CC BY
49
Investigating the effects of wrestling gear in flatfoot deformity of wrestlers
Acak M.1ABCDE, Korkmaz M.F.2ABCDE, Taskiran C.1ABCDE, Demirkan E.3ABCDE 1 Inonu University Faculty of Sport Sciences, Malatya, Turkey 2 Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, Istanbul Medeniyet University School of Medicine, Istanbul, Turkey
3 Hitit University Faculty of Sport Sciences, Corum, Turkey
Authors' contributions: A - Study design; B - Data collection; C - Statistical analysis; D - Manuscript Preparation; E - Funds Collection. Abstract Purpose:
Material:
Results:
Conclusions:
Keywords:
In this study, our aim was to determine the effects of wrestling shoes, wrestling mats and wrestling styles on postural deformation of the foot and to elaborate its possible causes.
Study group comprised of 158 athletes (109 males, 59 females) from 26 different countries who participated in the 12th World University Wrestling Championship. Of the athletes, 102 (59 females, 43 males) performed in freestyle and 56 performed in Greco-Roman style. The age range of the athletes was 19 to 31 years and they have done wrestling for 3 to 18 years. Were evaluated to determine the relationship between flatfoot deformity and gender, age, wrestling style and years in the sport. Footprint parameters were used to determine and evaluate the overall structure of the foot. The Staheli and the Chippaux-Smirak indexes were used in the study. Statistical analyses were performed using the SPSS v.21.0 software, with the significance level set at a=0.05.
No significant relationship was found either between the gender of the wrestlers or their age and their
pes planus state. A significant relationship was detected between the wrestling style performed and the
wrestlers' pes planus state, and between the years in the sport and their pes planus state.
The fact that wrestlers wear the wrestling shoes for a long time can be a cause of pes planus. The center
of mass of freestyle wrestlers shifts during continuous feet movement, and the surface of their soles
extends the contact surface on the mat to maintain balance. This situation can also lead to a higher
prevalence of pes planus in wrestlers. In addition, the wrestling shoes wrap around the Achilles tendon
and thus the stretching of this tendon is restricted. Such restriction strengthens the opinion that freestyle
wrestlers experience pes planus more.
flatfoot; pes planus; postural distortion; wrestling.
Introduction
Physical structures formed due to the movements in different sport subdivisions differ from each other in terms of both posture features and anthropometric features [1]. Studies report that sport subdivisions demonstrate differences in postural forms [2]. Wrestling is a performance sport and it requires one to be physically healthy and balanced in addition to features such as physiological, psychological, technical, tactical, strength, and agility. Among these features, balance has a different aspect in wrestling. Foot posture plays an important role in maintaining balance. Pes planus, which distorts foot posture, is a foot deformation that is characterized by the inner longitudinal arch's disappearance and the heel's outer movement. Medically, pes planus, expressed as flat feet, is the flattening or disappearance of one of the longitudinal or transverse arches. This condition rules out the springiness of the foot and obstructs normal movements during walking or running. In another expression, pes planus is defined as when the "foot's medial longitudinal arch's heights decrease or the deformation caused by its total collapse" [3]. Pes planus disorder is characterized by the foot arch's flatness in the medial part and the contact of the whole foot with the ground. The reason for this disease, which usually does not cause pain, may be the nonformation of foot arches in © Acak M., Korkmaz M.F., Taskiran C., Demirkan E., 2020 doi:10.15561/26649837.2020.0301
childhood. The rate of pes planus in 3-year-old children is 44%, whereas it decreases to 24% in 6-year-old children
[4]. Daneshmandi, Rahnema, and Mehdizadeh reported a meaningful relationship between obesity and pes planus
[5].
In recent years, heavy training techniques have been employed by athletes at an early age. Such training practices may bring about significant changes in the body as the musculoskeletal system is not mature enough [6]. Hawkins et al. reported that when an athlete, a tennis player for example, is exposed to a unilateral overload, he may display an apparent inconsistency, such as increased external rotation and decreased internal rotation of one foot compared to the other [7]. It is known that sport-specific training and repeated practices may have an effect on the arch index of the sole of the athletes [6]. Gymnasts who begin training at early ages, weightlifters who lift enormous weights during training periods and wrestlers who require complex and heavy training sessions are included in this category. The arch of the foot develops and strengthens in early childhood as a part of normal growth of bones, ligaments, muscles and tendons. When misalignment or deformation of the bones, or weakening of the tendon or ligament occur, a postural defect of the foot, such as pes planus, can pose serious problems [8].
Pes planus has two clinical forms; flexible and rigid. Using insoles is a basic application suggested for
2020
individuals with pes planus. Depending on the severity and the type of the deformity; whether pediatric or adult, congenital or acquired or flexible or rigid, several types of orthoses may be used in the treatment of pes planus [9, 10]. It is important to determine the factors involved in forming and maintaining the arches of the foot, and to evaluate the foot posture correctly in order to identify flatfoot deformity and differentiate cases that need treatment from those that need only reassurance [8]. Doctors often suggest using insoles made of steel arches and leather surfaces with shock-absorbing material, such as silicon or semi-rubber [11]. Agak [12] and Yurt [13] reported that the use of insoles in pes planus reduced the pain and the subjects got tired later than usual. Nevertheless, it should be noted that these insoles do not provide the original setting for a standard arch's height, but are rather used only for pain-relief purposes.
Wrestling was first performed barefoot on a dirt surface in the 1st Modern Olympics in Athens in 1896, whereas it was practiced on thick and soft mats and with leather shoes, which covered ankles tightly, in London in 1908 [12]. These high neck wrestling shoes used in the London Olympics made it to our day with almost the same features. The shoes do not have any elevation in the heel or any orthopedic insole. It is still debatable whether the foot arch morphology or the use of flat shoes causes pes planus in athletes. The literature holds no study on postural distortion of the foot in wrestlers. The lack of elevation in the heel or an orthopedic support causes postural distortions on the soles of wrestlers, which constitutes the topic of our study. Thus, the aim of this study was to determine the effects of wrestling shoes, wrestling mats and wrestling styles on postural deformation of the foot and to elaborate possible causes. We hypothesized that the foot structure would be affected by wearing the wrong wrestling shoes, thus showing an increased eversion at the mid-stance phase.
Material and Methods
Participants: The study was designed based on the quantitative screening model to evaluate the flatfoot deformity of wrestlers. Our study group comprised of 158 athletes (109 males, 59 females) from 26 different countries who participated in the 12th World University Wrestling Championship. Of the athletes, 102 (59 females, 43 males) performed in freestyle and 56
performed in Greco-Roman style. The age range of the athletes was 19 to 31 years and they have done wrestling for 3 to 18 years. The participants were categorized under four different age groups: those 19 years old and under, 20 to 23 years old, 24 to 27 years old and 28 years old and above. The athletes were also categorized according to the time they performed the sport: 5 years or less, 6 to 10 years and 11 years or more.
Procedure: Footprint parameters were used to determine and evaluate the overall structure of the foot. An evaluation form was created after receiving the approval of the officials of the championship, and measurements were made based on this form. The Staheli and the Chippaux-Smirak indexes were used in the study [14].
Statistical analysis: Statistical analyses of the data were performed using the SPSS v.21.0 software. The significance level in comparisons was set at a=0.05. The chi-square test was used in the evaluation of the qualitative data and the significance of the difference between the observed and expected frequencies.
Results
The prevalence of flatfoot was 18.4% in female wrestlers and 19.3% in males. The chi-square test revealed no significant relationship between the gender of the wrestlers and their pes planus state (n=158; X2=0.018, df=1, p>0.05) (Table 1).
The prevalence of flatfoot was 10.5% in the wrestlers that are 19 years old or younger, 15.7% in those who are 20 to 23 years old, 26.2% in the 24 to 27 years old wrestlers and 28.6% in the 28 years old and above. The chi-square test revealed no significant relationship between the age of the wrestlers and their pes planus state (n=158; X2=3.733, df=3, p>0.05) (Table 2).
The prevalence of flatfoot was 22.5% in the freestyle wrestlers and 12.5% in the Greco-Roman style wrestlers. The chi-square test revealed a significant relationship between the style performed and the wrestlers' pes planus state (n=158; X2=18.234, df=1, p<0.05) (Table 3).
Regardless of the gender and style of the sport performed, the prevalence of flatfoot was 9.1% in wrestlers who wrestled for 5 years or less, 13.6% in wrestlers who wrestled for 6 to 10 years and 28.8% in wrestlers who wrestled for 11 years or more. The chi-square test revealed a significant relationship between the years in the sport and the wrestlers' pes planus state (n=158; X2=6.042, df=2, p<0.05) (Table 4).
Table 1. Prevalence of flatfoot based on gender
Pes planus state
Participants Not present Present
n % n %
Woman 40 81.6 9 18.4
Male 88 80.7 21 19.3
Total 128 81.0 30 19.0
X2=0.018, df=1, p=0.894
Table 2. Prevalence of flatfoot based on age groups
Pes planus state
Age group Not present Present
n % n %
19 years old and under 17 89.5 2 10.5
20 to 23 years old 70 84.3 13 15.7
24 to 27 years old 31 73.8 11 26.2
28 years old and above 10 71.4 4 28.6
Total 128 81.0 30 19.0
X2=3.733, df=3, p=0.064
Table 3. Prevalence of flatfoot based on style
Pes planus state
Style Not present Present
n % n %
Freestyle 79 77.5 23 22.5
Greco-Roman style 49 87.5 7 12.5
Total 128 81.0 30 19.0
X2=18.234, df=1, p=0.44
Table 4. Prevalence of flatfoot based on years in the sport
Pes planus state
Years in the sport Not present Present
n % n %
5 years or less 10 90.9 1 9.1
6 to 10 years 76 86.4 12 13.6
11 years or more 42 71.2 17 28.8
Total 128 81.0 30 19.0
X2=6.042, df=2, p=0.049
Discussion
The results of our study, which exhibit a significant relationship between the wrestling style and pes planus state of freestyle and Greco-Roman wrestlers (Table 3), are in concordance with those of Ta§kiran et al. [15] Their leaning forward further, standing on their feet spread sideways for balance and pulling and pushing the opponent forward, backward, and sideways may be an important factor of higher prevalence of flatfoot deformity in freestyle wrestlers in comparison to the Greco-Roman style performers. The surface of the sole extends the contact surface with the mat, or the contact surface may be wider than desired due to the shock-absorbency characteristics of the foam core. This might lead us to think that such incident may be a predisposing factor for higher incidence of flatfoot deformity among freestyle wrestlers. Moreover, by wrapping around it, the wrestling shoes avoid the movement of the Achilles tendon. The failure of the Achilles tendon to stretch supports the opinion of its predisposing effect in the higher incidence of flatfoot deformity among freestyle wrestlers.
Based on the age variable of the participants in our study, the prevalence of flatfoot was 10.5% in the 19 years old and younger wrestlers, 15.7% in the 20 to 23 years old wrestlers, 26.2% in the 24 to 27 years old wrestlers and 28.6% in the 28 years old and older wrestlers; showing a steady increase in the prevalence as the age went up (Table 2). However, no significant relationship was detected between the age of the wrestlers and their pes planus state. The prevalence of the deformity was higher in the male athletes, yet, the difference with their female counterparts was statistically insignificant (Table 1).
A significant relationship was detected between the years in the sport and the wrestlers' pes planus state (Table 4). The athletes were more prone to having flatfoot deformity as their years in the sport increased. Our results were accordant with the results from the study of Ta§kiran et al.,[15] in which postural deformities of the feet were examined. In another supporting study, Wojtys et al. suggested that frequent training sessions in early ages have an impact on the posture [16]. In their study on the height of the arch of athletes playing different sports, Aydog et al. observed that the prevalence of flatfoot among
2020
gymnasts was significantly lower than that of wrestlers [6]. Considering that the gymnasts from Ay dog et al.'s study had started sports four years before the participating wrestlers, our results exhibiting the relationship with the time spent in the sport and flatfoot deformity support the view that suggests that the prevalence of the deformity in wrestlers is higher.
As flatfoot patients lack a normal arch, the impact on the sole is dispersed without absorption. Forces exerted on the soles and upper parts of the body will cause a chain reaction in especially in the spine and lumbar spine [17]. Flatfoot deformity has been shown to cause pain while standing [18], walking and running [10]. The deformity has also shown a positive correlation with waist pain in the studies of Violante et al. [19] and Oskay et al.[20]. Kaufman et al. [21] showed that flatfoot triggered feeling of pain and stiffness in the foot, imbalance in foot muscles and tension in ligaments, fatigue when walking and most importantly the stress fractures. Taking such complications into account, it is not hard to predict that wrestlers are prone to facing serious problems.
The increase in the time spent in the sport in turn means more training and matches, and thus, wearing the wrestling shoes more. This might suggest that the wrestling shoes lead to unfavorable results in the long term. The characteristics of the sole of the wrestling shoes depict similarity to those of the boots worn in the folk dance, horon. In their study, Aydos et al. [22] revealed that significant deviations occur in the soles of horon dancers, due to the characteristic figures of the dances performed over a long period of time and the incapability of the shoes in supporting and protecting the feet. It is natural to expect that similar characteristics will lead to similar results.
Continuous and balanced feet movements are necessary to perform the practiced figures, to disrupt
the opponent's balance and to intimidate him. While disrupting the opponent's balance, a wrestler will have a significant advantage in technical performance and preserving energy as long as he maintains his balance. In addition, an accessory navicular in flatfoot individuals will stretch the posterior tibial tendon and impair its elasticity to a great extent. This in turn will significantly restrict the performance of moves like salto, arm throw and takedown, where rising on tiptoes, springing and throwing the opponent over your own body are performed.
Under the light of the outcomes of our study, we can recommend the following; the need for redesigning the wrestling shoes, raising the heels of the wrestling shoes like those in sneakers and daily shoes, placing orthopedic insoles in the wrestling shoes, and that the wrestlers wear normal sneakers when performing exercises other than wrestling, such as warm up runs and moves, and educational and sportive activities.
Conclusion
The pes planus seen in wrestlers was found to be in direct proportion to the style, wrestling year and age of the wrestlers. It was noted that the factors such as; freestyle wrestlers tying their shoes very tightly, transferring their center of gravity to the front, the wrestling shoes not supporting the foot arch area, the wrestling cushion being soft and athletes running whilst the wrestling shoes on might have contributed to pes planus. It was concluded that wrestling shoes, which were produced more than 100 years ago and have not changed much, should be produced or researched in accordance with the health of athletes.
Conflict of Interests
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interests.
References
1. Elliott B. Training in sport, applying sport science. London: John Wiley & Sons; 1998.
2. Uetake T, Ohtsuki F. Sagittal configuration of spinal curvature line in sportsmen using Moire technique. Okajimas Folia Anatomica Japonica, 1993;70(2-3): 91- 103. https://doi.org/10.2535/ofaj1936.70.2-3_91
3. Lee MS, Vanore JV, Thomas JL, Catanzariti AR, Kogler G, KravitzSR,GassenSC.Diagnosisandtreatmentofadultflatfoot. Journal of Foot and Ankle Surgery, 2005; 44(2): 78- 113. https://doi.org/10.1053/jjfas.2004.12.001
4. Pfeiffer M, Kotz R, Ledl T, Hauser G, Sluga M. Prevalence of flat foot in preschool-aged children. Pediatrics, 2006; 118(2): 634- 639. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2005-2126
5. Daneshmandi H, Rahnema N, Mehdizadeh R. Relationship between obesity and flatfoot in high-school boys and girls. International Journal of Sports Science and Engineering, 2009; 3(1): 43-49.
6. Aydog ST, Tetik O, Demirel HA, Doral MN. Differences in sole arch indices in various sports. Br JSportsMed. 2005; 39(2): e5. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsm.2003.011478
7. Hawkins RJ, Mohtadi N. Rotator cuff problems in athletes.
In: DeLee JC, Drez D, ed. Orthopaedic sports medicine. Philadelphia: WB Saunders Company; 1994. P.631-2.
8. Nurzynska D, Di Meglio F, Castaldo C, Latino F, Romano V, Miraglia R, Guerra G, Brunese L, Montagnani S. Flatfoot in children: anatomy of decision making. Ital J Anat Embryol. 2012;117(2): 98-106.
9. Banwell HA, Mackintosh S, Thewlis D. Foot Orthoses For Adults With Flexible Pes Planus: a Systematic Review. J Foot Ankle Res. 2014; 7(1): 23. https://doi.org/10.1186/1757-1146-7-23
10.Lee MS, Vanore JV, Thomas JL, Catanzariti AR, Kogler G, Kravitz SR, et al. Diagnosis and treatment of adult flatfoot. The Journal of Foot and Ankle Surgery 2005;44:78-113. https://doi.org/10.1053/jjfas.2004.12.001
11.Kulcu DG, Yavuzer G, Sarmer S, Ergin S. Immediate Effects of Silicone Insoles on Gait Pattern in Patients With Flexible Flatfoot. Foot&Ankle International,2007; 28(10): 1053- 1056. https://doi.org/10.3113/FAI.2007.1053
12.A?ak M, Korkmaz MF, Ta^kiran C, Karabulut SE, Düz S, Bayer R. Prevention and Rehabilitation of Sports Injuries. 17th International Sport Sciences Congress Antalya, 13th - 16th November. [Internet] 2019. [updated 2019 Nov 27; cited 2019 Nov 6]; Available from: http://sbk2019.org/
en/?p=kabul-edilen-bildiriler (In Turkish)
13.Yurt Y. Comparison of two diffent insole types which were producted by Cad/Cam and conventional methods on pain, quality of life and physical performance in painful flexible flat foot Hacettepe University Institute of Health Sciences, Prosthesis-Orthotics and Biomechanics program. [PhD Thesis]. 2015.
14.Staheli LT, Chew DE, Corbett M. The longitudinal arch. A survey of eight hundred and eighty-two feet in normal children and adults. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1987; 69: 426- 8. https://doi.org/10.2106/00004623-198769030-00014
15.Taskiran C, Afak M, Korkmaz M F. Foot Posture Disorders in Wrestlers. The 10th International Conference In Physical Education, Sports And Physical Therapy. Firat University, Elazig, Turkey. 2016. November. 2016. P. 64.
16.Wojtys EM, Ashton-Miller JA, Huston LJ, Moga PJ. The association between athletic training time and the sagittal curvature of the immature spine. Am J Sports Med. 2000;28 (4):490- 8. https://doi.org/10.1177/03635465000280040801
17.Gharakhanlou R, Daneshmandi H, Alizadeh MH. Prevention and treatment os sport injuries. 1st. Tehran: Samt Press; 2005.
18.Kizilci H. Assesment of pysical fitness parameters and quality of life in men with and without pes planus. [Master Thesis]. Ankara: Institute of Health Sciences; 2010.
19.Violante FS, Fiori M, Fiorentini C, Risi A, Garaqnani G, Bonfiqlioli R, Mattioli S. Associations of Psychosocial and Individual Factors With Three Different Categories of Back Disorder Among Nursing Staff. J. Occup. Health. 2004; 46(2): 100- 108. https://doi.org/10.1539/joh.46.100
20. Oskay D, Yakut Y. Comparation of physical fitness parameters in women with and without low back pain. Goztepe Medical Journal. 2011; 26 (3):117-122.
21.Kaufman KR, Brodine SK, Shaffer RA, Johnson CW, Cullison TR. The effect of foot structure and range of motion on musculoskeletal overuse injuries. The American Journal of Sports Medicine. 1999; 27(5): 585- 593. https://doi.org/10.1177/03635465990270050701
22.Aydos L, Kaya M, Kanatli U, Yüksel MF, A.Uzun A. Investigation of the effect of horon play on plantar, Inonu University. Journal of Physical Education and Sport Sciences, 2016, 3(3): 12-22.
Information about the authors:
A^ak M.; Associate Professor; http://orcid.org/0000-0002-2843-4834; [email protected]; Inonu University Faculty of Sport Sciences; Malatya, Turkey.
Korkmaz M.F.; Associate Professor; (Corresponding Author); http://orcid.org/0000-0001-7498-6763; [email protected]; Department of Orthopedics and Traumatology, Faculty of Medicine, Istanbul Medeniyet University; Istanbul, Turkey.
Taskiran C.; Associate Professor; http://orcid.org/0000-0001-8941-4987; [email protected]; Inonu University Faculty of Sport Sciences ; Malatya, Turkey.
Demirkan E.; Associate Professor; http://orcid.org/0000-0002-6243-8062; [email protected]; Hitit University Faculty of Sport Sciences; Corum, Turkey..
Cite this article as:
Acak M, Korkmaz MF, Taskiran C, Demirkan E. Investigating the effects of wrestling gear in flatfoot deformity of wrestlers.
Pedagogy of physical culture and sports, 2020;24(3):106-110.
https://doi.org/10.15561/26649837.2020.0301
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en).
Received: 19.11.2019
Accepted: 09.12.2019; Published: 05.01.2020
