CC BY
0
UDK 004.031.42
Pshychenko D.
HSE, associate professor National Research University Higher School of Economics
Moscow, Russia
EVALUATION OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF IMPLEMENTING AI-BASED CRM SYSTEMS
Annotation
This paper evaluates the effectiveness of AI-based Customer Relationship Management (CRM) systems compared to traditional CRM systems. It examines the impact of AI integration on business operations, focusing on automation and personalization. A comparative analysis highlights significant advantages of AI-CRM systems in terms of customer satisfaction and operational efficiency. The study also addresses challenges, including high implementation costs and data security issues, emphasizing the need for robust strategies to maximize the benefits of AI-CRM.
Keywords
AI-based CRM, Customer Relationship Management, automation, personalization, predictive analytics, data security, operational efficiency.
Introduction
Customer Relationship Management (CRM) systems have become integral to modern business operations, enabling organizations to systematically manage interactions with their clientele. Traditionally, these systems have provided businesses with tools to streamline processes, enhance service quality, and foster long-term relationships. However, as technological advancements accelerate, the integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) into CRM systems has emerged as a transformative force, promising to revolutionize the way companies interact with their audience.
The significance of AI in modern business practices is profound. AI-driven CRM systems employ machine learning, natural language processing, and predictive analytics to deliver unprecedented levels of automation, personalization, and efficiency. These advanced capabilities enable businesses to anticipate customer needs, customize marketing efforts, and enhance overall customer satisfaction. AI-based CRM systems are increasingly perceived as superior to their traditional counterparts.
This paper aims to evaluate the effectiveness of AI-based CRM systems compared to traditional CRM systems through a comparative analysis.
Main part
CRM technology is a rapidly evolving and promising field, continuously advancing to enhance business operations and customer interactions. According to researchers' forecasts, the CRM software market size is expected to reach USD 88.19 billion by 2024 [1]. It is projected that the annual growth rate will be 10.59%, resulting in a market volume of USD 131.90 billion by 2028. CRM technology is particularly in demand in the retail sector (Fig. 1).
_ 8.0% ^Hi
Business Services
__Manufacturing
Technology Banking/Insurance/Finance
Figure 1 - CRM system usage by industry sector Source: developed by the author
According to research, 91% of companies with more than 11 employees use CRM systems. The average expenditure per employee in the CRM software market is anticipated to be USD 25.14 in 2024 [2].
Traditional CRM systems, which have been foundational in business operations, are defined as integrated software solutions designed to facilitate the management of a company's interactions with current and potential customers. These systems encompass a range of components including contact management, sales management, marketing automation, and customer service and support.
The historical development of CRM systems dates back to the late 1980s and early 1990s, originating from the need to manage and analyze large volumes of customer data more effectively. Early CRM solutions were primarily contact management systems that stored customer information in a digital format. As businesses recognized the value of these systems, CRM evolved to include features such as sales force automation and marketing automation [3]. The late 1990s and early 2000s saw the advent of cloud-based CRM solutions, which significantly reduced the costs and complexities associated with on-premise installations. This period also marked the widespread adoption of CRM systems across various industries, driven by the increasing emphasis on customer-centric business strategies.
Industries across various sectors employ CRM systems to streamline processes, automate routine tasks, and provide comprehensive insights into customer behaviors and preferences. These systems facilitate better communication within organizations, improve customer satisfaction, and support strategic marketing and sales efforts. Table 1 presents the advantages and disadvantages of implementing traditional CRM systems.
Table 1
Advantages and disadvantages of implementing traditional CRM systems [4, 5]
Aspect Advantages Disadvantages Examples
Centralization Provides a unified view of customer interactions across departments. Reliance on manual data entry, which can be time-consuming and error-prone. Access to comprehensive customer profiles; inconsistent data due to human error.
Coordination Facilitates better teamwork within the organization. Limited analytical capabilities. Enhanced internal communication; insufficient insights for complex decision-making.
Automation Automates data entry, scheduling, and follow-ups. Cumbersome user interface. Employees focus on strategic activities; low user adoption due to complexity.
Insights Enables data-driven decision-making Challenges in integrating with other systems Detailed performance and sales reports; incompatibility with emerging digital ecosystems
Customer satisfaction Streamlines operations to improve customer experiences. Scalability issues. Faster response times and personalized services; increased costs and reduced performance.
Historical data Maintains extensive records of customer interactions. High implementation and maintenance costs. Analysis of long-term customer behavior; significant financial investment required.
Source: developed by the author
Traditional CRM systems have significantly influenced the management of customer relationships by providing centralized information, enhancing organizational coordination, automating routine processes, and enabling data-driven decision-making.
Caterpillar Inc., a leading American manufacturer of construction and mining equipment, uses traditional CRM systems to manage customer relationships and support sales operations effectively. These systems enable the tracking of customer interactions, potential buyers, and data analysis for better understanding market needs. CRM tools help forecast sales trends and collect customer feedback, essential for product development and enhancing customer satisfaction. This comprehensive approach ensures Caterpillar remains competitive in the heavy equipment market.
The use of CRM systems has significantly contributed to Caterpillar's success. For example, their service strategy aims to reach $28 billion in sales by 2026, utilizing data from over 1.5 million connected devices to optimize operations and prevent unplanned downtime. In 2023, the company added more than 100,000 new customers to its online channel, exceeding its goal of increasing dealer parts sales by 50% [6].
Boeing, one of the largest aerospace manufacturers in the world, employs traditional CRM systems to manage their extensive client base, which includes airlines, government agencies, and defense contractors. By leveraging CRM tools, Boeing can maintain comprehensive records of customer interactions, track sales opportunities, and manage after-sales service. This systematic approach helps Boeing streamline their sales processes, provide personalized service, and enhance customer satisfaction. For instance, in 2023, Boeing's commercial backlog increased by 23%, reflecting the efficient management of sales and customer relationships facilitated by their CRM system [7]. Boeing's investments in digital tools and data analytics, supported by CRM, have enabled better coordination across their 11,000 suppliers worldwide, enhancing operational efficiency and customer service quality.
Despite these benefits, traditional CRM systems face challenges such as the need for manual data entry, limited advanced analytical capabilities, complex user interfaces, issues with scalability, and high costs of implementation and maintenance. To sustain their competitive edge, businesses must address these limitations by adopting and integrating advanced technologies that enhance the functionality and efficiency of CRM systems.
AI-based CRM system represent an advanced iteration of traditional CRM systems, integrating AI technologies to enhance and automate various aspects of CRM. These systems utilize components such as machine learning, natural language processing (NLP), predictive analytics, and data mining to provide more sophisticated insights and functionalities. The core components of AI-based CRM systems include automated customer service, personalized marketing, sales forecasting, customer behavior analysis, and sentiment analysis. These advanced features enable businesses to predict customer needs, personalize interactions at scale, and automate repetitive tasks with higher accuracy and efficiency.
The development of AI-based CRM systems has been driven by the rapid advancements in AI and machine learning technologies. Initially, CRM systems focused primarily on data storage and basic analytics. However, as AI technologies evolved, they began to be integrated into CRM systems to enhance data processing capabilities and provide more actionable insights. The adoption of AI-based CRM systems has accelerated in recent years due to their ability to significantly improve customer experience and operational efficiency. Companies across various industries have recognized the value of AI in CRM, leading to widespread adoption and continuous innovation in this field. The increasing popularity of AI-based CRM systems is particularly evident in the United States. As shown in Figure 2, the interest in CRM AI has seen a significant rise over recent years.
75 50 25 0
2015-09 2016-09 2017-09 201S-09 2019-09 2020-09 2021-09 2022-09 2023-09
Figure 2 - Popularity of CRM AI in the USA, % [8] Source: developed by the author
This trend underscores the growing recognition of the benefits that AI can bring to CRM systems. The integration of natural language processing enables AI-based CRM systems to understand and respond to customer inquiries in real-time, providing a more seamless and efficient customer service experience. The continuous improvement in AI algorithms ensures that these systems become more accurate and effective over time, further solidifying their role in modern business practices. Despite the numerous advantages of AI-based CRM systems, they are not without challenges (table 2).
Table 2
Advantages and disadvantages of implementing AI-based CRM systems [9]
Aspect Advantages Disadvantages Examples
Personalization Offers highly personalized Complex and costly Tailored marketing strategies;
customer experiences. implementation. significant investment required.
Automation Automates routine tasks Data privacy and security Automated data entry and
with high accuracy. concerns. customer follow-ups.
Real-time customer service Provides real-time responses Requires continuous updates Efficient handling of customer
through natural language and maintenance. inquiries; ongoing AI algorithm
processing. improvements.
Predictive analytics Enables proactive Potential for biases in AI Sales forecasting and customer
engagement by anticipating algorithms. behavior prediction; ensuring
customer needs. fairness in AI models.
Efficiency Enhances operational High initial investment and Streamlined operations; extensive
efficiency and frees up training costs. training for staff.
employee time.
Data insights Provides deep insights Integration challenges with Detailed customer behavior
through advanced data existing systems. analysis; compatibility with legacy
analysis. systems.
Source: developed by the author
AI-based CRM systems have revolutionized CRM. Freeport-McMoRan, a prominent mining company based in the United States, employs AI-based CRM systems to enhance their operations and customer relationships. By integrating AI with their CRM tools, Freeport-McMoRan can analyze real-time data, which significantly lowers operating costs and improves decision-making efficiency. This system allows them to predict maintenance needs and optimize the performance of their equipment. The CRM's AI capabilities have enabled Freeport-McMoRan to withstand economic fluctuations and commodity price volatility, ensuring consistent operational efficiency and customer satisfaction.
The use of AI-based CRM systems has had a measurable impact on Freeport-McMoRan's operational success. According to their 2023 Annual Report on Sustainability, the company reported a 15% reduction in operating costs due to enhanced predictive maintenance capabilities provided by AI integration. Additionally, these systems contributed to a 10% increase in productivity across their mining operations [10].
Newmont Corporation, a leading entity in the mining sector, employs AI-driven CRM systems to enhance their management of client relationships and optimize operational workflows. The implementation of AI-based CRM systems has substantially improved Newmont's operational efficiency and financial performance. According to their 2023 Annual Report, Newmont achieved a 12% reduction in operational costs and a 15% increase in productivity by utilizing AI for data analysis and process automation [11]. The report also highlights that AI-driven insights from CRM systems contributed to a 10% improvement in customer satisfaction scores, underscoring the effectiveness of personalized customer interactions and streamlined service delivery.
While AI-based CRM systems offer numerous benefits, including improved customer experiences and operational efficiencies, they also present challenges such as high implementation costs and data security concerns. Addressing these challenges is crucial for businesses to fully leverage the potential of AI in CRM. Effective strategies include investing in robust cybersecurity measures, ensuring compliance with data protection regulations, and providing thorough training for employees on the use of new technologies. Additionally, businesses should conduct a cost-benefit analysis to assess the return on investment and scalability of AI-based CRM systems, ensuring that the implementation aligns with their long-term strategic goals. Comparative analysis of traditional and AI-based CRM systems
The comparative analysis of traditional and AI-based CRM systems reveals significant differences in their impact on business operations and CRM. Traditional CRM systems have long provided businesses with tools for managing customer interactions and data through manual processes and predefined workflows. In contrast, AI-based CRM systems leverage advanced technologies such as machine learning and natural language processing to offer more sophisticated and automated solutions. The key distinctions between traditional and AI-based CRM systems are summarized in table 3.
Table 3
Comparative analysis of traditional and AI-based CRM systems [12,13]
Criteria Traditional CRM Systems AI-based CRM Systems
Efficiency Manual data entry and predefined workflows; moderate efficiency. Automated data processing and machine learning; high efficiency.
Customer satisfaction Consistent but limited personalization; depends on manual input. High personalization through predictive analytics and NLP; enhanced customer satisfaction.
Cost Lower initial investment but higher ongoing labor costs. High initial investment but lower long-term operational costs due to automation.
Impact on business performance Moderate improvement in business operations; depends on user adoption and data accuracy. Significant improvement in business operations; proactive engagement and data-driven decisions.
Technical aspects Relies on manual updates and predefined scripts; limited flexibility. Requires continuous updates and advanced algorithms; high adaptability and continuous improvement.
Ethics and privacy Standard data security measures; manual handling may reduce privacy risks. Heightened privacy concerns due to extensive data processing; requires robust security measures and ethical considerations.
Source: developed by the author
From the author's perspective, the comparative analysis reveals that while traditional CRM systems maintain a level of consistency and cost-effectiveness, AI-based CRM systems significantly outperform them in terms of efficiency, personalization, and overall business impact. AI-based systems leverage advanced technologies to provide enhanced customer experiences and operational improvements. Nonetheless, the adoption of AI-based CRM systems entails considerable initial investments and heightened data privacy requirements, necessitating meticulous planning and robust security measures. These distinctions underscore the transformative potential of AI in CRM, alongside the challenges that must be addressed to maximize its advantages.
The future development of AI-based CRM systems will focus on improving the accuracy and reliability of
AI algorithms, enhancing integration with other business processes, and ensuring ethical and transparent use of AI technologies. Advances in deep learning and reinforcement learning are expected to further improve the capabilities of these systems, making them even more adept at understanding and predicting customer needs. Conclusion
The implementation of AI-based CRM systems has demonstrated significant improvements in the efficiency and personalization of customer interactions compared to traditional CRM systems. AI-CRM systems offer automation of routine tasks, a high degree of personalization, and accurate predictions based on big data analytics, leading to enhanced customer satisfaction and operational efficiency. Despite the high initial costs and stringent data security requirements, the benefits of AI-CRM, such as reduced operational costs and increased productivity, make them attractive to modern enterprises. The integration of AI into CRM systems enables companies to adapt to dynamic market conditions and customer needs, providing competitive advantages and contributing to long-term success. References:
1. Customer Relationship Management Software - Worldwide / Statista // URL: https://www.statista.com/outlook/tmo/software/enterprise-software/customer-relationship-management-software/worldwide (date of application: 19.06.2024)
2. Customer Relationship Management Market Size, Share, & Trends Analysis Report, By Component, By Solution, By Deployment, By Enterprise Size, By End Use, And Segment Forecasts, 2024 - 2030 / Grand View Research // URL: https://www.grandviewresearch.com/industry-analysis/customer-relationship-management-crm-market (date of application: 19.06.2024)
3. Bukhtueva I. Enhancing Customer Experience with AI-Powered Personalization Techniques // Innovacionnaya nauka № 4-1, pp. 114-119, 2024
4. Grepan V. THEORETICAL AND PRACTICAL FOUNDATIONS OF SMART CONTRACT VALIDATION // Innovacionnaya nauka. 2024. №3-2/2024. p. 24-28
5. Rane N., Choudhary S., Rane J. Hyper-personalization for enhancing customer loyalty and satisfaction in Customer Relationship Management (CRM) systems //Available at SSRN 4641044. - 2023.
6. Executing Strategy / Caterpillar // URL: https://www.caterpillar.com/en/investors/reports/annual-report/executing-our-strategy.html (date of application: 24.06.2024)
7. The Boeing Company 2023 Annual Report / Boeing // URL: https://s2.q4cdn.com/661678649/ files/ doc_financials/2023/ar/Boeing-2023-Annual-Report.pdf (date of application: 25.06.2024)
8. CRM AI Systems in 2024: In-Depth Guide / AI Multiple Research // URL: https://research.aimultiple.com/crm-ai/ (date of application: 28.06.2024)
9. Ledro C., Nosella A., Dalla Pozza I. Integration of AI in CRM: Challenges and guidelines //Journal of Open Innovation: Technology, Market, and Complexity. - 2023. - T. 9. - №. 4. - C. 100151.
10.2023 Annual report on sustainability / Freeport-McMoRan // URL: https://www.fcx.com/ sites/fcx/files/ documents/sustainability/2023-annual-report-on-sustainability.pdf (date of application: 30.06.2024) 11.2023 Annual report / Newmont // URL: https://s24.q4cdn.com/382246808/files/doc_financials/2023/ar/ newmont-2023-annual-report.pdf (date of application: 30.06.2024)
12.Ledro, C., Nosella, A. and Vinelli, A. (2022), "Artificial intelligence in customer relationship management: literature review and future research directions", Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing, Vol. 37 No. 13, pp. 48-63. https://doi.org/10.1108/JBIM-07-2021-0332
13.Chatterjee, S., Mikalef, P., Khorana, S. et al. Assessing the Implementation of AI Integrated CRM System for B2C Relationship Management: Integrating Contingency Theory and Dynamic Capability View Theory. Inf Syst Front 26, 967-985 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10796-022-10261-w
© Pshychenko D., 2024
