CC BY
65
FURTHER CONSIDERATIONS ON POSSIBLE ARAMAIC ETYMOLOGIES OF THE DESIGNATION OF THE JUDAEAN SECT OF ESSENES ('Effffatoi/Effonvof) IN THE LIGHT OF THE ANCIENT AUTHORS' ACCOUNTS OF THEM AND THE QUMRAN COMMUNITY'S WORLD-VIEW
Igor Tantlevskij St. Petersburg State University, Russia tantigor@mail.wplus.net
Abstract. The author considers three possible Aramaic etymologies of the designation 'ECTCTaioi/'Eaonvoi: (1) Since, according to reiterated Josephus Flavius' accounts and the Dead Sea scrolls' evidences, the Essenes and the Qumranites, closely associated with them, believed in predestination and foretold the future, they could be called: those, who believe in predestination, sc. the "fatalists", "determinists"; or: those, who predict fate, i.e. the "foretellers". This hypothetical etymology is derived from the Aramaic word hassayya'(m. pL in st. det.; resp. hs( '){y)yn in st. abs.) reconstructed by the author from the term hsy/hs' ("what man has to suffer, predestination, fortune") after the model: C,aC2C2aC3. (2) In the present author's opinion, the Qumran community held itself allegorically to be the "root(s)" and "stock" of Jesse, giving life to the "holy" Davidic "Shoot" (see: Isa 11:1); or, in other words, the Qumranites appear to have considered their Yahad (lit. "Unity/Oneness") the personification of a new Jesse, who would "beget" and "bring up" a new David. (Cf., e.g., iQSa, II, 11-12: "When [God] begets (yolid) the Messiah with them ('ittam; i.e. the sectarians. — I. T.)...".) Proceeding from this doctrine, one can assume the etymology of the designation 'ECTCTaioi/'ECTCTnvoi from the Aramaic-Syriac spelling of King David father's name Jesse — 'Is(s)ay. (3) The Essenes' and the Qumranites' aloofness from this world and their striving for interrelations with the other world could be a reason, by which they came to be regarded as "liminal" personalities and nicknamed (probably, with a tinge of irony) after the name of "rephaites" (the original vocalization seems to have been: rofe'im, lit. "healers", sc. "benefactors") of former times, whom they really recalled in some key aspects of their outlook and religious practice. In this case, the designation Sspansurai, "healers", — applied in Jewish Hellenized circles, primarily, in Egypt, to the members of the (ex hypothesi) Essenean communities of mystic-"gnostic" trend — could be in fact a Greek translation of the Hebrew term rofe'im. It also seems natural to assume that this designation of the sectarians could be interpreted/translated by the uninitiated by the word 'asayya'/'asen, meaning "healers", "physicians", in the Aramaic-speaking milieu of the region of Syria-Palestine.
Keywords: Essenes, Therapeutae, the Qumran community, predestination, prediction, Messianic expectations, mysticism, esotericism, immortality of the soul, angel-like beings, re-phaites.
* This research was carried out thanks to the funding of the Russian Science Foundation (project №15-18-00062; Saint-Petersburg State University).
EXOAH Vol. 10. 1 (2016) www.nsu.ru/classics/schole
© Igor Tantlevskij, 2016
I. The Essenes as "foretellers"-"fatalists"
The correct etymology of the designation 'EccaToi/'ECTanvoi (unmeaning in Greek), i.e. the "Essenes", Judaean sect flourished in the 2nd century B.C.E. - 1st century C.E., was unknown or at least doubtful for many uninitiated Jews nearly from the start of its emergence, as one can conclude, for example, from the following note attested in Philo of Alexandria:
This name (sc. 'Eowaioi. - I. T.), though in my opinion the form of the Greek is inaccurate, is derived from holiness (OcioTnTOi;).1
Describing the appearance of three principal Jewish sects, Josephus Flavius singles out the attitude towards predestination (ei^ap^evn; lit. "lot", "fate", "destiny", sc. Providence) as the main aspect of religious "schools" separation in Judea in the middle of the second century B.C.E. (Antiquitates Judaicae, XIII, 171-173). At this, the very essence of the Essenes' doctrine, according to Josephus, is "that all things are best ascribed to God" (Antt., XVIII, 18). In Antt., XIII, 172, he mentions:
The genus of the Essenes affirm, that fate (t^v si^ap^svnv) governs all things, and that nothing befalls men but what is according to its (determination).
The widely spread Essenes' practice of the prediction of future events (including personal fates), well known to Josephus Flavius2, was likely to be based on their belief in predetermination. In Antt., III, 214-218, Josephus speaks of the Judaean high priest's breastplate and describes its role in the process of predictions. At this, he transcribes the Hebrew word hosen for a "breastplate" as sctct^v, and correlates the latter term with the Greek XOyiov, "oracle"3 (cf. the Septuagint's correlate term AoysTov). Thus, it is not impossible that Josephus perceived the implicit meaning "prediction" in the designation 'Econvoi.
Pliny the Elder (Historia Naturalis, V, 15, 17) asserts that the numbers of the Essenes (Esseni) "are fully recruited by multitudes of strangers that resort to them, driven thither to adopt their usages by the tempests of fortune". The mention offortuna (this term correlates with the si^ap^svn in Josephus' account) in this context can imply the Essenes' belief in predestination, according to which the sectarians, as they thought, found themselves in the community.
1 Philo of Alexandria, Quod omnis probus Liber sit, XII, 75. See also: ib., 91; Philo's Apologia (1) (in Eusebius' Praep. Evang., VIII, 11). Cf.: Josephus Flavius, Bellum Judaicum, II, 119; Hippolytus of Rome, PhiLosophumena, IX, 18, 3.
2 See, e.g.: , Josephus Flavius, BJ, I, 78-80; II, 111-113, 159; Antiquitates Judaicae, XIII, 311313; XVII, 346-348; XV, 371-379; XVII, 345-348. Cf. also: Hyppolitus, PhiLosophumena, IX, 27.
3 Antt., III, 163, 217.
The doctrine of absolute predestination plays a key role in religious outlook of the Qumran community,4 and it is considered to be one of the most fundamental arguments in favour of the widespread Qumranites' identification with the Es-senes.5 All is predetermined in the world — in heaven and on earth; and there is neither the past, nor the future for God: all is the present for Him, all is the eternal "now".6 A Qumran Hebrew etymological and semantic equivalent of the term si^ap^svn, used by Josephus, is the notion goral, "lot", "share", sc. destiny, frequently attested in the scrolls.7 Judging by the sectarian manuscripts, mainly the so-called Pesharim (i.e. Commentaries on the Prophets and Psalms), the members of the Qumran community, like the Essenes (cf. in this connection especially Josephus' Bellum Judaicum, II, 159), predicted the fates of the whole world, as well as of certain individuals.8
In the light of these considerations it seems most natural to correlate the hitherto unclarified etymology of the term 'EccaToi / 'Ecanvoi 9 with the Aramaic notion hsy10 /hs' u, which is interpreted by M. Jastrow as "what man has to suffer, predestination, fortune"12. The term hsy is attested in the Midrash on the Book of Lamentations, or Eichah Rabbah (89:14; ib. 20), which, along with the Bereshith Rabbah and the Pesiqta de-Rab Kahana, is the oldest composition of the midrashic literature. It is written in the so-called Jewish Palestinian Aramaic,
4 On the Sitz im Leben of the Qumran Community and its scrolls in Judaea of the Hellenistic Period see, e.g.: VanderKam, Flint 2002; Eshel 2008; Tantlevskij 2013a, 243-302.
5 See, e.g.: Wise 1993, 71-74.
6 See, e.g.: iQHa IX (= 4Q432 2), 7-34; iQS IX, 24-25; iQpHab VII, 13-14, etc. Cf., e.g., iQH IX, 23-24: "Everything is engraved before You... for all the periods of eternity, for the numbered seasons of eternal years in all their appointed times". On the basis of the main Qumran manuscripts' analysis one can conclude that, according to the sectarians view, the idea/plan of the entire future Universe arises originally in God's Mind (binah, sekel), and the world itself comes into existence by His Knowledge (da'at), Wisdom (hokmah), Thought (mahasabah). Cf., e.g.: iQS XI, 11; iQH IX (= 4Q432 2), 7-34. See further in detail, e.g.: Tantlevskij 1994, 281-297; Tantlevskij 2013b, 316-324; Tantlevskij, Svetlov 2014a, 5053; Tantlevskij, Svetlov 2014b, 54-66.
7 Cf. also the Hebrew notions heleq in the meaning "share", "portion", "lot" (e.g.: CD-B XX, 10, 13) and te'udah, "destiny", "predestination" (e.g.: iQHa IX, 19).
8 See, e.g.: Tantlevskij 1995; Tantlevskij 1997a, 329-338.
9 The lists of the most widespread etymologies of the denomination "Essenes" hitherto proposed one can find, e.g., in: Tantlevskij 1997b, 193-213; Idem 1999, 195-212; Idem 2013a, 280; Beall 2000, I, 262-268.
10 See: Sokoloff 2002, 217.
11 Jastrow 1926, 508.
12 M. Sokoloff (2002, 217), however, leaves this term without any interpretation.
which "continued, as opposed to the other Western Aramaic languages of the middle stage, one of the written Old Aramaic languages of the western branch".13 One can try to reconstruct a conjectural noun (m. pl.) of the same root after the model C,aC2C2aC3 (normally designations of persons by their profession, usual activity, etc. are formed after it) as hassayya '14 in st. det., resp. hs( ')(y)yn in st. abs. The etymology of the term 'EccaToi / 'Eca^voi derived from this hypothetical term appears to be relevant not only semantically, but also linguistically. In connection with the correspondence of the beginnings spelling cf., e.g., the following transcriptions attested in Hellenistic sources: Hammot is normally rendered as E^^aoug15; hosen - as ectct^v16; as to the Greek "endings" -aToi / -nvoi, they can represent transcriptions of the Aramaic endings -ayya '/-in (pl. m. in st. det. and pl. m. in st. abs. respectively) plus the Greek ending m. pL -oi proper.
Thus, if the suggested derivation of the ECTCTaToi/ECTCTnvoi's etymology from the reconstructed Aramaic term hsy(y) '/hs( ')(y)yn is correct, then the "Essenes" are:
1) Those, who predict fate, the "foretellers". In Antt., XIII, 311 (cf. also: BJ, I, 78), Josephus Flavius even mentions a special school of the Essenes, who "learned the art of foretelling things to come" (it flourished at the end of the 2nd cent. B.C.E.). (Cf. also especially: BJ, II, 159.) The Essenes had the "foreknowledge (np6yvwCTiv; 'predetermination'. - I. T.) of future events given by God" (Antt. XV, 373; cf. ib. 379: "...many of these (Essenes) have, by their excellent virtue, been thought worthy of this knowledge of divine revelations").
2) Those, who believe in predestination, that is to say, the "fatalists", "deter-minists".17
II. The Essenes as the personification of a new "Jesse", begetting a new "David"
Josephus Flavius, obviously sympathyzing with the Essenes, remains silent concerning their Messianic expectations, in all probability, deliberately — for reasons of safety. It seems that one can reveal the only remark of this character in Antt., XVIII, 18, according to which the Essenes "believe that they ought to strive especially for the approach of the Righteous One (xou Sixaiou x^v TCp6co§ov)". (Cf.:Jer. 23:5, 33:15.)
13 Лёзов 2009, 459. Works written in Jewish Palestinian Aramaic were composed par excellence in Galilee.
14 Cf., on the other hand: Jastrow 1926, 508.
15 Albright, Mann 1969, 108.
16 Moreover, one should bear in mind that the original pronunciation of the sect's name could begin with 'E-, not 'E-.
17 See, e.g.: Tantlevskij 2013b, 316-324.
On the other hand, we know that it was already at the early stage in the history of the Qumran community that the sectarians came to regard their Yahad (lit. "Oneness", "Unity"=community) as a potential spiritual earthly "father" of a lay Messiah (while God is his Heavenly Father), who, according to their expectation, would arise just in the midst of them in the "latter days", owing to their pious mode of life (in particular, to their eschatological "preparations" in the Judaean wilderness) and righteous activities.18 In one of the earliest Qumran documents -iQ Rule of the Congregation (iQSa), II, 11-12, it is said:
When [God] begets (yolid) the Messiah with them ('ittam; i.e. the sectarians. — I. T.)... 19
The author of the Qumran Thanksgiving Hymn iQH XI, 7-1020 depicts eschatological "woes" of the community, begetting (sc. promoting by means of its righteous activities the coming of) a "Wonderful Counsellor with his might" (Isa. 9:5), i.e. the Davidic King-Messiah.21 (Cf., e.g.:Jer. 30:21; cf. also: Rev. 12:1-6.)
The author of the 4Q Commentary on Genesis A (4Q252), V, 2-522 plays on several meanings of the word ham-mehoqeq in his commentary on Gen. 49:1023: it is "the staff", and at the same time the denomination of the leader of the Qumran Yahad-"Unity" — "the Lawgiver" (another meaning of the word mehoqeq), who is identical with the "[Expounder of] the Law" (cf.: CD-A VI, 7, VII, 16; 4QFlorilegium I, 11). (In the texts 4Q252, V, 2-5 and CD-A VI, 7-10, "the Lawgiver" seems to be none other than the Qumran charismatic leader, named the Teacher of Righteous.) The adherents of the "Lawgiver" are designated in the Commentary as "the legs" (we read ha-raglayim, not had-daglayim, "the banners"24) of Judah. On the whole, the Yahad, headed by "the Lawgiver", is represented in the Commentary as a true successor of Judah, a "keeper" of "the Covenant of kingship", substitut-
18 See further: Tantlevskij 2012, 200-207; Idem 2015.
19 See further, e.g.: Tantlevskij 2012, 198-207; Idem 2014d, 93-99.
20 Cf. also: 4Q428 (4QHb), fr. 2; 4Q432 (pap 4QH), fr. 4, col. I.
21 Cf., e.g.: i Enoch 62:4-8; Test. of Joseph 19:8.
22 Published in: Brooke et al., eds. (1996a), 185-207, pls. XII-XIII; see also: Brooke (1996b), 385-401.
23 It seems that the terms "scepter" (sebet) u «warder» (mehoqeq) with their original meanings "rod", "staff' could be used in Gen. 49:10 not only as an allegory of dominion, but also as an euphemism for the organ of Judah's male power. (Cf., e.g.: Good 1963, 427432; Carmichael 1969, 438-444.) The present author believes that the phrase 'ad kiyabo' s{i}loh can be interpreted in a double entente, with the agent not only Judah, but also his "scepter"/"rod"; in the latter case, this passage could be rendered as follows: "until it ('scepter'/'rod') enters/comes into his (Judah's / his descendant's) own/what is his", i.e., until Judah possesses what is his due.
24 This reading is attested in the Samaritan Pentateuch.
ing in a certain sense for an absent legitimate King of Judah's tribe, "until the coming" ('ad bo') of "the Righteousness Anointed One, the Shoot of David"25 in the world. (NB: "Judah" is one of the self-denominations of the Qumran community in the scrolls.) It is not impossible that the Yahad, employing in the Commentary a symbol of generative power for its self-designation, endeavoured to express in that way the belief in its direct participation in the appearance of the legitimate Davidic King-Messiah.
In the light of some passages of the Qumran Thanksgiving Hymns (see, e.g.: iQH XVI, 4-12; XIV, 14-16), using the allegorical plant illustrations, one can also say that the sectarians held themselves to be a "garden", bearing fruit in the coming of the King-Messiah, the "root(s)" and "stock" of Jesse, giving life to the "holy" Davidic "Shoot"-neser (see: Isa. 11:1). In several other Qumran documents,26 the passage of Isa. 11:1-5 is directly connected with the appearance of the legitimate Davidic Messiah in the midst of the community, and its priestly leaders are depicted as his teachers and advisors.27 In other words, the members of the Qumran community appear to have considered their Yahad the personification of a new Jesse, who would "beget" and "bring up" a new David. (NB: In the Bible28 and in the Qumran scrolls29, the term 'ab is used not only in its direct meaning "father", "begetter", but also has a connotation "advisor", "teacher".)
Since the Qumran sect apparently laid the foundations of the Essenean movement, it seems to the present author possible to suppose that the designation "Essenes" could be eventually derived from the name of King David's father —Jesse (Heb. Ylsay [or Ylssay30]; the name's Aram. and Syr. form 'Isay is attested in 1 Chr. 2:13). The etymology of the sect's denomination from Jesse was proposed in the Panarion (Haer. XXIX, 1,4; 4,9) by Epiphanius of Salamis, who cited Ps. 132:11 ("From the fruit of your belly I will place on your throne") as a main biblical proof-text for its confirmation. This Christian author believed that 'lEccaToi31 (= ECTCTaToi), including their Egyptian branch - 0EpanEuxai (lit. "healers", "physi-
25 Cf.:Jer. 23:5, 33:15; Zech. 3:8, 6:12.
26 E.g., the Commentary on Isaiah (4QpIsaa), fr. 8-10 (col. Ill), 11-25; 4Q285 (4QSefer ham-Milhamah), fr. 5, 2-4 (= 11Q14, fr. 1, col. I, 10-13); iQSb (iQRule of Benedictions), col. V.
27 Cf., e.g.:Isa. 11:3-4 and 4QpIsaa, fr. 8-10, 22-25; cf. also: Deut. 17:17-20 and 11Q Temple Scrolla 56:20-57:15.
28 Cf., e.g.: Gen. 45:8;Judg. 17:10, 18:19; 2 Ki. 2:12.
30 Cf., e.g.: iQHaXVII, 30-31, 35-36.
30 On this possible vocalization see, e.g.: De Lagarde 1889, 44.
31 This spelling is also attested in: Nilus the Ascetic, Tractatus de monastica exercita-tione, 3; he considered the Essenes to have been a pre-Christian Jewish sect.
cians"; or "worshipers"),32 described "in Philo's treatises ", and, first of all, "in his book nspi 'Isccaítov" (5,i),33 were none other than early Judaeo-Christian ascetics.34 The spelling 'Isccaioi was apparently derived from the Hebrew form of the name Jesse - Ylsay / Ylssay (cf., e.g., the Septuagint's transcription of this name as 'Isccaí and Josephus' one as 'Isccaioig). As for the designation 'Eccaioi, it could be derived from the Aramaic/Syriac spelling of the name - 'Isay.35 (As a parallel to the transcription of the first syllable one can mention, e.g., Josephus' and Ori-gen's transliteration of the word 'issah, "woman" in Hebrew, as scca (Antt. I, 36) and éccá (Epist. ad Africanum, I, 82,84) respectively; in the Septuagint, the Aramaic equivalent of Ylsay / Ylssay - the name 'Ittay / 'Ittay is transcribed as 'EQQsí, EcQasí.) In this connection let us note that medieval Jewish scholars transcribed the Greek Eccaioi as ysyy36 (cf. also the Modern Hebrew spelling of the "Es-senes" as 'ysyym).
Etymology of the designation Eccaioi from "Jesse" - or its other possible etymologies of "Messianic" character - appears to give an opportunity to answer an intriguing question: why is this denomination not found in the New Testament, nor its Semitic original in the old Rabbinic literature? It seems that those Jews, as well as early Christians, who knew or only suspected the true meaning of the term "Essenes", did not employed this designation, because they could consider it to be blasphemous (as, for example, Jews avoided, and sometimes abstain nowadays, from usage of the term "Christians").
On the other hand, it is also not impossible that the hypothetical Semitic original of the designation of the community — (')ysy'/(')ysyn could be taken in uninitiated circles not as derived from the proper name Ylsay, but in its literal sense — as the "wealthy (people)" (from material or/and spiritual points of view). Echoes of such an interpretation, in the present author's opinion, could be found in Philo's treatises Quod omnis probus liber sit, XII, 77 and De vita contemplativa, II, 13. In the first work, Philo of Alexandria says that the Eccaioi "called themselves the 'wealthiest (people)' (nXouciwxaxoi)", since they are moderate in needs, and this is tantamount to an abundance. In the second composition, the philosopher
32 Cf., e.g.: Tantlevskij 2003, 107-115.
33 Cf., e.g., the following title of a Latin translation of the treatise "On Contemplative Life" by Philo of Alexandria: Philonis Judaei liber de statu Essaeorum, id est Monachorum, qui temporibus Agrippae regis monasteria sibifecerunt.
34 Cf.: Eusebius of Caesaria, Historia Ecclesiastica, II, 16-17.
35 The addition of a prosthetic aleph before yod was a wide spread practice in Jewish Palestinian Aramaic (as well as in Mishnaic Hebrew). See, e.g.: Dalman 1960, 100; cf., e.g.: Taylor 2010, 377; Tantlevskij 2014c, 547.
36 Cf., e.g.: Rossi 1866, 90-97.
defines the 0EpanEuxai (who, as it was noted above, in all probability represented an Egyptian branch of the Essenes) as those who have got "the wealth of insight (xov pXsnovxa nXouxov)". Some Greek-speaking Jews of the Diaspora (including Philo himself) may also have connected the denomination ECTCTaToi/ECTCTnvoi with the term eccia (Doric form of the word oucia; cf.: Lat. esse, essentia), meaning "essence", "property" and probably known to the educated public from Plato's treatise Cratylus, 401. (NB: these Greek and Latin terms are possibly congeneric with the Hebrewyes/'is, "substance"; "existence"="there is" [the name Ylsay is apparently derived from this very word].) From the point of view of this correlation, the "Essenes" could probably be considered as those, who investigate the essence of God and the Universe,37 and, at the same time, as those, who have obtained imperishable property.
III. The Essenes as new "rephaites"
In the Qumranites' view, the border between the transcendent and the earthly worlds is relatively "transparent" on both sides, i.e. not only angel-like beings can descend from the heavens and stay in their community,38 but also certain representatives of this world are able to visit the heavenly one. In particular, it follows from some of the Thanksgiving Hymns (e.g.: iQH", XI, 19-23; XII, 27-29), as well as from the so-called Self-glorification Hymn (4Q49ic) and its recension(s) included in the Thanksgiving Hymns collection39, the author of which informed his adherents of his heavenly "voyage(s)" and of his firm belief that on finishing his terrestrial path he would stay with the heavenly beings in the celestial Council. Further, judging by these fragments of the Hymns, the Qumran Rule of the Discipline (see, e.g.: iQS, IV, 8), the Songs of the Sabbath Sacrifice (or the Angelic Liturgy; 4Q400-407; 11Q17),40 etc., the Qumranites evidently believed that the departed righteous and wise (first of all, their own dead comrades) came to be angel-like beings (who are designated, in particular, 'elim, "gods"). This view is obviously attested also in the following fragment of the War Scroll (iQM), XII, 1-2:
For there is multitude of the holy ones in the heavens, and the hosts of angels are in
Thy Holy Abode, [praising] Thy [Name]. And Thou hast established in [a community] for Thyself the elect of Thy holy people (i.e. the departed righteous ones. — I. T.).
37 Cf., e.g.: Philo, QOPL, XII, 80; Idem, DVC, passim; Josephus, BJ, II, 136.
38 See, e.g.: iQSa, II, 3-9; iQS, XI, 8; cf., e.g.: 4QDb (Damascus Documentb), fr. 17, I, 6-9; 11Q14 (iiQ Sefer ham-Milhamah), fr. 1, II, 14-15; 4Qs6g (Prayer of Enosh (?)), fr. 1, II, 9.
39 See in detail, e.g.: Tantlevskij 1997b, 193-213; Idem 2000, 92ff.; Idem 2004, 67ff.; Idem 2012, 299-313. Cf., e.g.: Wise 2000, 173-219.
40 Some fragments of this composition were discovered at the fortress of Masada as well.
[The] list ("book". — I. T.) of the names of all their host41 is with Thee in the Abode of Thy Holiness, and the num[ber of the righ]teous in Thy Glorious Dwelling".42
In the light of the texts mentioned above, and especially the hymnic fragment of 4Q49ic and its recension(s), one can assume that "gods" ('elim/'elohim), mentioned in the Qumran Songs of the Sabbath Sacrifice, are not only the angelic beings, but also the deified departed righteous.43
An implicit parallel to this Qumranic conception one can find in the text of BJ, II, 154, in which Josephus Flavius notes that the Essenes believe that the souls, "when they are set free from the bounds of the flesh", "rejoice and mount upwards" (see further: BJ, II, 153-158, and especially, 153; Antt., XVIII, 18). Hippolytus of Rome writes in his Philosophumena (IX, 27), that the Essenes
admit that the body will resurrect and remain immortal, exactly like the soul which is already immortal, and, separated (sc. from the body. — I. T.), rests till the Judgement in a pleasant and effulgent place, which the Hellenes would call, had they heard (about it), the Islands of the Blessed".
Judging by Philo of Alexandria (DVC, II, 11-13), the Therapeutae (dwelling mostly in Egypt; see below) practiced mystical heavenly "voyages" in a certain ecstatic state:
Let the genus of the Therapeutae, constantly accustoming itself to contemplation, aspire to consider the Being, ascend above the visibly perceived sun. Like frantic Bacchants and Corybantes,44 they are seized with an exaltation till they see what they long for.
* * *
However, searching for certain possible parallels and sources of the Qumranites' and the Essenes' views concerning the ascent of the departed righteous members of their community to the heavens and their transition into the category of "gods", i.e. the angel-like beings, one should primarily pay attention not to the
41 Cf. the passage BJ, II, 142, in which Josephus notes that the Essenes keep secret "both the books belonging to their sect and the names of the angels" — probably in order to prevent the possibility of their unauthorized invoking by uninitiated outsiders. (Cf., e.g.: Gen. 32:30;Judg. 13:17-18; cf. also: i Sam. 28:8-14.)
42 Cf.: Dan. 12:3; cf. also, e.g.: i Enoch 39:6-41; ch. 102-104.
43 See also: Tantevskij 1994, 236-241, 275; Idem 1997b, 193-213. Cf., e.g.: Fletcher-Louis 1998, 367-399; Idem 2000, 292-312; Idem 2002.
44 Cf., e.g., Plato's treatises Banquet, 218b; Phaedrus, 253a; Ion, 533e. (Corybantes were the priests of the Phrygian Great Mother Cybele, whose cult was notable for its licentiousness and state of frenzy.)
corresponding Hellenic/Hellenistic (or Iranian) religious views, but rather to the relevant local old Canaanite/Ugaritic and old Israelite-Judahite people's beliefs and practices associated with the cult of the dead.45 It is natural to suppose a priori, that some of these traditions and practices still existed in certain heterodox (esoteric) Judaean circles during the Hellenistic and Early Roman periods, or, at least, could be revived and modified among them in one or another form (as, for example, the Qumranites and the Essenes seem to have employed old solar calendar, used in the pre-Exilic epoch, in its somewhat remodeled form46). For instance, one can see certain points of contiguity between the corresponding views and lifestyles of the Qumranites/Essenes and the old Canaanite/Ugaritic and Is-raelite-Judahite conception of the so-called refa'im (or rather rofe'im [Ugaritic rp'um; Phoenician rp'm], i.e. "healers", sc. "benefactors"47; see below), who are referred to as "gods"48 in ancient sources, and their mystic and esoteric cultic associations, crystallizing around the cult of a god or a hero, called, in particular, marzehim (Hebrew, sg. marze^h; Ugaritic marzahu or marzihu).49 In all probability, the departed ones continued to be considered the members of the marzehim and hence were invisibly "present" at their communal sacred meals, funerary rites, religious feasts, etc. (Cf., e.g., the Ugaritic text KTU 1.161 ["On the Re-phaites"], 2-10, according to which the spirits of the deified ancestors were invited to the house of marzahu during the New Year festival.) Such cultic associations are also attested in later cultures in the region of Syria-Palestine.
Along with the "rephaites of old" (divine ancestors), dwelling in the other world, - this could be the heavens or/and the netherworld50 - the existence of the "rephaites of earth ('ars51; or 'land', 'country')" is attested in some Ugaritic texts. These are likely to have been called also the "gods of earth" ('ilm 'ars). The "earthly" rephaites (as well as the "sons of the rephaites"; cf.: 2 Sam. 21:16, 18 and
45 See, e.g.: Tanlevslij, 1997b, 193-213; Idem 2004, 67-79; Idem 2012, 313-346.
46 Cf., e.g.: Tanlevslij 2004, 69; Ben-Dov 2008.
47 Cf.: Köhler, Baumgartner 1996, III, 1274^
48 In some Ugaritic texts, the rephaites dwelling in the abode of gods, including spirits of the departed kings and heroes, the righteous and wise, were called, e.g.: "star-gods", "those-of-the-stars" "in the heavens", "divine ancestors", "protectors". See, e.g.: Tantlevskij 2004, 71.
49 On the marzehim see, e.g.: Assen 1996, 73-87; Maier, Daenfus 1999, 45-57; McLaughlin 2001.
50 Cf., e.g.: Tantlevskij 2013a, 372-401; Idem 2014e, 142-145.
51 According to an alternative supposition, the expression rp 'i 'ars in KTU 1.15:iii.3, 14 should be interpreted as "the rephaites of the underworld" (see, e.g.: Toorn 1996, 210 and n. 14). Cf., e.g.: Ps. 16:3.
20; i Chr. 20:4 and 6, 8), i.e. probably those, who live on earth,52 seem to have been the liminal personalities, who acquired special initiation and consecration — which apparently presupposed the experience of mystical death and subsequent rebirth to a new life in the process of accomplishment of a ritual act - and through this also sacral knowledge opening the way during a lifetime into spheres usually accessible only for the dead — into the other world — and drawing nearer to the association of "gods", i.e. the other world beings.53 There was a belief that they could periodically come into contact with the other world, and probably even visit it in a certain ecstatic state. Their connection with the other world has been reflected, in particular, in the fact that the terms used for their designations coincided with the denominations of the other world dwellers, with whom they associated; cf., e.g., in the Hebrew Bible: the other world and the earthly refa 'im/[rofe'im]-"healers"; the knowing spirits and those (witch doctors), who invoke the knowing spirits — yidde'onim; the ancestors' spirits and those, who invoke the ancestors' spirits — 'Shot.
Some basic aspects of the rephaites' conception appears to have been distorted in, and in many cases deleted from, the Jewish orthodox written records extremely negative towards the cult of the departed and contacts with them in any form.54 On the same plane one should consider the Masoretic vocalization of the very word for spirits of the dead — rp 'ym — as refa 'im, "impotent ones", instead of the most probable original rofe 'im, "healers". This is corroborated, for instance, by the fact that the Septuagint translates the term rp 'ym in Isa. 26:14 and Ps. 88:11 as iaxpoi, i.e. reads it as rofe'im. On the other hand, in 2 Chr. 16:12, — where it is said of King Asa's "seeking" help from the rofe'im, i.e. "healers", and not from the Lord, — the former seem to be none other than spirits of the dead. The vocalization refa'im, "impotent ones", "powerless", — instead of the original rofe'im, "healers", "benefactors", — could arise as a polemical and simultaneously pejorative reaction to the designation of the worshipped ancestors (primarily, the prominent ones; cf., e.g.: Lev. 24:15; i Sam. 28:13) by the term 'elim/'elohim ("gods"), meaning literally "powerful", "strong", "potent ones".
52 In particular, the "earthly" rephaites were the heroes of the Ugaritic epos DanniIlu and Karatu (cf., e.g.: KTU 1.15:iii.2-4 = 13-15). Cf.: Deut. 3:11-13;Josh. 12:4-5, 13:12 about Og, King of Bashan.
In the Hebrew Bible, the term of the same consonant spelling - rp 'ym (Masoretic vocalization: refa'im) - is also used several times as a general term for the designation of some Canaanite and Transjordanian peoples of giants.
53 Shifman 1999, 198, 242-244.
54 Cf.: Toorn 1996, 225.
Philo of Alexandria called the Essenean communities thiasi (a designation of Greek cultic associations), including syssitia (sc. communal meals).55 The term Qiacog could well be correlated with the Hebrew marze^h (see, e.g.: Jer. 16:5 [LXX]), resp. Aramaic marzeha', for, in particular, both associations included cultic banquets connected with cult of the departed (cf., e.g.: Deut. 26:14; Judg. 9:26-29 (cf. also: 9:9, 13); Isa. 65:4; Ps. 106:28). Josephus Flavius compares the Essenes' mode of life with that of the Pythagoreans (Antt., XV, 371),56 probably implying thus an esoteric character of their associations. Both Philo and Josephus, depicting the Essenes, hint at the sacral character of their meals and liturgy; exactly the same one can say about the Therapeutae's practice in Philo's description of them.
In the light of what was said above concerning the rephaites and the mystical beliefs and practice of the Essenes and the Qumranites, it seems plausible to suppose that the sectarians' aloofness from this world and their striving for contacts and relations with the other world could be a reason, by which they came to be nicknamed (probably, with a tinge of irony) after the designation of refa'im/resp. rofe'im, lit. "healers", whom they really recalled in some key aspects. In this case, the designation QEpanEuxai, "healers", — applied in Jewish Hellenized circles,57 primarily, in Egypt, to the members of the (ex hypothesi) Essenean communities of mystic-"gnostic" trend, to which the Qumran community appears to have appertained as well, — could be in fact a Greek translation of the Hebrew term rofe 'im. It also seems natural to assume that this designation of the sectarians could be interpreted/translated by the word 'asayya'/ 'asen, meaning "healers", "physicians" (with a connotation: "thaumaturges"; cf., e.g.: Y. Yoma, Ill, 40d, bottom of page), in the Aramaic-speaking milieu of the region of Syria-Palestine.58 NB: Both Greek and Aramaic translations of the sectarians' designation could be made by uninitiated outsiders without any connection with the special "mystical" connotation of the Hebrew term rp 'ym — it could simply be a literal translation of this word.
Whether or not the Essenes and the Therapeutae were healers in actual fact, is unknown. In Philo's opinion, the Therapeutae were not physicians in the proper sense, for they cured not bodies, but souls — from their passions and vices (DVC,
55 QOPL, XII, 85f.; Apologia, (5) [in: Eusebius, Praeparatio Evangelica, VIII, 11].
56 Cf.: Hyppolitus, Philosophumena, IX, 27.
57 Cf., e.g., Philo, DVC, III, 21: "This genus lives everywhere, for it is incumbent on both Hellas and barbarians to join the perfect virtue...".
58 Etymology of 'Естсшо1/'Еста"^о( from 'asayya'/ 'asen had been proposed before the discovery of the Dead Sea scrolls. Cf., e.g.: Jastrow 1926, 93. Selective bibliography on this etymology see, e.g., in: Tantlevskij 2004, 79, n. 259.
I, 2).59 The presence of women-Therapeutrides in the community also corroborates this conclusion. (On the other hand, judging by, e.g., 1 Sam. 28:3, 7, 9, women were among those, who practiced communion with spirits of the departed.) Jose-phus' remark that the Essenes "inquire after such roots and medicinal stones as may cure distempers" (BJ, II, 136), probably, means simply that they didn't consult actual physicians. The Dead Sea scrolls remain silent of medical activity of the Qumran sectarians. Thus, if the Essenes-Qumranites were in fact called rofe 'im by Hebrew-speaking outsiders, this term implied, in all probability, that they were "healers" out of this world, like the rephaites of former times, whom they strikingly resembled. In conclusion, let us mention that, judging by the Panarion, XXIX, 4, 9-10, Epiphanius of Salamis knew a tradition, according to which the designation 'IsccaToi (= 'EccaToi) had been eventually derived from the word, meaning "in Hebrew" 0£pan£UT^g/iaxp6g, lit. "healer"/"physician".
References
Лёзов, С. В. (2009) Арамейские языки, Языки мира. Семитские языки. Москва, 414-496. Тантлевский, И. Р. (1994) История и идеология Кумранской общины, Санкт-Петербург. Тантлевский, И. Р. (2000) Книги Еноха, Москва-Иерусалим.
Тантлевский, И. Р. (2012) Загадки рукописей Мертвого моря. История и учение общины
Кумрана. Санкт-Петербург. Тантлевский, И. Р. (2013а) История Израиля и Иудеи до 70 г. н. э. Санкт-Петербург. Тантлевский, И. Р. (2013b) "Фатализм ессеев," Вестник РХГА 14.3, 316-324. Тантлевский, И. Р.; Светлов, Р. В. (2014b) " 'Ессеи как пифагорейцы': предестинация в
пифагореизме, платонизме и кумранской теологии," ЕХОЛН (Schole) 8.1. 54-66. Тантлевский, И. Р. (2014d) " 'Когда [Бог] породит Мессию с ними.': Идея рождения Мессии Израиля в лоне Кумранской общины," Вестник ЛГУ им. А. С. Пушкина 93-99. Тантлевский, И. Р. (2014e) "Оптимизм Экклесиаста", Вопросы философии 11, 137-148. Тантлевский, И. Р. (2015) "Фрагмент Благословения Йакова Быт. 49:10 и его интерпретация в Кумране: имплицитная аллегория органа мужской силы в религиозно-политической декларации," Вестник РХГА 16. 4. Шифман, И. Ш. (1999) О Ба'лу. Угаритские поэтические повествования. Москва. Albright, W.F., Mann, C.S. (1969) "Qumran and the Essenes: Geography, Chronology and Identification of the Sect," The Scrolls and Christianity. Historical and Theological Significance. Ed. by M. Black. London, 11-25. Assen, B. A. (1996) "The Garlands of Ephraim; Isaiah 28:1-6 and the 'marzeah'," Journal for the
Study of the Old Testament 71, 73-87. Beall, T. S. (2000) "Essenes," Encyclopedia of the Dead Sea Scrolls. Ed. by Shiffman, L., Vander-Kam, J. Oxford, vol. I.
Ben-Dov, J. (2008) Head of All Years: Astronomy and Calendars at Qumran in their Ancient Context. Leiden.
59 Cf. also: Eusebius of Caesarea, Historia Ecclesiastica, II, 17, 1-24.
Brooke, G. et al., eds. (1996a) Discoveries in theJudaean DesertXXII. Qumran Cave 4. Parabib-lical Texts, Oxford; New York, Part 3, 185-207, pls. XII-XIII.
Brooke, G. (1996b) "4Q252 as Early Jewish Commentary," Revue de Qumran 17/65-68, 385-401.
Carmichael, С. M. (1969) "Some Sayings in Genesis 49," Journal of Biblical Literature 87, 438444.
Dalman, G. (1960) Grammatik des jüdisch-palästinischen Aramäisch. Darmstadt.
De Lagarde, P. Übersicht über die im Aramäischen, Arabischen und Hebräishen übliche Bildung der Nomina. Göttingen, 1889.
Eshel, H. (2008) The Dead Sea Scrolls and the Hasmonean State. Grand Rapids, 2008.
Fletcher-Louis, C.H.T. (1998) "Heavenly Ascent or Incarnational Presence Revisionist Reading of the 'Songs of the Sabbath Sacrifice' ," Society of Biblical Literature Seminar Papers
37.1, 367-399.
Fletcher-Louis, C.H.T. (2000) "Some Reflections on Angelomorphic Humanity Texts Among the Dead Sea Scrolls," Dead Sea Disceries 7.3, 292-312.
Fletcher-Louis, C.H.T. (2002) All the Glory of Adam: Liturgical Anthropology in the Dead Sea Scrolls. Leiden.
Good, E. (1963) "The Blessing on Judah," Journal of Biblical Literature 82, 427-432.
Jastrow, M. (1926) A Dictionary of the Targumim, the Talmud Babli and Yerushalmi, and the Midrashic Literature. London; New York.
Köhler, L.; Baumgartner, W (1996) The Hebrew and Aramaic Lexicon of the Old Testament. Tübingen, 1996, vol. III.
Ljezov S. V. (2009) "Aramejskije jazyky," Jazyky mira Semitskije jazyky [Aramaic Languages, Languages of the World. Semitic Languages]. Moscow, 414-496 (in Russian).
Maier Ch., Daenfus, E. M. (1999) " 'Um mit ihnen zu sitzen, zu essen und zu trinken' — Am 6, 7; Jer 16, 5 und die Bedeutung von marzeah," Zeitschrift für die Alttestamentliche Wissenschaft 111, 45-57.
McLaughlin, J. L. (2001) The marzeah in the Prophetic Literature: References and Allusions in Light of the Extra-Biblical Evidence. Leiden; Boston; Cologne.
Rossi, A. dei (1866) Me 'or Einayim. Wilna.
Shifman, I. Sh. (1999) O Ba'lu. Ugaritskje poeticheskje povestvovanija [On Ba'lu. Ugaritic Poetical Compositions]. Moscow (in Russian).
Sokoloff, M. (2002) A Dictionary of Jewish Palestinian Aramaic of the Byzantine Period. 2nd ed. Ramat-Gan; Baltimore; London.
Tantevskij, , I. R. (1994) Istorija i ideologja Qumranskoj obschiny [The History and Ideology of the Qumran Community], Saint-Petersbug (in Russian).
Tantlevskij, I. R. (2000) KnigiEnocha [The Books of Enoch], Moscow-Jerusalem (in Russian).
Tantlevskij, I. R. (1995) "The Two Wicked Priests in the Qumran Commentary on Habakkuk," The Qumran Chronicle, Appendix C.
Tantlevskij, I. R. (1997a) "The Historical Background of the Qumran Commentary on Nahum", Hellenismus. Beiträge zur Erforschung von Akkulturation und politische Ordnung in den Staaten des hellenistischen Zeitalters. Herausgegeben von Bernd Funck Tübingen: J.C.B.Mohr (Paul Siebeck), 329-338.
Tantlevskij I. R. (1997b) "Elements of Mysticism in the Dead Sea Scrolls (Thanksgiving Hymns, War Scroll, Text of Two Columns) and Their Parallels and Possible Sources," The Qumran Chronicle, 8.3/4, 193-213.
Tantlevskij I. R. (1999) "Etymology of 'Essenes' in the Light of Qumran Messianic Expectation," The Qumran Chronicle, 8.3, 195-212.
Tantlevskij I. R. (2003) "The Wisdom of Solomon, the Therapeutae, and the Dead Sea Scrolls," The Qumran Chronicle, 11.1/4, 107-115.
Tantlevskij I. R. (2004) "Melchizedek Redivivus in Qumran: Some Peculiarities of Messianic Ideas and Elements of Mysticism in the Dead Sea Scrolls," The Qumran Chronicle. 12.1 (Special issue).
Tantlevskij, I. R. (2012) Zagadki rukopisej Mertvogo morja. Istorija i uchenije obschiny Qumra-na [Riddles of the Dead Sea Scrolls. History and Teaching of the Qumran Community]. Saint-Petersburg (in Russian).
Tantlevskij, I. R. (2013a) Istorija Izrailja iIudei do 70 g. n. e. [History of Israel and Judaea up to 70 B.C.E.]. Saint-Petersburg (in Russian).
Tantlevskij, I. R. (2013b) "Fatalizm essejev" ["The Essenes' Fatalism"], Vestnik Russkoy Chris-tianskoy Gumanitarnoy Academii (RChGA) 14.3, 316-324 (in Russian with an English summary).
Tantlevskij I. R., Svetlov R.V. (2014a) "Predestination and Essenism," EXOAH (Schole), 8.1, 50-53.
Tantlevskij, I. R.; Svetlov R. V. (2014b) " 'Esseji как pythagorejtsy': predestinatsija v pythagore-jstve, platonizme i qumranskoj theologii" [" 'Essenes as Pythagoreans' ": Predestination in Pythagoreanism, Platonism and the Qumran Theology], EXOAH (Schole) 8.1. 54-66 (in Russian with an English summary).
Tantlevskij, I. R. (2014c) Etymology of the Nickname Iskariot(h) ('1акар1ш8/'1акар1штп^): the "One Who Saw a Sign" (Л1К(')-|рО(К) / Л1К(')-|рО\ ('i)sqar(i)'ot / yisqar(i)'ot) or the "One Who Slandered/Betrayed a Sign" (Л1К(')-|р^(К) / Л1К(')-|р^\ ('i)sqar(i)'ot / yisqar(i)'ot)?,ЕХОЛН(Schole) 8.2, 545-548.
Tantlevskij, I. R. (2014d) " 'Kogda Bog porodiy Messiju s nimi': Ideja rozdenija Messii Izrailja v lone Qumranskoj obschiny "[" 'When [God] Begets the Messiah with Them.': The Idea of the Messiah of Israel Birth in the Bosom of the Qumran Community "]," Vestnik LGU im. A. S. Pushkina, 93-99 (in Russian).
Tantlevskij, I. R. (2014e) "Optimism Ecclesiasta" ["Optimism of Ecclesiastes"], Voprosy Filosofii 11, 137-148.
Tantlevskij, I. R. (2015) "Fragment Blagoslovenija Jakova Byt. 49:10 i ego interpretacija v Qum-rane: implicitnaja allegorija organa muzskoj syly v religiozno-politicheskoj deklaracii [The Fragment of Jacob's Blessing Gen. 49:10 and Its Interpretation in Qumran: Implicit Allegory of the Organ of Man's Power in a Religious-Political Declaration], Vestnik Russkoy Christianskoy Gumanitarnoy Academii (RCHGA) 16. 4 (in Russian with an English summary).
Taylor, J. E. (2010) "The Name "Iskarioth" (Iscariot),"Journal of Biblical Literature 129.2, 363-383.
Toorn, van der K. (1996) Family Religion in Babylonia, Syria and Israel: Continuity and Change in the Forms of Religious Life. Leiden.
VanderKam, J., Flint, P. (2002) The Meaning of the Dead Sea Scrolls. Their Significance for Understanding the Bible, Judaism, Jesus, and Christianity. Foreword by E. Tov. New York.
Wise, M. (1993) "4QMMT and the Sadducees: a Look at a Recent Theory," The Qumran Chronicle, 3.1/3, 71-74.
Wise, M. (2000) "D'Vra 'газ A Study of 4Q49lc, 4Q47lb, 4Q427 7 and 1QHA 25:35-26:10," Dead Sea Discoveries, 7.3, 173-219.
