A. V. Priezzhev, and V. D. Ustinov, "Relation between the diffraction pattern visibility and dispersion of particle sizes in an ektacytometer," Quantum Electronics 41(9), 843-846 (2011).
18. S. Yu. Nikitin, A. V. Priezzhev, and A. E. Lugovtsov, "Analysis of laser beam scattering by an ensemble of particles modeling red blood cells in ektacytometer," Journal of Quantitative Spectroscopy and Radiative Transfer 121, 1-8 (2013).
19. V. D. Ustinov, "On inverse reconstruction problems of the erythrocyte size distribution in laser diffractometry," Mathematical Models and Computer Simulations 9(5), 561-569 (2017).
20. G. P. Sarkisyan, Theoretical description of diffraction of laser radiation on erythrocytes monolayer, NAS of Armenia. Reports. Optics. Biophysics 120(1), 45-51 (2020). [in Russian]
21. F. Emde, Tables of higher functions, B. G. Teubner Verlagsgesellschaft, Leipzig, Germany (1960).
22. S. Yu. Nikitin, V. D. Ustinov, S. D. Shishkin, and M. S. Lebedeva, "Line curvature algorithm in laser ektacytometry of red blood cells," Quantum Electronics 50(9), 888-894 (2020).