CC BY
44
Protistology 1 (3), 113-119 (2000) February, 2000
Protistology
Colonies of trypanosomatids on agar plates: the tool for differentiation of the species and isolates
Sergei A. Podlipaev and Andrew D. Naumov
Zoological Institute Russian Academy of Sciences, St.Petersburg, Russia
Summary
Trypanosomatids unlike many other protozoans may grow on axenic liquid and solid media providing cultures of high density. It allows to investigate the colonies size and shape polymorphism. In the present study colonies structure was investigated under scanning electron microscopy. The comparison of colony diameter distribution in 5 species of trypanosomatids was also studied. The density of cell packing varies in the colonies of different species. In cultures where the single size class of colonies predominates some selective factors eliminate the cells which could form colonies of certain diameter. Such factor may be connected with a procedure of isolation or with cultivating conditions. All data obtained allow to discriminate various isolates of trypanosomatids by phenotypic characters of the colonies and to use this features in taxonomy of trypanosomatids.
Key words: Trypanosomatidae, insect and plant trypanosomatids, systematics, colonies on solid media
Introduction
Trypanosomatids unlike many other protozoans may grow on axenic liquid and solid media. The high density of the cells in cultures (108-109 cells/ml) allows to use a wide spectrum of biochemical and molecular methods as well as techniques which are rather rarely used in protistology. One of such approaches is the investigation of colonies size and shape polymorphism.
First attempts to use solid media for trypanosomatids cultivation were made in the twenties (Noller, 1917; Nieschulz, 1922, 1924) and then iterated sporadically for limited number of species (Senekjie, 1944; Newton, 1956; Keppel and Janovy, 1977, 1980; Goldberg and Chiari, 1980; Lucic and Nadazdin, 1982; Wittner et al., 1982). The clonal nature of colonies was demonstrated for insect trypanosomatids Crithidia harmosa, Herpetomonas megaseliae and Crithidia oncopelti (Keppel and Janovy, 1977; Haetsky, 1982).
C. harmosa H. megaseliae were found to differ from each other by colonies shape (hemispherical or flattened) and it was proposed that colonies shape may be of a taxonomic value (Keppel, Janovy, 1977). Later the colonies polymorphism has been studied on 8 isolates of trypanosomatids from insects collected in the North-West Russia (Podlipaev, 1985; Podlipaev et al., 1990, 1991). Several distinctive phenotypes were determined as heritable ones: for example hemispherical or amoeba-like
colonies were found to be such characters for Leptomo-nas peterhoffi (Podlipaev, 1985); they remained stable during at least 5 years of cultivation. Some isolates were marked by peculiar set of phenotypes displayed on solid media and characters of their colonies were used for taxo-nomical purposes (Krylov et al., 1985; Podlipaev, 1985; Podlipaev et al., 1990, 1991).
Giant multinuclear cells, described in liquid cultures of insect trypanosomatids (Podlipaev, 1985) have been discovered in colonies of Crithidia oncopelti and Lepto-monas peterhoffi by transmission electron microscopy (Skarlato and Malysheva, 1987; Malysheva and Skarlato, 1989).
Colonies size has never been used for discrimination of trypanosomatids isolates except the case with colonies of Blastocrithidia miridarum that are much bigger than those of Leptomonas rigidus having just different size distribution (Podlipaev et al., 1991).
For Leishmania donovani it was shown that colonies having been initiated from promastigotes are indistinguishable from colonies originated from another life cycle stage
- amastigotes (Keppel and Janovy, 1980). On the contrary, Wallaceina inconstans demonstrates three definite heritable types of colonies, which differ from one another by cell composition (Podlipaev et al., 1990). Cells in different Wallaceina colonies coincide to different stages of Wallaceina life-cycle in the host as well as to different cell morphotypes in culture.
© 2000 by Russia, Protistology.
Colonies seem to serve as a promising tool for delineation of trypanosomatids species and isolates as it was used earlier for numerous microorganisms.
In the present study we investigated colonies characters of new species and isolates of monogenetic trypanosomatids.
Material and methods
List of trypanosomatids is presented in Table 1. Methods of culture isolation and cultivation were described earlier (Haetsky, 1982; Podlipaev, 1985; Podlipaev and Frolov, 1987).
Trypanosomatids from insects were cultured in BHI (Brain Hart Infusion) medium (Difco) with hemin (10 mg/ ml) and 2% of Difco agar for solid medium. Isolates from plants were maintained in Grace’s medium (Gibco) with 10% heat-inactivated fetal calf serum. 10-days colonies were used for analysis.
For scanning electron microscopy colonies were fixed with 2% OsO4 and material was subjected to the critical-
point drying method using acetone/CO2 system. Colonies were coated in platinum with Hitachi 21PC32 apparatus and examined with a Hitachi S570 microscope.
Results and Discussion
The clonal essence of colonies may be noted from the first cells divisions on agar plates (Fig. 1).
When the humidity is high enough for colonies development the flagella of cover cells are moving (Figs 2, 3 ).
Colonies of Leptomonas seymouri show the inner rosette-like structures, differing from those, described earlier (Podlipaev, 1985; Podlipaev and Frolov, 1987) (Fig. 4). These features may be the evidence of the inner structure of colony.
The density of cell packing varies in the colonies of different species - it is high in the Leptomonas sp. P (Fig. 5), somehow lower with the small gaps between the cells in L. peterhoffi (Fig. 6) and the most friable in L. seymouri (Fig. 8).
Table 1. List of trypanosomatids
Name Host Host order and family Place of isolation Comments
Crithidia acantocephali Acanthocephala Hetmiptera: USA Received from
Hanson et McGhee, 1961 femorata Coreidae E. Camargo
Crithidia guilhermei Phaenicia Diptera: Brazil Received from
Soares et al., 1986 cuprina Calliphoridae E. Camargo
Herpetomonas roitmani Ornidia obesa Diptera: Brazil Received from
(Fiorini et al., 1989) Syrphidae E. Camargo
Herpetomonas muscarum Musca domestica Diptera: ? Received from D.
Leidy, 1856 Muscidae Maslov
Leptomonas peterhoffi Nabicula Hemiptera: North-West
Podlipaev, 1985 flavomarginata Nabidae Russia
Leptomonas samueli Zelus Hemiptera: Brazil Received from
Carvalho, 1973 leucogrammus Triatominae E. Camargo
Leptomonas seymouri Dysdercus Hemiptera: USA Received from D.
Wallace, 1977 suturellus Pyrrhocoridae Maslov
Leptomonas rigidus Salda littoralis Hemiptera: North-West
Podlipaev et al., 1991 Saldidae Russia
Leptomonas sp. P Panorpa Mecoptera: North-West Isolated by
communis Panorpidae Russia S. Podlipaev in 1988
Phytomonas serpens 1G Lycopersicon Plantae: Brazil Received from. M.
(Gibbs, 1957) esculentum Solanaceae Dollet
Phytomonas sp. EM1 Euphorbia pinea Plantae: France Received from. M.
Euphorbiaceae Dollet
Phytomonas sp. Hart1 Cocos nucifera Plantae: French Received from. M.
Palmaceae Guiana Dollet
Phytomonas sp. Mz1 Elais guinensis Plantae: Colombia Received from. M.
Palmaceae Dollet
Fig. 1. Cells of Leptomonas peterhoffi on agar plate, 24 hours after inoculation. Giemsa staining. Scale bar: 1Q цш. Figs 2, 3. Border of Blastocrithidia gerricola alive Ю-days colonies. Arrow - moving flagella. Scale bar: 2Q цш. Fig. 4. Alive Leptomonas seymoury 1Q-days colonies with inner rosette-like structures. Scale bar: Q.1 mm.
At the surface of the colonies of Leptomonas sp. P the rare free flagella take place, their number is considerably higher in L. peterhoffi and many of them extend above the colony surface (Fig. 7). In L. seymouri the majority of the cells retains typical promastigote form and the upper covering layer is not expressed in the colony (Fig. 8).
The upper cells in the colonies of L. peterhoffi form the dense covering layer, the inner cells are packed crumbly, many of them bearing the free flagellum (Figs 9, iQ).
Till now the colonies polymorphism of about 15 species and isolates of insect trypanosomatids has been investigated (Keppel and Janovy, 1977; Krylov et al., 1985; Podlipaev, 1985; Podlipaev et al., 199Q, 1991). Newly
investigated cultures (Leptomonas samueli, L. seymouri, Herpetomonas muscarum, H. roitmani, Crithidia acanthocephali and C. guilhermei) show the same spectrum of colony phenotypes as it was mentioned before: 1) hemispherical large; 2) hemispherical small; 3) amoebalike and 4) branched (Podlipaev, 1985; Podlipaev et al., 1991). Plant trypanosomatids (Phytomonas serpens 1G; Phytomonas sp. EM1; Phytomonas sp. Harti and Phytomonas sp. Mzi) display monomorphic hemispherical colonies only.
Besides the discrete character of the form, trypanosomatid colonies may differ by their size. The comparison of colony diameter distribution in 5 species of
Fig. 5. Ю-days colony of Leptomonas sp. P on agar plate (AP), scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Scale bar: 1Q цш. Figs 6, 7. Upper surface of Leptomonas peterhoffi Ю-days colonies (SEM). F - free flagella. Scale bar: 1Q цш.
Fig. 8. Upper surface of Leptomonas seymoury 1Q-days colonies (SEM). F - free flagella. Scale bar: 1Q цш.
trypanosomatids shows that in Leptomonas rigidus and Crithidia guilhermei the mode at the area of Q.1-Q.3 шш can be noticed, whereas in Crithidia acantocephali and Leptomonas seymouri it may be found at Q.4-Q.6 шш area.
Herpetomonas muscarum has bimodal distribution of this size parameter, modes lying at the same areas (Fig. 11). The bimodal distribution of colony size in H. muscarum as well as the difference of average diameter of other spe-
Fig. 9. Crack of the Leptomonas peterhoffi Ю-days colony border (SEM). CC - cover cells. F - free flagella. Scale bar: 1Q цш. Fig. 10. Inner cells in Leptomonas peterhoffi 1Q-days colony (SEM). F - free flagella. Scale bar: 1Q цш.
cies mentioned above are of good statistical significance at the confidence level P<0.01.
The described distribution of colony size remains stable during at least two years of cultivation. Thus we can confirm that in the species studied there are two heritable phenotypes differing by sizes of colonies. In H. muscarum colonies of both types are phenotypically expressed, while in other species under discussion - only one of them. It may be considered, therefore, that in cultures, where the single size class predominates some selective factors eliminate cells which could form colonies of certain diameter. Such factor may be connected with a procedure of isolation or with cultivating condi-
tions. Colony size distribution in C. guilhermei and L. rigidus possesses a positive asymmetry, therefore these cultures have enough cells, which can form rather big colonies. It may be suggested that in the case of selection the number of such cells may increase and the second mode of size distribution could be obtained. In this connection it is worth saying that cultures with small colonies predominance were isolated in 1986 (Crithidia quilhermei) in Brazil (Soares et al., 1986) and in 1987 (Leptomonas rigidus) in North Russia (Podlipaev et al., 1991) - in about 2Q years after cultures of Crithidia acantocephali (Hanson and McGhee, 1961) and L. seymouri (Guttman, 1966; Wallace, 1977) were obtained.
£
15
1
£
Diameter of colonies, mm Fig. 11. Colony diameter distribution in 5 species of trypanosomatids from insects.
The procedure of trypanosomatids isolation from a host to culture and the cultivation itself might perform a selective choice of some certain genotypes in parasite population. One of the evidences of such selection is the decreasing number of amoeba-like colonies (Podlipaev, 1985) in culture of Leptomonaspeterhoffi. They amounted 15 - 20% of the total colonies number just after culture isolation and presented single colonies per Petri dish in 5 years of laboratory cultivation. Therefore laboratory cultures generally do not precisely correspond to natural infection and may reflect the structure of real parasite population rather incorrectly. The latter especially refers to classical cultures (like Crithidia oncopelti and C. fasciculata) isolated many years ago.
In the case described above we have a simple system of measure characters which seems to be promising for genetic researches of trypanosomatids.
All data obtained allow to discriminate various isolates of trypanosomatids by phenotypic characters of the colonies and to use this features in taxonomy of trypanosomatids.
Acknowledgements
We thank E. Camargo (University Sao Paulo, Brazil)
for Crithidia acanthocephali, C. quilhermei, Herpetomo-
nas roitmani and Leptomonas samueli cultures; M. Dollet (CIRAD, Montpellier, France) for plant trypanosomatids isolates and D. Maslov (University California, Riverside, USA) for Herpetomonas muscarum and L. seymouri. This work was supported by Russian Foundation of Basic Research (Grant 99-04-49-572).
References
Goldberg S. and Chiari E. 1980. Growth and isolation of single colonies of Trypanosoma cruzi on solid medium. J. Parasitol. 66, 677-679.
Guttman H.N. 1966. First defined media for Leptomonas spp. from insects. J. Protozoology. 13, 3, 390-392.
Haetsky A.S. 1982. Cloning of a flagellate Crithidia oncopelti on a solid medium of independent content without hemin. Tsitologiya. 24, 2, 211-314 (in Russian with English summary).
Hanson W.L. and McGhee R.B. 1961. The biology and morphology of Crithidia acantocephali n.sp., Leptomonas leptoglossi n.sp. and Blastocrithidia euchisti n.sp. J. Protozool. 8, 200-204.
Keppel A.D. and Janovy J. 1977. Herpetomonas megaseliae and Crithidia harmosa: growth on blood-agar plates. J. Parasitol. 63, 879-882.
Keppel A.D. and Janovy J. i9S0. Morphology of Leish-mania donovani colonies growth on blood-agar plates. J. Parasitol. бб, S49-S5i.
Krylov M.V., Podlipaev S.A., Hayetsky A.S., Belova L.M., Frolov A.O. and Nijazbekova B.Y. i9S5. Is only one species present in a culture of Crithidia oncopelti (Kinetoplastida, Trypanosomatidae?). Zool. Zhurn. б4, 2, Іб5-І7І (in Russian with English summary).
Lucic N. and Nadazdin M. i9S2. Beobachtungen wahrend der Kultivierung von Crithidia luciliae auf festen und flussigen Nahrboden. Arztl. Lab. 2S, 39І-394.
Malysheva M.N. and Skarlato S.O. i9S9. Studies on the ultrastructural organization of Leptomonas peterhoffi (Trypanosomatidae) grown on liquid and solid media. Tsitologiya. 3І, 3, 2б7-272 (in Russian with English summary).
Newton B.A. І95б. A synthetic growth medium for the trypanosomatid flagellate Strigomonas (Herpetomo-nas) oncopelti. Nature. І77, 279-2S0.
Nieschulz O. І922. Unsere bis heringen Kenntnisse von der Flagellatenkrankheit der Pflanzen. Zeit. Pflanzenkrankheiten. 32, i02-i0S.
Nieschulz O. І924. Zur morphologie der Kulturformen einer Herpetomonas aus Euphorbia cereiformis. Zentralblt Bakt. 2 Abt. бІ, 3ІІ-3Іб.
Noller W. І9І7. Blut- und Insektenflagellaten-zuchtung auf Platten. Arch. Schiffs. Tropen. Hyg. 2І, 53-94.
Podlipaev S.A. i9S5. New species of lower trypanosomatids from Heteroptera families Gerridae and Nabidae: stages of their life cycles in nature and
in the laboratory. Proc. Zoological Inst. Leningrad. І29, 35-47 (in Russian with English summary).
Podlipaev S.A. and Frolov A.O. i9S7. Description and laboratory cultivation of Blastocrithidia miridarum sp. n. (Mastigophora: Trypanosomatidae). Parasitologiya. 2І, 4, 545-552 (in Russian with English summary).
Podlipaev S.A., Frolov A.O. and Kolesnikov A.A. І990. Proteomonas inconstans n.gen., n.sp. (Kinetoplastida: Trypanosomatidae), a parasite of the bug Calocoris sexguttatus (Hemiptera: Miridae). Parasitologiya. 24, 4, 339-345 (in Russian with English summary).
Podlipaev S.A., Malysheva M.N. and Kolesnikov A.A. І99І. Leptomonas rigidus sp. n. (Trypanosomatidae)
- a parasite of Salda littoralis L. Hemiptera: Heteroptera. Acta Protozoologica. 30, І2І-І27.
Senekjie R. І944. American visceral leishmaniasis - the etiological agent. J. Parasitol. 30, 303-30S.
Skarlato S.O. and Malysheva M.N. i9S7. Ultrastructure of giant multinucleate cells of the parasitic flagellate Crithidia oncopelti (Kinetoplastida). Tsitologiya. 29, І2, І337-І342. (in Russian with English summary).
Soares M.J. Brazil R.P., Tanuri A., and de Souza W. 19S6. Some ultrastructural aspects of Crithidia guilhermei n. sp. isolated from Phaenicia cuprina (Diptera: Cal-liphoridae). Can. J. Zool. б4, 2S37-2S42.
Wallace F.G. І977. Leptomonas seymouri sp.n. from the cotton stainer Dysdercus suturellus. J. Protozool. 24, 4S3-4S4.
Wittner M., Squillante L., Nadler J. and Tanowitz H.B. 19S2. Trypanosoma cruzi: colony formation and clonal growth in agar. Exp. Parasitol. 53, 255-2б1.
Address for correspondence: S.A.Podlipaev. Zoological Institute Russian Academy of Sciences, 199034, St. Petersburg, Russia. E-mail [email protected].
The manuscript is presented by A.A.Dobrovolskij
